Russia-Ukraine War Politics Thread Mk. 2

Corruption on the homefront?
At one point this year, about $980 million in weapons contracts had missed their delivery dates, according to government figures, and some prepayments for weapons had vanished into oversees accounts of weapons dealers, according to reports made to Parliament. Though precise details have not emerged, the irregularities suggest that procurement officials in the ministry did not vet suppliers, or allowed weapons dealers to walk off with money without delivering the armaments.
a billion dollars confirmed as missing. quite a hit.
 
Corruption on the homefront?
Unfortunately as Minister of Defense the buck stops with him. He made several questionable appointments. But his friendship with the UK and USA liason allowed him to avoid removal the first time. This is the second time. Zelensky has no choice now.

Well more details on the Pskov attack. It turns out the Russians were using an original production batch, non-modernized ZSU 23-4 as air security. . . I've only seen those in museums and Moscow Victory Day parades. Specifically as gate guardians at the Yorkshire RAF museum. That thing has no business in modern AAA batteries. No effort was made to protect the planes because Pskov was considered too far away from Ukraine. The crews were getting drunk around a campfire cooking their rations. Russians. The commitment to the Gopnik stereotype is morbidly fascinating.
 
Unfortunately as Minister of Defense the buck stops with him. He made several questionable appointments. But his friendship with the UK and USA liason allowed him to avoid removal the first time. This is the second time. Zelensky has no choice now.
I wonder how much of this unaccounted for money ended up in the hand of UK and USA oligarchs like the biden crime family.

We already know of at least 10 million dollars of ukraine money went to the bidens via burisma bribery.

And that they murdered the burisma accountant. And then later on his wife approached the FBI claiming to having the info on exactly where the bidens are keeping the bribe money, and then she too was murdered.
 
I wonder how much of this unaccounted for money ended up in the hand of UK and USA oligarchs like the biden crime family.
Wasn't that Ukrainian crypto guy arrested for fraud after taking the aid money sent to Ukraine, putting it into his crypto, and laundering it into a bunch of democrat election campaigns?
 
Most of the stuff that he has been called out for does not invovle US money...
 


The UN being useless again.

Also, good line here "we don't have a choice between victory and capitulation. We have a choice between winning and extinction."

For Ukraine this is a war that will end either in 'victory or extinction' in the words of their own people.

If some one does not support aiding Ukraine against Russia, they support what Ukrainian's see as their extinction as a people.

I’m sorry but this is nonsense and cheapens the word genocide into a so what.

Genocide is the total extinction of a group. Occupation and losing your national independence and freedom are not genocide.
 
Unfortunately as Minister of Defense the buck stops with him. He made several questionable appointments. But his friendship with the UK and USA liason allowed him to avoid removal the first time. This is the second time. Zelensky has no choice now.

Well the plagiarized article (Dnyuz is an Armenian website that plagiarizes and uses poorly sourced content) seemed to state it had little to do with foreign liaisons in the first place but its a reduced variety of the corruption that has always occurred in Ukraine and that part of the world. The current administration has been surprisingly admirable in removing loyal and dedicated supporters of Zelensky however over these issues when it could've potentially been easily avoided. It occurred with Arestoyvych and that wasn't even corruption related as much as him just using improper speech.

New York Times said:
Government officials acknowledge that some military contracts failed to produce weaponry or ammunition, and that some money has vanished. But they say that most of the problems arose in the chaotic early months of the invasion last year and have since been remedied.

As minister of defense, Reznikov viewed his principal job as rallying allies to provide weaponry. He was not directly responsible for the day-to-day running of the war and his dismissal is not seen as linked to the slow progress of Ukraine's counteroffensive.

Military spending now accounts for nearly half of Ukraine's national budget, and the reports of contracting scandals point to a shift in the sources of public corruption.

Before the full-scale invasion, the primary source of embezzlement had been poorly run state companies, of which there were more than 3,000 on the government's balance sheet. Money was siphoned off through myriad schemes by wealthy insiders, while the national budget, propped up by foreign aid, absorbed the losses.

Anti-corruption groups say the huge influxes of funds to support the war has prompted them to shift their focus to military spending.

Ukrainian investigative journalists have highlighted overpayment for basic supplies for the army, like eggs for 17 hryvnia, or 47 cents, each — far above prevailing prices, according to a report in Dzerkalo Tyzhnia, a Ukrainian newspaper. Canned beans were bought from Turkey at more than the price for the same cans in Ukrainian supermarkets, the newspaper reported, even though the military would be expected to purchase at less than retail prices.

The ministry also bought thousands of coats that turned out to be insufficiently insulated for Ukraine's bitter winters.

Overcharging of sundry goods (which is actually pretty common with many governments) as well as more exceptional things like bribes to avoid the draft and the contracts for weapons/munitions from state-run companies and focused on the early months of the War.

The article also talks about how the current Administration has been tackling corruption, and to such an extent that it has caused some dismay locally. But as the article itself states, folks overcharging for eggs or accepting bribes for draft evasion were criminally charged or whatever.
I wonder how much of this unaccounted for money ended up in the hand of UK and USA oligarchs like the biden crime family.

Very little apparently in regards to this articles revelation as right below the paragraph you quoted.

New York Times said:
The public revelations of mismanagement so far have not directly touched foreign weapons transferred to the Ukrainian army, or Western aid money, but they are nonetheless piercing the sense of unquestioning support for the government that Ukrainians had exhibited throughout the first year of Russia's full-scale invasion.
 
I’m sorry but this is nonsense and cheapens the word genocide into a so what.

Genocide is the total extinction of a group. Occupation and losing your national independence and freedom are not genocide.
I agree that the term "cultural genocide" would be more appropriate, though Russia would probably go further than this, outright attempting heavy handed assimilation into Russian culture and national identity to destroy Ukrainians as a nationality.

On the other hand, can the term be that cheapened at this point anyway?
Look at the post 1945 entries. Some aren't that different at all.
 
Cuban Ministry of Foreign Affairs has apparently denounced Russia's recent efforts to recruit Cubans as mercenaries for their special three day Coalition operation to liberate Ukraine. It referenced the Russian backed efforts as "human trafficking for mercenarism or recruitment purposes" and states its working to dismantle the network from Russia that was trying to organize these efforts.



Early in July it was reported that Cuban mercenaries were being offered $2,000 a month to serve in the Russian military operations in Ukraine and also reports they were to gain Russian citizenship as a reward as well.

This could be related to their efforts to attract Central Asians and other former SSR citizens from countries like Kazakhstan and Armenia to serve in the Russian military operations in Ukraine in exchange for citizenship as reported by the British Government a few days ago.

 
I agree that the term "cultural genocide" would be more appropriate, though Russia would probably go further than this, outright attempting heavy handed assimilation into Russian culture and national identity to destroy Ukrainians as a nationality.

On the other hand, can the term be that cheapened at this point anyway?
Look at the post 1945 entries. Some aren't that different at all.
Can you tell me what differance there is between Russian and Ukrainian culture? It seems hard to tell. Like if the British Empire was reformed, and Canada conqured America. I'd heisitate to call it genocide. What cultural traditions would be removed? I guess the 4th of July would no longer be celebrated. But what else? I mean Ukranians and Russians seem to be about as similar as Americas and Canadians. But you live in that part of the world so you know more about their differances, what are they?
 
Can you tell me what differance there is between Russian and Ukrainian culture? It seems hard to tell.
So it's plain severe ignorance. Separate language, a lot of differences in history and interpretation of it, and if you are interested in "national character" of course people also try to quantify that, for starters Ukrainians and Russians have quite different attitudes towards such major questions like having a strong authoritarian state:
Like if the British Empire was reformed, and Canada conqured America. I'd heisitate to call it genocide.
So you think cultural genocide should have "similar and related cultures are fair game" exception?
Like Germans can't go germanize Poland by force, but Russians can russify it instead? Germans have to satisfy themselves with removing Austria and Switzerland from the map, while the British have to keep their imperial designs to Ireland and Scotland.
This is fucking insane.
What cultural traditions would be removed? I guess the 4th of July would no longer be celebrated. But what else? I mean Ukranians and Russians seem to be about as similar as Americas and Canadians. But you live in that part of the world so you know more about their differances, what are they?
Obviously there is even more difference between Ukrainians and Russians than British and Americans, as the chances a random Ukrainian and random Russian can communicate easily is far lower.

Secondly, Ukraine has a lot of cultural influence from its time under Lithuania, Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth and the Cossack traditions, while at the same time Moscow was Mongol's tribute collector vassal who was going freelance when Mongols weakened, and in turn had taken some characteristics from that, its few centuries we are talking about here.
 
Laura Loomer's most important story below deals with Ukrainian spies at the J6 party and hired to be there by the FBI. This goes way beyond election interference into Treason.




This is massive. You all need to read this.

I have exclusively confirmed that the FBI identified Ukrainian operatives and Neo Nazis who were at the US Capitol on J6 and even questioned J6ers about these Ukrainian spies during interviews with the FBI.

During their private interview with @AmericaShaman , the@FBI asked him how he knew a Ukrainian operative who took a photo with him the day of J6 2021. Chansley didn't know the guy, and FBI confirmed that the Ukrainian Sergai Dybynyn was a Ukrainian spy who is affiliated with the Nazi Azov Battalion.

This means the US Capitol was penetrated by Ukrainian spies and the US Government and FBI have still not arrested these people or made the public aware of foreign penetration. This is an act of war by Ukraine against the United States, and yet the US Government has sent $200 BILLION to Ukraine in the last 2 years.

The CIA is funding a color revolution in the United States via Ukrainian Nazis and American Nazis who are being recruited by the CIA and FBI to fight overseas in the Azov Battalion and then come back to the US to instigate Nazi political movements in a psyop intended to make right wingers look bad.

The reality is, these people are Democrats and Biden supporters and the FBI has been hiding the fact that Ukrainian operatives penetrated the US Capitol on J6 and they have been hiding the fact that they are working with Ukrainian Nazis to instigate violence to subvert the US Government, including actions to impeach President Trump, instigate violence at Charlottesville which was used as Biden's reason for running for President against Trump, and to stage violence at the Capitol on J6.

Now the FBI and CIA are using Ukrainian Nazis to instigate racial division in the US during an election year so that Neo Nazi marches pop up in red states when voters are deciding who to vote for ahead of 2024.

This is a CIA funded domestic terror operation intended to interfere in the U.S. Election and to make sure Donald Trump is never allowed to be President ever again.

This is treason. And everyone involved needs to go to prison.

This might be the biggest story I have ever uncovered.



BREAKING:

Now that I have exposed Ukrainian Nazis working with the CIA and FBI, let me show you how this isn't a one time thing, and let me show you how our government is working with Ukrainian neo Nazis to instigate conflict in America and recruit for White Supremacist movements both domestically and internationally.

On Jan 6th, 2021, a known Ukraine Neo-Nazi spy was identified in front of the U.S. Capitol, and additionally confirmed to be a Ukrainian spy by the FBI in an interview with January 6th Defendant Jacob Chansley @AmericaShaman, also known as the Q-Anon Shaman.

I personally spoke to Jacob, and he confirmed to me that the FBI told him during an interview with him and his lawyer that the person he was pictured with at the Capitol on Jan 6th was in fact "a known Ukrainian spy". The FBI asked Jacob Chansley if he knew the Ukrainian spy. Jacob didn't know who he was, and said the man approached him and asked for a photo.

The FBI knew of a Ukrianian spy outside of the US Capitol on J6, and yet this was NEVER reported or even mentioned to the J6 Committee. This same Ukrainian spy who was identified by the FBI has been identified via facial recognition technology as Sergai Dybynyn, a neo-nazi who works in Ukraine.

Despite the picture with Jacob Chansley being taken at the front door of the U.S. Capitol, the FBI has never placed Sergai Dybynyn on their January 6th most wanted list, and he has not been arrested over J6 like @AmericaShaman was. Jacob Chansley was arrested and incarcerated, and yet Sergai Dybynyn, the U.S.-Backed neo-nazi still runs free with the help of the FBI.

Interestingly enough, Sergei Dybynyn was also once photographed with John McCain and @LindseyGrahamSC.

Is our Government using Ukrainian spies and Neo Nazis to instigate political conflict and falsely accuse Trump supporters of being white supremacists?

Let me remind you that there is also documentation of Ukrainian Nazis being present at the Charlottesville March, which @JoeBiden infamously used to launch his 2020 Presidential campaign by using false claims that Donald Trump said Nazis were "very good people". This lie was used to launch a massive cancel culture campaign aimed at Trump supporters, and it opened the door for the DOJ to accuse Trump supporters of being "white supremacists".

I believe that I have uncovered something massive, and I just happened to be in the right place at the right time this weekend in Altamonte Springs, Florida.

Our government appears to be using Ukrainian Nazis and American Nazis as confidential informants to recruit more Nazis to fight in the Ukraine-Russia war. And by doing so, they are endangering the lives of American Citizens and compromising our national security.





RELATED:


UKRAINIAN NAZIS ARE RECRUITING NAZIS FROM FLORIDA TO FIGHT IN THE UKRAINE WAR

One of the Nazis I caught on camera yesterday who was shouting slurs at me is a guy by the name of Kent McLellan. He goes by the name "Boneface" and his entire face is covered with tattoos.

Kent McLellan is an American neo-Nazi who fought in the Donbass as part of the Nazi Right Sector movement. He then joined Ukraine's Nazi Azov Battalion after Russia launched an attack on Ukraine.

According to one report from 2022, "McLellan received a Ukrainian passport in March of 2022. Kent McLellan is a man who has a swastika tattoo on half of his torso. He has killed civilians, has several convictions in the United States and heads several neo-Nazi associations. This man now has Ukrainian citizenship."

How is this man walking the streets and who is paying for his travel to Ukraine?

A source who reached out to me says they know Boneface and they said he's homeless and is often unemployed.

How is he affording plane tickets to Ukraine to fight Russia, and who paid him? How is he even able to travel freely between the US and Ukraine?

This is insane.

Kent McLellan is a US citizen and he says he lives in Florida. He is also the son of the front man of a Nazi rock band called "Brutal Attack".

F5G7a8pXAAAoxb9


F5G7a8hXMAAa20W


F5G7a8hXAAArveN

Kent " Boneface" McLellan was arrested by the FBI in Florida for domestic terrorism in May of 2012. The FBI said he and others were "preparing a terrorist act against national minorities in Florida."

He then fled to Ukraine to join Right Sector (a creation of the CIA) in 2014. In 2022, he returned to Ukraine and was reportedly deported.

There is no way you get away with all of that after being arrested by the FBI unless you are some type of FBI informant.





WATCH: Here is another video of Florida Nazi Kent "Boneface" McLellan saying the CIA helped him get to Ukraine years ago to fight alongside "Right Sector", a Ukrainian Neo Nazi group that was propped up by the CIA in an effort to combat Russia.

He was one of the Nazis I spotted yesterday in Altamonte Springs, FL where he was waving a swastika flag, doing Roman salutes and saying "heil Hitler", and shouting anti-Jewish slurs at me alongside his fellow Nazi friends.

He was arrested by the FBI in Florida in 2012 for planning what they called an act of domestic terrorism against minorities. He also reportedly served time in for prison for physically assaulting and beating immigrants.

He obtained a Ukrainian passport in 2022.

How is he walking the streets of Florida?

Is he still working with the CIA and FBI?

Also, why is @RonDeSantis allowing for the CIA to plant Nazis all over Florida in staged appearances which are then used by the media to falsely accuse Right wingers of being Nazis?

This guy is a Democrat deep state operative who is on video admitting that the CIA Helped him get to Ukraine and join a Nazi militia.






WATCH:

I am only posting this because I believe it's news worthy, and I am an investigative journalist.

The Nazi rally in Altamonte Springs, FL today was organized by Goyim Defense League (GDL) and its founder Jon Minadeo. I had no idea this was even taking place until I was driving back from the hair salon in Altamonte where I have been getting my hair done for over an entire year, and as I was getting ready to turn onto the highway, I saw a cluster of about 50 masked men carrying SWASTIKA FLAGS, doing Roman Salutes, and shouting "heil Hitler".

When I pulled my car over to record, they shouted "look it's Laura Jewmer" and they proceeded to shout chants of "Jigsaw Jew", "white power" and "go home to Israel K*ke" in my face. One of them even told me that I would "get the oven too".

Very vitriolic and irrational behavior. But, it is moments like this that remind us that this is what free speech was created for.

Speech you disagree with is also free speech. And while I certainly don't enjoy the way I was treated today while driving home from an afternoon of errands and getting my hair done, it's a reminder that free speech must be for everyone, or else we have free speech for no one.

I personally find GDL to be reprehensible. This is not the first time GDL has harassed me. In March when I was outside of the @RonDeSantis book signing, GDL founder Jon Minadeo followed me to my car and shouted anti/Jewish slurs at me and proceeded to knock on my car window until I drove away. I am a free speech absolutist, and I am also a US citizen. I am not from Israel, further proving how irrational GDL is.

However, they still have a right to free speech and freedom of association, even if they are irrational Nazi trolls (and possibly even Feds).




Jon Minadeo (blue glasses) is the head of Goyim Defense League (GDL), the group that held the Nazi rally in the Orlando, FL area today and by 1-4 in Altamonte Springs. He goes by "Handsome Truth" on social media.

While I was walking back to my car after I pulled over to film the shocking pro-Nazi rally, he told me the Holocaust was a hoax, and he confronted me on video, calling me a "tra**y Jew", said "fuck you" and then walked away after shouting "white power" and accusing me of destroying the world simply because I am Jewish.

Mind you, I am a free speech absolutist. This behavior is disgusting. But do you see me calling for him to be arrested or banned? No, you don't. Because I understand the importance of protecting free speech. Even when it's speech like this from actual Nazi and Nazi sympathizers who are attacking me and saying I deserve to be shoved in a gas chamber because I'm Jewish. And yea, that was shouted at me today.




( I tired to link the videos from twitter but can't seem able to figure out how to, so my apologies there)
 
Laura Loomer's most important story below deals with Ukrainian spies at the J6 party and hired to be there by the FBI. This goes way beyond election interference into Treason.










RELATED:


















( I tired to link the videos from twitter but can't seem able to figure out how to, so my apologies there)

Stop spamming this conspiracy bullshit all over the friggin forum like it's something of any value.
Loomer is a well known grifting bullshitter trying to scam donation money out of the right long before anything related to J6 or Ukraine, she is about the opposite of a trustworthy source for anything.

But go on, lose the last bits of credibility larping as antifa and spreading the manure of known grifters to simp for muscovite barbarians.

If anyone had any doubt, she was a massive muscovite simp before coming up with this shit.


And of course official muscovite propagandists support this story, suggesting it was made up in Moscow to begin with.

So shame upon you, muscovite parrot.
 
Last edited:
I’m sorry but this is nonsense and cheapens the word genocide into a so what.

Genocide is the total extinction of a group. Occupation and losing your national independence and freedom are not genocide.
So you want to ignore the mass kidnapping of UA children into Russia, the direct quotes of people in Russia themselves back at the start of the invasion admitting they expected to need 2 gens of occupation to 'Russify' Ukrainians, and the Russian's often saying Ukraine is a country with no right to exist.

I do not always agree with what the UN definition defines as genocide, but I also will not deny Russia has hit multiple checks on the list for 'did they commit genocide' list with their actions in Ukraine.
 
Laura Loomer's most important story below deals with Ukrainian spies at the J6 party and hired to be there by the FBI. This goes way beyond election interference into Treason.










RELATED:


















( I tired to link the videos from twitter but can't seem able to figure out how to, so my apologies there)

Why are you taking that grifter Loomer seriously anymore? Particularly after her stupidity with regards to Cassandra Fairbanks and attacking other Trump supporters over stupid shit, along with the harassment evidence.

She was one of those who kept acting like Trump 'still has a path to victory' even after Jan 6th, and usually was more about helping her grift by being a parasite on Trump's movement.

People like her should just be ignored these days; if she has something legit for the Right to worry about, someone more credible (in the eyes of the normie Right, not alt-right) would be able to break the story as well.

Though it is odd how many Russia supporters/anti-Ukraine people tend to have haraasment or sexual crimes in their background. I mean Scott Ritter, Gonzo Lira, MacGregor, now Loomer.
 
Can you tell me what differance there is between Russian and Ukrainian culture? It seems hard to tell. Like if the British Empire was reformed, and Canada conqured America. I'd heisitate to call it genocide. What cultural traditions would be removed? I guess the 4th of July would no longer be celebrated. But what else? I mean Ukranians and Russians seem to be about as similar as Americas and Canadians. But you live in that part of the world so you know more about their differances, what are they?
I'm trying to figure out how to even explain to you how wrong you are, but the sheer level of either ignorance or believing things that are the opposite of true is so staggering, I don't even know if there's a reference point that would be within sight of wherever you are.

...How about this:

Canada has French as a second national language, as opposed to the USA's de-facto Spanish.

Can you understand the implications of that difference?
 
So it's plain severe ignorance. Separate language, a lot of differences in history and interpretation of it, and if you are interested in "national character" of course people also try to quantify that, for starters Ukrainians and Russians have quite different attitudes towards such major questions like having a strong authoritarian state:
I thought that Ukranians and Russians were able to understand each other when speaking? If they can't that does lend credence to your arguments.

As for attitudes towards dictatorship vs democracy no that is not enough. That is a political differance. If some dictator went Emperor of mankind and took over all of humanity under his rule that would not be genocidal. Being forced into political submission is not genocide.

So you think cultural genocide should have "similar and related cultures are fair game" exception?
Like Germans can't go germanize Poland by force, but Russians can russify it instead? Germans have to satisfy themselves with removing Austria and Switzerland from the map, while the British have to keep their imperial designs to Ireland and Scotland.
This is fucking insane.
That's not exactly what I said. Ok let me ask you question to clear it up how do you genocide a people? Obviously you can kill them all and move in your own people. But let's say you aren't killing them. You can still genocide them that would be by forbidding them from practicing their religion, cultural customs, festivals, and language. Poland is different from Russia and Germany. Germany if it conqured Austria wouldn't really be able to genocide them culturally because they are the same they speak the same language they have similar festivals and ways of life.

The only differance is that Austrians are Catholic and Germans protestants. Or at least they used to now they are both liberal secular states so it would not be a differance.

Obviously there is even more difference between Ukrainians and Russians than British and Americans, as the chances a random Ukrainian and random Russian can communicate easily is far lower.

Secondly, Ukraine has a lot of cultural influence from its time under Lithuania, Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth and the Cossack traditions, while at the same time Moscow was Mongol's tribute collector vassal who was going freelance when Mongols weakened, and in turn had taken some characteristics from that, its few centuries we are talking about here.
If what you said about language is true then it is true.

However your second argument doesn't seem as good. Ukraine do they really have a lot of influence from the Polish Lithuanian commonwealth?

As for the Cossacks they were still under the Russian empire they just had autonomy.

So you want to ignore the mass kidnapping of UA children into Russia, the direct quotes of people in Russia themselves back at the start of the invasion admitting they expected to need 2 gens of occupation to 'Russify' Ukrainians, and the Russian's often saying Ukraine is a country with no right to exist.

I do not always agree with what the UN definition defines as genocide, but I also will not deny Russia has hit multiple checks on the list for 'did they commit genocide' list with their actions in Ukraine.
The mass kidnapping of Ukrainian children would work.
The quotes about occupation don't meet the definition anymore than the American quotes in world war 2 about Japanese being spoken only in hell after this count as genocide.

Also saying a country has no right to exist also does not make it a genocide. Again a nation annexing another nation is not genocide. Genocide is done to remove an ethnic people not removing their government. If the Ukrainians still exist as Russian subjects they were not genocided.
I'm trying to figure out how to even explain to you how wrong you are, but the sheer level of either ignorance or believing things that are the opposite of true is so staggering, I don't even know if there's a reference point that would be within sight of wherever you are.

...How about this:

Canada has French as a second national language, as opposed to the USA's de-facto Spanish.

Can you understand the implications of that difference?
Ok? What is your point those are second languages the majority in both speak English. Tell me how would Canadians genocide Americans or Americans genocide Canadians(without mass killings) Because cultural genocide means that a people are basically no longer themselves. If China or the Japanese empire conquered a European province and they forced the people to live in a different way you can see how they are different. More than just politics.
 
I thought that Ukranians and Russians were able to understand each other when speaking? If they can't that does lend credence to your arguments.
Some portion of Ukrainians speak Russian, some Ukrainian, and some both to varying degrees. Ukrainian is a Slavic language, so it's kinda understandable to all other Slavs in a limited way, but the same goes for Polish, Czech, Russian and so on. Personally i find Ukrainian and Czech easier to understand than Russian, can catch what around 30-50% of words mean if someone is speaking very clearly, which is to be expected because those have more Polish influence than the Russian language.
As for attitudes towards dictatorship vs democracy no that is not enough. That is a political differance. If some dictator went Emperor of mankind and took over all of humanity under his rule that would not be genocidal. Being forced into political submission is not genocide.
And it still wouldn't make everyone like his rule.
Just like Islamists in Europe have to live under liberal democracy, even though they go on the streets and demand a theocracy, and the Islamist protest will obviously consist of more or less recent immigrants from distant foreign countries or their descendants, rather than locals who had a political opinion change.
This is about their preference for how government should work. They can like the government they have or not, but this undeniably is a difference.
Prefereces for how the state should work obviously are a significant part of a culture, and vary between cultures.
That's not exactly what I said. Ok let me ask you question to clear it up how do you genocide a people? Obviously you can kill them all and move in your own people. But let's say you aren't killing them. You can still genocide them that would be by forbidding them from practicing their religion, cultural customs, festivals, and language. Poland is different from Russia and Germany. Germany if it conqured Austria wouldn't really be able to genocide them culturally because they are the same they speak the same language they have similar festivals and ways of life.
Let's say you do genocide with chinese characteristics like some from the end of the list.
You aren't killing them, you just force them into labor camps more or less, and if they have any children you force them into propaganda camps/schools where they get raised in your culture, with no parental involvement if they cause problems.

You technically aren't killing them, but in few decades the "tribe" in question will in fact cease to exist. It would be just a slightly more humane (and economically efficient) version of ancient's "kill the men, turn the women into sex slaves and the children into servants/slaves".
The only differance is that Austrians are Catholic and Germans protestants. Or at least they used to now they are both liberal secular states so it would not be a differance.
No, that's not the only difference. As i said, it's an insane "it's not cultural genocide if a similar culture does it" caveat. This is ridiculous, and seems mostly based on your personal ignorance of how similar cultures still have a lot of subtle differences that someone without close knowledge of them usually won't know about.
If they were so similar they would have never been separate nationalities to begin with.
If what you said about language is true then it is true.

However your second argument doesn't seem as good. Ukraine do they really have a lot of influence from the Polish Lithuanian commonwealth?
Yes, Kyiv was under Polish or Lithuanian rule for as almost as long as it was under the rule of Moscow, and it does show in the culture.
And yes, unlike Canada's bilingualism, Ukrainian is a separate language in its own right.
As for the Cossacks they were still under the Russian empire they just had autonomy.
Gradually turned into "autonomy". As in they were treated like shit, like everyone in Russia is.
The mass kidnapping of Ukrainian children would work.
The quotes about occupation don't meet the definition anymore than the American quotes in world war 2 about Japanese being spoken only in hell after this count as genocide.
Quotes aren't actions, i think that distinction is pretty clear.
Also saying a country has no right to exist also does not make it a genocide. Again a nation annexing another nation is not genocide. Genocide is done to remove an ethnic people not removing their government. If the Ukrainians still exist as Russian subjects they were not genocided.
The thing is that Russians were now quite clear that they also will not accept Ukrainians as a separate nationality and culture even inside Russia, because having such a large culturally separate population in an empire is obviously an issue, as everyone can see now, it is a group that doesn't want to be ruled by Russians and will try to overthrow this rule whenever it can. Hence, cultural genocide.
 
Last edited:
Ok? What is your point those are second languages the majority in both speak English. Tell me how would Canadians genocide Americans or Americans genocide Canadians(without mass killings) Because cultural genocide means that a people are basically no longer themselves. If China or the Japanese empire conquered a European province and they forced the people to live in a different way you can see how they are different. More than just politics.
Congratulations, you may be the first example I have personally seen of the Dunning-Kruger effect.

You know so little about what forms a culture, that you can't even perceive when they are or are not different, much less how drastic those differences are.

If you want to learn, please ask somebody to teach you. Otherwise, please stop wasting people's time with your ignorance.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top