Armchair General's DonbAss Derailed Discussion Thread (Topics Include History, Traps, and the Ongoing Slavic Civil War plus much much more)

ATP

Well-known member
Rubs his hands.
Time to go in and protect the oppressed Bulgarian minority on the other side of the Danube basin and northern Dobrudzha while the Russians are dealing with denazifying Romania.


Putin needs to Denazify Ankara and Athens next, too.
And whatever the capitol of Makedonia was.

EDIT:


With what army? Czeczenya was not supported by anybody and have 1 million of inhabitants.russia need 10 years and 20.000KIS soldier to pacify them.
Ukraine have 44 millions and foreign support.russia would lost more then 900.000KIA to take country.Possible in sralin times,but not now,when russia is dying.

Unless they use nukes,all they get would be Mariunpol.

P.S Do you really want to all balkan states gang on you,just like in 1913?
 

Agent23

Ни шагу назад!
With what army? Czeczenya was not supported by anybody and have 1 million of inhabitants.russia need 10 years and 20.000KIS soldier to pacify them.
Ukraine have 44 millions and foreign support.russia would lost more then 900.000KIA to take country.Possible in sralin times,but not now,when russia is dying.

Unless they use nukes,all they get would be Mariunpol.

P.S Do you really want to all balkan states gang on you,just like in 1913?
This would be revenge for what they did back then.
I'd gladly join forces with anything that helps us give those treacherous, backstabbing scumbags what they deserve.
Even if it is a bunch of Plague marines, or the Flood.
 

strunkenwhite

Well-known member
This would be revenge for what they did back then.
I'd gladly join forces with anything that helps us give those treacherous, backstabbing scumbags what they deserve.
Even if it is a bunch of Plague marines, or the Flood.
Then why not admit you're willing to join forces with people that shoot civilians in Bucha?
 

Chiron

Well-known member


Retired Operations Officer Tyler Weaver aka Armchair Warlord lays out the reality that Jennifer Cafarella is unable to grasp with her cope maps.

A better map I found that gives more accurate lines from better sources than Cope Maps from OSINT.





Bridge Networks go boom if and when Russia decides.



And Russia has decided Comrades.



Scott Ritter lays out the reality.

Then why not admit you're willing to join forces with people that shoot civilians in Bucha?

Its been well established for weeks now that Ukraine killed those folks, primarily collaborators with Russians and blamed Russia for it and OSINT and MSM repeated it only to get debunked by actual investigators on alternative platforms where the masses have turned to these days.

I and others also pointed it out.

Ukraine killed those people, end of story.

Edit: Seems telegram functions are not working properly at the moment in the coding, or its just my monitor and connection.
 

strunkenwhite

Well-known member
Its been well established for weeks now that Ukraine killed those folks, primarily collaborators with Russians and blamed Russia for it and OSINT and MSM repeated it only to get debunked by actual investigators on alternative platforms where the masses have turned to these days.

I and others also pointed it out.

Ukraine killed those people, end of story.

Edit: Seems telegram functions are not working properly at the moment in the coding, or its just my monitor and connection.
If that's your position, I'd like to know what you make of the video I posted earlier, taken during the Russian occupation, showing an armored vehicle with Russian invasion markings gunning down a civilian at exactly the spot where a body was found.

P.S. I also await, with bated breath, those details on what you mean by "replacement rate".

 
Last edited:

Chiron

Well-known member
If that's your position, I'd like to know what you make of the video I posted earlier, taken during the Russian occupation, showing an armored vehicle with Russian invasion markings gunning down a civilian at exactly the spot where a body was found.

P.S. I also await, with bated breath, those details on what you mean by "replacement rate".



From the angle we can't see what he was doing. For all we know, he disregarded instructions to stop, Russian soldiers didn't know what was in the bike basket, and his failure to follow instructions gave them a legal right to conclude he was making an attack and put him down. Thus not a war crime.

That said, this 2nd point you want me to address: All military campaigns involve losses, any competent military will account for that and have a set amount of new recruits and equipment in reserve and being brought in as new recruits/production to replace losses. With less than 10k in causalities of all types and an active duty force of 1m+ men and reserves of 2m men and ~200k drafted each year, the losses in Ukraine are manageable for Russia.

Same for vehicle losses given their stockpiles and new production.
 

Abhorsen

Local Degenerate
Moderator
Staff Member
Comrade
Osaul


Can you spot the convoy? Granted... you have a better angle...


Honestly, that's not a half bad idea. If there was just one, and it was still (movement is much more detectable), parking on the side of the road with aerial faced camo would work about as well as possible.
 

strunkenwhite

Well-known member
From the angle we can't see what he was doing. For all we know, he disregarded instructions to stop, Russian soldiers didn't know what was in the bike basket, and his failure to follow instructions gave them a legal right to conclude he was making an attack and put him down. Thus not a war crime.
Taking this reply together with your previous post, it seems to me as if you're saying, "Ukraine killed them all and it was a war crime, except for the ones we have video evidence of Russians killing, and those killings were not a war crime." I hope you can see how such a position ... appears to reek of motivated reasoning, to say the least. But perhaps I've misunderstood you?
That said, this 2nd point you want me to address: All military campaigns involve losses, any competent military will account for that and have a set amount of new recruits and equipment in reserve and being brought in as new recruits/production to replace losses. With less than 10k in causalities of all types and an active duty force of 1m+ men and reserves of 2m men and ~200k drafted each year, the losses in Ukraine are manageable for Russia.

Same for vehicle losses given their stockpiles and new production.
With regard to personnel, there are all sorts of factors that go into "replacement", such as their level of training, etc. There is no doubt that Russia could hypothetically field many more conscripts than the number of soldiers that are currently fighting, but they wouldn't necessarily be as good. Even if all-volunteer, quality is not guaranteed for a new pilot vs. one that had years of experience that went down in his plane.

But we can hopefully evaluate losses in materiel more concretely. For example, what I specifically questioned you on was your claim that losses of aircraft were below replacement rate. So how many piloted fighters do you believe have been lost in the war so far, and how many do you believe have been newly put into service or restored to service from a mothballed state? Same question for helicopters. edit: and, if it's possible to know, how does the quality compare? For instance, new-ish fighters being "replaced" with ones that are 15 years older with avionics 30 years older because it didn't get the same upgrades.

It seems ridiculous to me to think that Russia is keeping its numbers of active service aircraft stable despite losses. Same for armored vehicles, logistics equipment, etc. The only reason Ukraine's stocks of military equipment aren't melting away is because of a constant influx from NATO countries, and Russia has no such influx. (Well, and arguably Ukraine has the influx from Russian captured stuff if one believes the memes, but I think we can agree that this by itself wouldn't be enough on either side, and most especially not the side that recently had to stage large scale withdrawals which inevitably leave lots of equipment behind.)
 
Last edited:

Agent23

Ни шагу назад!
From the angle we can't see what he was doing. For all we know, he disregarded instructions to stop, Russian soldiers didn't know what was in the bike basket, and his failure to follow instructions gave them a legal right to conclude he was making an attack and put him down. Thus not a war crime.
Or it is just more staged nonsense.
 

PsihoKekec

Swashbuckling Accountant
Media here is talking about Germany negotiating with Slolvenia and Croatia to give them M-84 tanks in exchange for surplus Marder and Fuchs vehicles. It is basically T-72M version, with more powerful engine and much better FCS, Slovenia has 54 and Croatia 72 of these tanks. In Slovenia 40 of these tanks are in storage and company of them is assigned to a training center in Germany as OPFOR.
The problem is that neither country wants Marders and Fuchs.
 

Agent23

Ни шагу назад!


Ayway, it is Easter Friday for me, so I am doubly uninterested by MSM regurgitation and pro-Elkboy reeing!
Here, have bunny and happy Easter!
 

Agent23

Ни шагу назад!
Well, fuck, it is Easter and not only are your friends all out shitposting, but all the distant, annoying relatives are coming to beg you for stuff, translation:
Top text: He came to ask for free shit.
Article: Kuleba will stay in Bulgaria until he doesn't get a reply regarding the weapons.

Bottom text: They ain't givin him, he curses, tries to get into a fight, curses again, shouts, and says "I ain' goin ome!"
photo-2022-04-22-11-52-22.jpg

I wonder if he is trying to get us to subsidize his Easter vacation, too.
Let him go to the Black Sea, if he encounters one of the mines his idiots released throughout it there will be some actual use from his visit.
 
Last edited:

Zachowon

The Army Life for me! The POG life for me!
Founder
The US can't even replace its losses of aircraft lost as fast as Chrion claims the Ruskiew can
 

BlackDragon98

Freikorps Kommandant
Banned - Politics
United States postulates Ukraine may have more operational tanks in theater then the Russians at the moment



A Russian media outlet in a now deleted VK post reportedly claimed a large number in Russian casualties.



Pictures of a Park filled with damaged or destroyed Russian vehicles taken by Ukrainian drones crossing the border.



Russian Senator Andrei Klimov warns Sweden and Finland that if they join NATO they could share in the fate of the Ukranians of Mariupol.



Foreign military veteran volunteers from Norway, UK and the USA with the Ukrainian TDF.


Guess the Ukrainian farmers were actually working for the Russians.

Seems like the Russians will get +2000 EXP in repair skill after this.

Foreign military volunteers . . .

So the cadre for the resurrected SS units "Wiking", "Englisch Freikorps", and "Amerika"

Here's the thing. The entire count of major warships remaining in the Russian Navy was a single Project 1143.5 aircraft carrier and five heavy guided missile cruisers — two of the Project 1144 Orlan (“Kirov” class) and three of the Project 1164 Atlant (“Slava” class). With the sole carrier Admiral Kuznetsov out of service since its attempted refit in 2017 and the Orlan-class Admiral Nakhimov stuck in an apparently perpetual refit since 1997, the Moskva represented fully one quarter of the Russian fleet’s deployable major units.

Without Moskva,the most powerful remaining warships in the Black Seas Fleet are three Project 11356P (“Admiral Grigorovich” class) multirole frigates, with two larger Project 22350 (“Admiral Gorshkov” class) expected to deliver sometime in the next two years. Now of course, the pro-Russian posters will insist that the new frigates and corvettes are a more cost-effective naval strategy. That's true in some ways, but while these are relatively capable modern warships, they are very small warships with even the Gorshkovs having a standard displacement of roughly 4500 tons.
yawwwnnnnnnn . . .

Ukrainian cruiser Ukraina - Wikipedia

when are the ukrops going to scuttle this one?

Because otherwise the Russkies will take it.

oh and according to the ukrops themselves, they were spending money keeping the ship (95% completed) maintained or something like that.
 

Zachowon

The Army Life for me! The POG life for me!
Founder
Guess the Ukrainian farmers were actually working for the Russians.

Seems like the Russians will get +2000 EXP in repair skill after this.

Foreign military volunteers . . .

So the cadre for the resurrected SS units "Wiking", "Englisch Freikorps", and "Amerika"


yawwwnnnnnnn . . .

Ukrainian cruiser Ukraina - Wikipedia

when are the ukrops going to scuttle this one?

Because otherwise the Russkies will take it.

oh and according to the ukrops themselves, they were spending money keeping the ship (95% completed) maintained or something like that.
I mean the Farmers are taking everything and taking it for personal use in farming.
How are the Farmers helping the Russians? You are making no sense.
And why would the Russians try and fix a ship that is in a port they no longer control amd within range of Neptune's?

Sorry Vatnik.
Can't hear you over Cope of losing the Moskow
 

Tiamat

I've seen the future...
Guess the Ukrainian farmers were actually working for the Russians.

Seems like the Russians will get +2000 EXP in repair skill after this.

Foreign military volunteers . . .

So the cadre for the resurrected SS units "Wiking", "Englisch Freikorps", and "Amerika"


yawwwnnnnnnn . . .

Ukrainian cruiser Ukraina - Wikipedia

when are the ukrops going to scuttle this one?

Because otherwise the Russkies will take it.

oh and according to the ukrops themselves, they were spending money keeping the ship (95% completed) maintained or something like that.

Weren’t you supposed to be taking an English teaching job in Kazakhstan after deciding it wasn’t worth staying in Canada even though you said you were going to stand and resist the RCMP? Or Was it you were going to migrate to the Crimea instead?

Its interesting you keep spouting off about Nazis when you at the very beginning of this conflict was practically fapping off on this forum about getting to see the corpses of dead Ukrainians. If you’re going to oppose Nazis, try not to emulate them?

Honestly I don’t think anyone can take you seriously anymore.
 

Husky_Khan

The Dog Whistler... I mean Whisperer.
Founder
Weren’t you supposed to be taking an English teaching job in Kazakhstan after deciding it wasn’t worth staying in Canada even though you said you were going to stand and resist the RCMP? Or Was it you were going to migrate to the Crimea instead?

Its interesting you keep spouting off about Nazis when you at the very beginning of this conflict was practically fapping off on this forum about getting to see the corpses of dead Ukrainians. If you’re going to oppose Nazis, try not to emulate them?

Honestly I don’t think anyone can take you seriously anymore.

TBF there's not many people left to teach in the Seperatist Republics. Many of the women and children were evacuated and many of the males pressed into service after being given excellent training and first rate equipment.







Any women and children leftover in the Donbass have likely been claimed by other heroic Independent Western journalists like Graham Phillips and Scott Ritter. 😪
 
Last edited:

Users who are viewing this thread

Top