Fallout Fallout General Thread - War, War Never Changes. Nor do game engines.

Navarro

Well-known member
So, what are your opinions on the dilemma in Honest Hearts? Having recently replayed the DLC, I pretty much always side with Graham. Barring the author fiat that kills the White Legs off if you pick Daniel, there's no reason why they won't hound the Sorrows and similar tribes forever.

And eventually they'll be no place where they can run if the White Legs aren't stopped.
 

Urabrask Revealed

Let them go.
Founder
So, what are your opinions on the dilemma in Honest Hearts? Having recently replayed the DLC, I pretty much always side with Graham. Barring the author fiat that kills the White Legs off if you pick Daniel, there's no reason why they won't hound the Sorrows and similar tribes forever.

And eventually they'll be no place where they can run if the White Legs aren't stopped.
There was a dilemma? I thought you only had to pick if Graham gives into his thirst for revenge or continues to follow the teachings of his religion?
 

CarlManvers2019

Writers Blocked Douchebag
Say, anybody here think that The Institute were more or less sorta acting as a parasite to the Commonwealth? A highly pseudo intellectual sort of parasite that’s more interested in doing mad science than actually using it to rebuild society as something better

And could also do way less horrible shit to the wastelanders above to get results, like they could just have some synth infiltrators go and trade for the experimental seeds being used
 

Urabrask Revealed

Let them go.
Founder
Say, anybody here think that The Institute were more or less sorta acting as a parasite to the Commonwealth? A highly pseudo intellectual sort of parasite that’s more interested in doing mad science than actually using it to rebuild society as something better

And could also do way less horrible shit to the wastelanders above to get results, like they could just have some synth infiltrators go and trade for the experimental seeds being used
They are. Problem is their culture promotes an arrogance and hatred towards the surface which is considered to be inhabitated by raiders and subhumans. Since they are not viewed as humans by the Institute, it's fine to do whatever you want with them to advance science. Any attempt to better the surface is sabotaged.

Does this in any way sound like they are trying to rebuild society? No, they subconsciously know, if civilization returns to the surface they can't continue their experiements anymore.
 
Last edited:

CarlManvers2019

Writers Blocked Douchebag
It's not even subconscious - it's a fact that they sabotaged an attempt to give Greater Boston a functioning government.

Wasn’t that supposedly a result of all those settlement leaders shooting each other and the Synth getting the blame?
 

CarlManvers2019

Writers Blocked Douchebag
That is what they claim. I really doubt it though.

I guess the Institute heads at the time were willing to lie to even their people on something like that

Probably also fits into their narratives regarding Wastelanders, they may barely have governments of their own, but I’m pretty sure most guys in settlements are reasonable enough NOT to unnecessarily go around shooting


How believable is this one?
 

Hlaalu Agent

Nerevar going to let you down
Founder
I mean, they also deliberately release super mutants "into the wild" to add to the unrest as well.

They do? I thought it was just them experimenting for lulz, and then being lazy fucks and releasing them into the wild...

And that brings them from negligence to malice.
 

CarlManvers2019

Writers Blocked Douchebag
They do? I thought it was just them experimenting for lulz, and then being lazy fucks and releasing them into the wild...

And that brings them from negligence to malice.

They even experimented on one of their own, Swann the Supermutant Behemoth was once on of theirs.

And frankly, I say that turning someone into a supermutant, especially one with the reduced intelligence and increase in violent impulses is nothing short of Mind Rape
 

Hlaalu Agent

Nerevar going to let you down
Founder
They even experimented on one of their own, Swann the Supermutant Behemoth was once on of theirs.

And frankly, I say that turning someone into a supermutant, especially one with the reduced intelligence and increase in violent impulses is nothing short of Mind Rape

Poor Swann, just wanted some cigarettes and was turned into a monster who could only remember his name, but not the meaning.

Also checking out on FO4, but the caravan merchants are dicks, not only are many of them informants, but them stiffing the Libertalian Minutemen and lack of decency towards them is what sent them down the slippery slope of being raiders.
 

CarlManvers2019

Writers Blocked Douchebag
Poor Swann, just wanted some cigarettes and was turned into a monster who could only remember his name, but not the meaning.

Even if the Commonwealth Provisional Government turning bad wasn't their fault, their actions afterwards kept affirming the Commonwealth's beliefs about them and they didn't up-front do immediately obvious helpful things, they just turned the Commonwealth into a place for experiments and its people as their lab rats
 

Hlaalu Agent

Nerevar going to let you down
Founder
Even if the Commonwealth Provisional Government turning bad wasn't their fault, their actions afterwards kept affirming the Commonwealth's beliefs about them and they didn't up-front do immediately obvious helpful things, they just turned the Commonwealth into a place for experiments and its people as their lab rats

I agree, and it is really sad, because they could have easily worked with the Commonwealth rather than destroy it and mutually benefitted. If I am not mistaken that settlement on University Point was doing research, and there is actual research being done around in the Commonwealth... So imagine if the Institute instead took a leading role?
 

Battlegrinder

Someday we will win, no matter what it takes.
Moderator
Staff Member
Founder
Obozny
There was a dilemma? I thought you only had to pick if Graham gives into his thirst for revenge or continues to follow the teachings of his religion?

That's one of the choices you make in Graham's route, but there's also an entirely different choice to just evacuate Zion and seal the path behind you. I've never been clear on what the upside of that one is supposed to be.



As for the institute, oxhorn covers it with the usual level of detail, including the CPG:

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top