• The Sietch will be brought offline for HPG systems maintenance tomorrow (Thursday, 2 May 2024). Please remain calm and do not start any interstellar wars while ComStar is busy. May the Peace of Blake be with you. Precentor Dune

Armchair General's DonbAss Derailed Discussion Thread (Topics Include History, Traps, and the Ongoing Slavic Civil War plus much much more)

ATP

Well-known member
Yeah, I think I said before that for every Ukrainian posturing with one after an alleged kill there are pics of a hell of a lot more captured by the Russians.
My theory was that they were actually shit, the Russians managed to counter them, or the simple truth is that the Ukrainian army is deserting or falling back in uncontrolled retreat.

Or all of the above.

My first thought when I saw the cope cage was WTF, my second after I heard that some of these things have heat seeking was, um, maybe that is a radiator?

Let say,that ukrainian army is deserting.Tell me,why russian army do not attacked and win then? either it not happened,or russians are dessering,too.
Or comrade colonel stopped them - he need bloody war,and KGB need russian army massacred,so they do not made putch and save Mother Russia from KGB mafias.
Which would work.

And is good for Europe - Putin could not conqer us later,and USA could nold sell Poland again to Moscow,let say to made alliance with China.

Ukrainians and russians are dying,but....when exactly anybody cared about dying russians or ukrainians? certainly not comrade Putin now.
 

Agent23

Ни шагу назад!
Let say,that ukrainian army is deserting.Tell me,why russian army do not attacked and win then? either it not happened,or russians are dessering,too.
Or comrade colonel stopped them - he need bloody war,and KGB need russian army massacred,so they do not made putch and save Mother Russia from KGB mafias.
Which would work.

And is good for Europe - Putin could not conqer us later,and USA could nold sell Poland again to Moscow,let say to made alliance with China.

Ukrainians and russians are dying,but....when exactly anybody cared about dying russians or ukrainians? certainly not comrade Putin now.

I am just wondering how and why so much very expensive, very modern western tech keeps getting captured.

Knowing us Slavs, both sides might be pretend-fighting and reselling each-other weapons and ammo, then pocketing the bribes and prize money provided by central command and this might just be them grifting, pretending to work and getting drunk all day long... 😂
Or at least that is one nice dream I have when I try and stop thinking about the current mess we are all in.:cry:
After all these shenanigans I hope that Polandball finally learns that far-away allies are useless, and that they need more weapons and nukes.
Then just tell Putin to not bother them and they won't bother him and sign some type of mutual non-intervention treaty.
 

Agent23

Ни шагу назад!
Speaking of piracy, they made it legal for all software coming from hostile countries.
Hey, I will have you know that stealing IP from your enemy is a time-honored Slavic tactic ever since the Xth century.

We see as guideline, not as law!
 

ATP

Well-known member
I am just wondering how and why so much very expensive, very modern western tech keeps getting captured.

Knowing us Slavs, both sides might be pretend-fighting and reselling each-other weapons and ammo, then pocketing the bribes and prize money provided by central command and this might just be them grifting, pretending to work and getting drunk all day long... 😂
Or at least that is one nice dream I have when I try and stop thinking about the current mess we are all in.:cry:
After all these shenanigans I hope that Polandball finally learns that far-away allies are useless, and that they need more weapons and nukes.
Then just tell Putin to not bother them and they won't bother him and sign some type of mutual non-intervention treaty.

Both sides are corrupted,but not to that extend.
Problem with Putin - he started with blowing up his own people to provoke war in which he genocided 200k Czechens,and later broken all promises made to country other then China.

We could not have lasting deal with him.But,if he gave us 300 missiles with nukes/and codes to them/ then we could be good neighbours.Problem is - even if KGB agree to that,our ruling eunuch do not.Becouse they always do what USA want.Opposition is even worst,they always do what germans want.

Only hope - Holy Mary is Qeen of Poland,if we survive it would be only thanks to HER.
 

LordsFire

Internet Wizard
Anyway, here is Rickards on the causes of the war and the impact of it on the whole world:


This really comes across as either paid shilling on Russia's behalf, or someone who is so buried in Russian propaganda that he doesn't realize he should be asking to be paid for what he's saying.

Sure, he makes it sound polite and pleasant, but ultimately what the message coming across is 'It's the US and EU's fault that Russia is invading the Ukraine, and the economic sanctions are going to hurt the rest of the world more than Russia.'

Everything is the West's fault, and they're just going to hurt themselves more than the Russia with what they're doing. It's like a flashback from the pinkos during the Cold War, so buried in their socialist dogma that they can't understand anything outside of their narrative.

To be fair, it's not like he's talking complete nonsense; he raises relevant points about the back and forth of diplomacy and international politics, he just is putting the weight and emphasis on the wrong elements.
 

Terthna

Professional Lurker
This really comes across as either paid shilling on Russia's behalf, or someone who is so buried in Russian propaganda that he doesn't realize he should be asking to be paid for what he's saying.

Sure, he makes it sound polite and pleasant, but ultimately what the message coming across is 'It's the US and EU's fault that Russia is invading the Ukraine, and the economic sanctions are going to hurt the rest of the world more than Russia.'

Everything is the West's fault, and they're just going to hurt themselves more than the Russia with what they're doing. It's like a flashback from the pinkos during the Cold War, so buried in their socialist dogma that they can't understand anything outside of their narrative.

To be fair, it's not like he's talking complete nonsense; he raises relevant points about the back and forth of diplomacy and international politics, he just is putting the weight and emphasis on the wrong elements.
To you, it comes across that way. To me, it matches with a lot of what I already knew; the situation in Ukraine is the west's fault, and economic sanctions, much like protests, are useless. You don't have to believe that, but painting everyone who disagrees with you as a "socialist pinko" just demonstrates that you're not coming at this from a position of reason; you're coming at it from a position of faith, and you're lashing out at the non-believers who threaten your beliefs by refusing to share them.

Quite frankly, I think any hope for a rational discourse regarding what going down in Ukraine died long before any of us were born. Because this isn't about what's actually happening there now; it's about the Cold War, and people who could never accept that it was over.
 

Captain X

Well-known member
Osaul
I seriously have to wonder how many of you pro-Russia/Putin types are old enough to have spent any of your lives during the Cold War. I wasn't real old when the Soviet Union collapsed, just in the first few grades, but I still remember what that was like. I think you're going to have a taste of it yourselves, though. ;)


ETA:

You know, I really have to wonder with some of you where your line is. What has to happen before you stop even bothering to stick up for Russia.
 
Last edited:

PsihoKekec

Swashbuckling Accountant
I seriously have to wonder how many of you pro-Russia/Putin types are old enough to have spent any of your lives during the Cold War. I wasn't real old when the Soviet Union collapsed, just in the first few grades, but I still remember what that was like. I think you're going to have a taste of it yourselves, though. ;)

I'm glad you can see the bright side of it.
 

TheRejectionist

TheRejectionist
I seriously have to wonder how many of you pro-Russia/Putin types are old enough to have spent any of your lives during the Cold War. I wasn't real old when the Soviet Union collapsed, just in the first few grades, but I still remember what that was like. I think you're going to have a taste of it yourselves, though. ;)


ETA:

You know, I really have to wonder with some of you where your line is. What has to happen before you stop even bothering to stick up for Russia.

I am young enough to remember your country trying to annihilate every inch of actual freedom, not the McFreedom. I am young to remember the United States destroyed 3 countries : Iraq, Syria, Lybia, Yemen. I am young enough to remember that your overthrow of legit governments didn't end with the Cold War.

Not to mention that as a Latin American passionate about history, I remember all of this :

Argentina1890TroopsBuenos Aires interests protected
Chile1891TroopsMarines clash with nationalist rebels
Haiti1891TroopsBlack workers revolt on U.S.-claimed Navassa Island defeated
Nicaragua1894TroopsMonth-long occupation of Bluefields
Panama1895Naval, troopsMarines land in Colombian province
Nicaragua1896TroopsMarines land in port of Corinto
Cuba1898-Naval, troopsSeized from Spain, U.S. still holds Navy base at Guantanamo
Puerto Rico1898-Naval, troopsSeized from Spain, occupation continues
Nicaragua1898TroopsMarines land at port of San Juan del Sur
Nicaragua1899TroopsMarines land at port of Bluefields
Honduras1903TroopsMarines intervene in revolution
Dominican Republic1903-04TroopsU.S. interests protected in Revolution
Cuba1906-09TroopsMarines land in democratic election
Nicaragua1907Troops"Dollar Diplomacy" protectorate set up
Honduras1907TroopsMarines land during war with Nicaragua
Panama1908TroopsMarines intervene in election contest
Nicaragua1910TroopsMarines land in Bluefields and Corinto
Honduras1911TroopsU.S. interests protected in civil war
Cuba1912TroopsU.S. interests protected in Havana
Panama1912TroopsMarines land during heated election
Honduras1912TroopsMarines protect U.S. economic interests
Nicaragua1912-33Troops, bombing20-year occupation, fought guerrillas
Mexico1913NavalAmericans evacuated during revolution
Dominican Republic1914NavalFight with rebels over Santo Domingo
Mexico1914-18Naval, troopsSeries of interventions against nationalists
Haiti1914-34Troops, bombing19-year occupation after revolts
Dominican Republic1916-24Troops8-year Marine occupation
Cuba1917-33TroopsMilitary occupation, economic protectorate
Panama1918-20Troops"Police duty" during unrest after elections
Honduras1919TroopsMarines land during election campaign
Guatemala1920Troops2-week intervention against unionists
Costa Rica1921Troops
Panama1921Troops
Honduras1924-25TroopsLanded twice during election strife
Panama1925TroopsMarines suppress general strike
El Salvador1932NavalWarships sent during Faribundo Marti revolt
Uruguay1947Nuclear threatBombers deployed as show of strength
Puerto Rico1950Command operationIndependence rebellion crushed in Ponce
Guatemala1954-?Command operation, bombing, nuclear threatCIA directs exile invasion and coup d'Etat after newly elected government nationalizes unused U.S.'s United Fruit Company lands; bombers based in Nicaragua; long-term result: 200,000 murdered
Panama1958TroopsFlag protests erupt into confrontation
Cuba1961Command operationCIA-directed exile invasion fails
Cuba1962Nuclear threat, navalBlockade during missile crisis; near-war with Soviet Union
Panama1964TroopsPanamanians shot for urging canal's return
Dominican Republic1965-66Troops, bombingMarines land during election campaign
Guatemala1966-67Command operationGreen Berets intervene against rebels
Chile1973Command operationCIA-backed coup ousts democratically elected Marxist president
El Salvador1981-92Command operation, troopsAdvisors, overflights aid anti-rebel war, soldiers briefly involved in hostage clash; long-term result: 75,000 murdered and destruction of popular movement
Nicaragua1981-90Command operation, navalCIA directs exile (Contra) invasions, plants harbor mines against revolution; result: 50,000 murdered
Honduras1982-90TroopsManeuvers help build bases near borders
Grenada1983-84Troops, bombingInvasion four years after revolution
Bolivia1987TroopsArmy assists raids on cocaine region
Panama1989Troops, bombingNationalist government ousted by 27,000 soldiers, leaders arrested, 2000+ killed
Haiti1994-95Troops, navalBlockade against military government; troops restore President Aristide to office three years after coup
Venezuela2002Command operationFailed coup attempt to remove left-populist president Hugo Chavez
Haiti2004-TroopsRemoval of democratically elected President Aristide; troops occupy country
Honduras2009Command operationSupport for coup that removed president Manuel Zelaya

Sources:
Blum, William. Killing Hope: U.S. Military and CIA Interventionism Since World War II. Monroe, Maine: Common Courage Press, 1995.
Ege & Makhijani. "180 Landings by the U.S. Marine Corps" (History Division), Counterspy (July-Aug. 1982). Foreign Affairs Division, Congressional Research Service, Library of Congress.
Instances of Use of Armed Forces Abroad, 1798-2020. CRS Report for Congress, 2020.
Grossman, Zoltan. Over a Century of U.S. Military Interventions. Self-published, revised Jan. 1, 1995.
Sklar, Holly. "Who's Who: Invading 'Our' Hemisphere 1831-," Z Magazine (Feb. 1990).
U.S. Congress, Committee on Foreign Affairs' Report. Background Information on the Use of United States Armed Forces in Foreign Countries. Washington, D.C.: 91st Congress, 2nd Session, 1970.
Zinn, Howard. A People's History of the United States. New York: Perennial Library, Harper & Row, 1980.
Zoltan Grossman, From Wounded Knee to Iraq (A Chronology of U.S. Imperialism)

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

1950s
1960s
1970s
1980s
1990s
2000s

If the past and current events are any indication, your country's elite will tell the USAF to fuck violently another country because "Team America". You and the rest of the working class will have to pay the price.

But you seem to enjoy that idea for some weird reason.
 

Captain X

Well-known member
Osaul
And yet you support Russia. I'm sure I could dig up a pretty long list of atrocities there. I'm sure I could dig up a pretty long one on Brazil, too. That isn't the point, though.
 

Captain X

Well-known member
Osaul
The point is that only fools would look at what is happening and think Russia is somehow in the right. Also only a fool would look to Russia as some kind of savior or defender of freedom. If any of you actually think that, I seriously have to wonder how you could legitimately be that stupid. I'd wonder if you were just pretending to be because you thought it was edgy or funny or something.
 

TheRejectionist

TheRejectionist
And yet you support Russia. I'm sure I could dig up a pretty long list of atrocities there. I'm sure I could dig up a pretty long one on Brazil, too. That isn't the point, though.

I support Russia for the simple reason that they haven't fucked up over half of the world for the supremacy of the US elites.

I support Russia because hasn't chained my countries into an alliance that is more submission than genuine partnership.

I support Russia because they have been the ones offering equal partnerships, which were turn down since the elites might just treat my countries as banana republics if given the slightest of reasons.

All countries have atrocities.

But very few pretend it was for my muh freedom, muh terrorism.

The point is that USA does it for freedom, everyone else does it for wrong reasons. Unless they are American allies, then they do it for right reasons as well.

AND Muh freedom excuse has lost all credibility.

Freedom of what ? To have a colorful boot up my arse ? For my taxes to go to NATO expenses ? To have children conditioned or indoctrinated to accept and practice degenerate behaviors ? For the banks to have more sovereignity than people ? To still being censored or suicided because I have the wrong opinion?
 

AnimalNoodles

Well-known member
Even if Russia does win this war, and I think they will simply due to numbers, I honestly think it's going to be a massive Pyrrhic victory to the point of an actual strategic defeat.

There's going to be massive insurgencies all over the country, which is going to tie down Russia's forces and whatever patsies they put in power.
Ironically, that'd also mean that the breakaway 'states' and Crimea are going to be victim of this, too.

Russia has been made to bleed for this invasion in terms of resources, men, and equipment -- Much of that equipment, such as the more modern attack helicopters, cannot be easily if at all replaced. Hell, a lot of it is being abandoned and outright fucking stolen by Ukraine! If the inevitable insurgents get their hands on this stuff, Ukraine is going to be a second Afghanistan for the Russians.

Generals have been killed. Generals.

Public opinion in Russia is either for the war or against it, so there are massive social divides forming. Hell, a lot of Russians and Ukrainians are openly saying "why the fuck are we fighting?" -- including Russian troops!

Western companies, governments, and people have mostly turned against Russia completely -- Whatever "good imagery" they had in people's eyes is now gone. This stigma is going to last for decades.

This may mean Russia will have to turn to China -- Yeah, the Russians don't like or trust the Chinese either.

Russia's economy, already precarious, is hemorrhaging, and it's never been in the best shape to begin with!

The Russian oligarchs are losing money and influence. Putin may end up with a bullet in the back of the head one night if they all turn against him, which is becoming increasingly likely as time goes on.

Yeah, victory or not, it ain't gonna be good for Russia. smh

Russia doesnt want to occupy all of Ukraine. Thier goals are clear..neutralise Ukraine, pull off the russian speaking areas east of the Dnieper and secure the flow of water to the crimean.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top