Armchair General's DonbAss Derailed Discussion Thread (Topics Include History, Traps, and the Ongoing Slavic Civil War plus much much more)

Getting involved in Korea was justified, Vietnam wasn't, and pretending it was is part of the reason parts of the population have turned against the US military in a lot of ways.

Vietnam was about France trying to make the US bleed to help them keep their colony and stress test how far NATO Art 5 would stretch.

No amount of military strength or accomplishments by soldiers, sailors, and airmen change that Vietnam was a war we never should have gotten involved in.
Life just isn't fair for the ruling class when things don't go their way directing their country and proxies but if one of them had a crystal ball they'd be the winner of the cold war.
 
The funny thing is - all reports back from 'volunteers/ western mercenaries in Ukraine' are the same - war is hell, much different from any of the low-intensity/COIN they are involved in before, and Ukraine is not winning by a wide margin.
Also if you discount the US and its vassals, no country passed sanctions on Russia, so that joke that Russia is isolated is only that - a joke.
Economically speaking about the sanctions - the EU is hit much harder than Russia, but ideology/obeying your masters is more important that the life of your people so...
 
Getting involved in Korea was justified, Vietnam wasn't, and pretending it was is part of the reason parts of the population have turned against the US military in a lot of ways.

Vietnam was about France trying to make the US bleed to help them keep their colony and stress test how far NATO Art 5 would stretch.

No amount of military strength or accomplishments by soldiers, sailors, and airmen change that Vietnam was a war we never should have gotten involved in.

France would win if USA only delivered more planes - but they choosed to bet when Dien Bien Phu fall.Even then Emperor Bao would keep South Vietnam safe,so CIA exiled him.Then they killed president who could stop commies.And then leaved South Vietnam to die.
That was no war to fight commies,but to help them.Becouse one of that fact mean mistake,3 mean helping commies.

The funny thing is - all reports back from 'volunteers/ western mercenaries in Ukraine' are the same - war is hell, much different from any of the low-intensity/COIN they are involved in before, and Ukraine is not winning by a wide margin.
Also if you discount the US and its vassals, no country passed sanctions on Russia, so that joke that Russia is isolated is only that - a joke.
Economically speaking about the sanctions - the EU is hit much harder than Russia, but ideology/obeying your masters is more important that the life of your people so...

kgbstan was supposed to win in week.Now they fight only in Donbas.
And UE is hit becouse of green madness and Berlin alliance with Moscow.
Remove both,and there would be no problems.
 
The funny thing is - all reports back from 'volunteers/ western mercenaries in Ukraine' are the same - war is hell, much different from any of the low-intensity/COIN they are involved in before, and Ukraine is not winning by a wide margin.
Naturally, the fighting in the east has degenerating to something not even resembling WW2, but WW1 western front. And not just in style, but also the stagnant nature of it.
Or in musical form:

Also if you discount the US and its vassals, no country passed sanctions on Russia, so that joke that Russia is isolated is only that - a joke.
A huge chunk of developed economies falls under that umbrella, and that has consequences. As some were celebrating ironically, and some not, Russia is truly on the way to become the leader of the third world.
Economically speaking about the sanctions - the EU is hit much harder than Russia, but ideology/obeying your masters is more important that the life of your people so...
Now you flew off into fucking Mars orbit.
Russia will lose up to an eighth of its GDP due to sanctions. According to Russian experts...
The West will lose part of its GDP growth.
Yeah, right, the west is totally being hit harder than Russia.
 
France would win if USA only delivered more planes - but they choosed to bet when Dien Bien Phu fall.Even then Emperor Bao would keep South Vietnam safe,so CIA exiled him.Then they killed president who could stop commies.And then leaved South Vietnam to die.
That was no war to fight commies,but to help them.Becouse one of that fact mean mistake,3 mean helping commies.



kgbstan was supposed to win in week.Now they fight only in Donbas.
And UE is hit becouse of green madness and Berlin alliance with Moscow.
Remove both,and there would be no problems.
Funny, let's see how better US performs in a scenario like Ukraine - oh, wait - they also have zero experience in that kind of war, and by the last time they are in one, not very well.
 
Naturally, the fighting in the east has degenerating to something not even resembling WW2, but WW1 western front. And not just in style, but also the stagnant nature of it.
Or in musical form:


A huge chunk of developed economies falls under that umbrella, and that has consequences. As some were celebrating ironically, and some not, Russia is truly on the way to become the leader of the third world.

Now you flew off into fucking Mars orbit.
Russia will lose about an eighth of its GDP due to sanctions. According to Russian experts...
The West will lose part of its GDP growth.
Yeah, right, the west is totally being hit harder than Russia.

I just wait to the next winter and talk to you again. You clearly only see the consequences after they hit you on the face, but that's okay by me. Just remember that right now (summer) the EU is already using the stocks to maintain the current use of gas - hint at this time they are supposed to fill the tanks, not using them.
 
I just wait to the next winter and talk to you again. You clearly only see the consequences after they hit you on the face, but that's okay by me. Just remember that right now (summer) the EU is already using the stocks to maintain the current use of gas - hint at this time they are supposed to fill the tanks, not using them.
Make coal great again! Poland, as with anything regarding Russia, was way ahead of everyone, to the protest of the usual suspects.
It's a sad day for CO2 number maniacs and other green nutjobs, but they whine all the time anyway.
 
Make coal great again! Poland, as with anything regarding Russia, was way ahead of everyone, to the protest of the usual suspects.
It's a sad day for CO2 number maniacs and other green nutjobs, but they whine all the time anyway.
Oh, right. Tell me again, how that is going to help the German industry that needs a lot of gas to work - not coal. Without that, German industry collapsed, and Germany's economy go down - and btw, is the engine of the EU economy, so do the math. Not even talking about how that is possible for all other European countries dependent on Russian gas (and oil and coal).
Please, learn about how much the European economy is dependent on Russian resources before regurgitating propaganda.
Not even talking about the other resources that are critical to so many European industries - that are only competitive in the world game because of cheap Russian energy.
Bottom line - the EU is fucked hard without lube, anyone that thinks otherwise is a deluded/ignorant dreamer.
 
Oh, right. Tell me again, how that is going to help the German industry that needs a lot of gas to work - not coal. Without that, German industry collapsed, and Germany's economy go down - and btw, is the engine of the EU economy, so do the math. Not even talking about how that is possible for all other European countries dependent on Russian gas (and oil and coal).
Oh my, wonder how German industry worked without Russian gas in WW2... Or in the Cold War.
The reliance here is part economic and part voluntary on the basis of green idiocy, not technically necessary. Perhaps Germans can start being pragmatic about their industry again if their retirement funds and home heating get threatened.
Please, learn about how much the European economy is dependent on Russian resources before regurgitating propaganda.
As above. It's voluntary, not by necessity. It can be changed, and quicker than you expect.
Not even talking about the other resources that are critical to so many European industries - that are only competitive in the world game because of cheap Russian energy.
Bottom line - the EU is fucked hard without lube, anyone that thinks otherwise is a deluded/ignorant dreamer.
Again, how did Europe get so rich during the Cold War, when reliance on Soviets would be pretty much unthinkable?
Europe didn't get hooked on Russian gas because it was just so cheap, it got hooked on gas at all because of muh CO2 numbers and Russia was conveniently right there with lots of gas.
 
You clearly don't know crap about how much time is necessary to change from russian resources to other ones. And how much that cost to the actual European economy.
Please educate yourself before talking about things you clearly don't understand.
 
You clearly don't know crap about how much time is necessary to change from russian resources to other ones. And how much that cost to the actual European economy.
Please educate yourself before talking about things you clearly don't understand.
What's so special about Russian resources? These are resources, not aircraft parts, anyone's do the job.
 
What's so special about Russian resources? These are resources, not aircraft parts, anyone's do the job.
They are cheap, plenty, and near. Yes, they can be replaced, but is not easy, takes time (the best estimate is 2 to 5 years, the worst estimate is 5 to 10 years), and costs a lot more.
The joys of Just in Time economies and fully globalization.
For example, replacing Russian gas - which comes via gas pipelines - needs a lot of GPL harbors on both sides and a lot more of GPL ships. That's a lot of investment and takes years to make.
 
They are cheap, plenty, and near.
The world market exists, they aren't cheap but at market rates, Russia is not a charity and knows what the global market pricing of all resources is lol, and they are not that "near" economically as transport by land is pretty expensive.
Yes, they can be replaced, but is not easy, takes time (the best estimate is 2 to 5 years, the worst estimate is 5 to 10 years), and costs a lot more.
The joys of Just in Time economies and fully globalization.
For example, replacing Russian gas - which comes via gas pipelines - needs a lot of GPL harbors on both sides and a lot more of GPL ships. That's a lot of investment and takes years to make.
Some countries were already working on that "just in case" since 2014 or even earlier.
 
Yeah, right. Is because of that the cost of gas goes from 800€ per million cubic meters (? I'm not sure about the unit of measure, can be other but the value is right) to 1500€ and goes up. And that the EU in the summer is using the tank reserves instead of filling them.
Also, can you tell me the countries in the EU that have 'fixed' that problem? For real, not in political discourses, that value nothing.
 
Funny, let's see how better US performs in a scenario like Ukraine - oh, wait - they also have zero experience in that kind of war, and by the last time they are in one, not very well.

You mean Iraq 2003? they win war,and lost occupation.kgbstan is unable even to do so.

Oh, right. Tell me again, how that is going to help the German industry that needs a lot of gas to work - not coal. Without that, German industry collapsed, and Germany's economy go down - and btw, is the engine of the EU economy, so do the math. Not even talking about how that is possible for all other European countries dependent on Russian gas (and oil and coal).
Please, learn about how much the European economy is dependent on Russian resources before regurgitating propaganda.
Not even talking about the other resources that are critical to so many European industries - that are only competitive in the world game because of cheap Russian energy.
Bottom line - the EU is fucked hard without lube, anyone that thinks otherwise is a deluded/ignorant dreamer.

Making gas from coal.They have technology for that.And if they forget,Japan and Poland have it,too.
kgbstan is gas station with H bombs no needed by anyone by idiot german politicians,who wanted that for political goal - kick off USA from Europe,genocide us again and co-rule for eternity.

Idiots forget,that they have deal with german tsars - becouse sralin planned to backstab them probable before he proposed such alliance.And his Putin fanboy would do the same.

Well,if german leaders were smart,they would win both WW1 and WW2.
 
LOL - the Iraq war is a very easy war - something not on the same scale as the Ukrainian one. Any decent student of war knows that.
Making gas from coal - costs how much more than the actual price?
Please - if you can't offer anything more than ideology, stay quiet.
Oh, wait - I forget that's you.
 
Yeah, right. Is because of that the cost of gas goes from 800€ per million cubic meters (? I'm not sure about the unit of measure, can be other but the value is right) to 1500€ and goes up. And that the EU in the summer is using the tank reserves instead of filling them.
Also, can you tell me the countries in the EU that have 'fixed' that problem? For real, not in political discourses, that value nothing.
As i said, it was always an ideological fancy, not technological necessity. It can be lifted with a stroke of a pen. And in some countries the right pens are already in action.
Electricity made from coal is no different than electricity made from gas.
Yes, i know, greens very sad, muh climate catastrophe.
LOL - the Iraq war is a very easy war - something not on the same scale as the Ukrainian one. Any decent student of war knows that.
Making gas from coal - costs how much more than the actual price?
Please - if you can't offer anything more than ideology, stay quiet.
Oh, wait - I forget that's you.
It's being used by such rich technological superpowers like... Indonesia.
Obviously poor, backwards Germany could never afford that.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top