Star Wars Star Wars Discussion Thread - LET THE PAST D-! Oh, wait, nevermind

Bear Ribs

Well-known member
There is a downside to the Baneite system. You could easily loose knowledge of Sith teachings under it due to apprentices killing the master too soon or the master not thinking the ability that important.
That's not a downside, that's a feature. It ensures only the strongest, most worthy teachings will survive.
 

LindyAF

Well-known member
There is a downside to the Baneite system. You could easily loose knowledge of Sith teachings under it due to apprentices killing the master too soon or the master not thinking the ability that important.

In Legends IIRC there was a bunch of lost knowledge because the Sith Master at one point went insane (well... not the standard darkside insane) and started blowing up Sith Holocrons. There's a ton of downsides to the Baneite system on paper, which is why there's such an undercurrent of "the Baneites suck and aren't True Sith" in the fandom. The Sith Master could like fuckin' die of natural causes or an accident while they're still looking for an apprentice (or at the same time as their apprentice, if they have one), and then that's game over for the Sith, and given long enough that's going to happen at some point, probabilistically speaking.

Darth Bane and his philosophy make more sense when viewing him as ideological and quasi-religious about the Dark Side. To him, the statistics and probabilities don't matter because the Dark Side of the Force isn't going to let it happen, as long as they're true to it.
 

Zachowon

The Army Life for me! The POG life for me!
Founder
Slave 1 is no longer Boba Fetts spaceship name..being replaced by what I just said oddly enough

 

Battlegrinder

Someday we will win, no matter what it takes.
Moderator
Staff Member
Founder
Obozny
Slave 1 is no longer Boba Fetts spaceship name..being replaced by what I just said oddly enough


Slave 1 never really made any sense for what a bounty hunter would call his ship, so in principle I support the name change. But in practice....not so much, it's had the name for 40 years, if you're going to change it you need a more compelling reason to change it than "we're afraid SJWs on the internet might get offended". Like, if Fett had actually become a better person in the intervening years, which he has not, then a rename would work.
 

Buba

A total creep
What an exercise in futility, people will still call it Slave I regardless.
Which will be reason good enough for banning people on sites such as SV ...

In unrelated news - I think I'm done with trawling for SW fanfics on FFN. The lack of "exclude character" feature in the already lackluster search engine is killing me.
I'm really, really, REALLY not interested in anything featuring Darth Emo, Expressionaless Bimbo wearing garments with holes over arms in a desert climate, The Lucky Deserter, Mister "What Am I Doing Here?" Ginger, Token Evul! But Still Likeable Female Character, Discount Bin Han Solo Lite ...
AO3's filters culling fics with these characters (as well as modern setting or soulmarks) help me with practicing There is Passion yet there is Serenity :)
 

Buba

A total creep
FFN is lackluster for sure, but one of the few things it does have is a character exclusion filter. That's what the smaller set of "Without" filters right under the "plus" filters are for.
u my saver!!111
insert semi-coherent squee!squee! noises

I feel so dumb for looking at "without" for a decade or two and never wondering what it does ...

BTW - have any of you experienced a run-in with a fan for whom Ben/Rey is the best thing that ever happened to Star Wars?
 
Last edited:

BlackDragon98

Freikorps Kommandant
Banned - Politics
Slave 1 never really made any sense for what a bounty hunter would call his ship, so in principle I support the name change. But in practice....not so much, it's had the name for 40 years, if you're going to change it you need a more compelling reason to change it than "we're afraid SJWs on the internet might get offended". Like, if Fett had actually become a better person in the intervening years, which he has not, then a rename would work.
It sort of makes sense once you read Jango Fett: Open Seasons.

It's the Legends origin story of Jango; a Dark Horse comic.

Jango gets captured by the Jedi after a brutal battle on Galidraan and then he's handed over to an obviously corrupt planetary governor who sells him into slavery.

Jango eventually escapes and gets revenge on the governor.
 

DarthOne

☦️
u my saver!!111
insert semi-coherent squee!squee! noises

I feel so dumb for looking at "without" for a decade or two and never wondering what it dies ...

BTW - have any of you experienced a run-in with a fan for whom Ben/Rey is the best thing that ever happened to Star Wars?

I was about to say....

As for the Raylos, I can’t say I have myself. Then again I avoid Disney Wars like it’ll give me the plague. Though I am aware of their existence, much like I am of, say, slime mold.
 

LindyAF

Well-known member
Hot take: Kylo/Rey is actually kind of based.

Poorly executed though, and the "force dyad" stuff was dumb af.
 

Navarro

Well-known member
What an exercise in futility, people will still call it Slave I regardless.

Makes no sense in lore either; slavery is still a thing in the uncivilised and criminal-run parts of the SW universe, and those areas are Fett's territory.

Hot take: Kylo/Rey is actually kind of based.

Poorly executed though, and the "force dyad" stuff was dumb af.

It was a badly-written semi-romance written to appeal to teenage fangirls and Twilight-ise Star Wars between two people who have zero chemistry or narrative reason to be attracted to each other, hence the "Force Dyad" BS. There's no redeeming it. Kylo is only "cool" because he's the least emasculated of the male leads, and even he's pretty pathetic.
 
Last edited:

Husky_Khan

The Dog Whistler... I mean Whisperer.
Founder
Slave 1 is no longer Boba Fetts spaceship name..being replaced by what I just said oddly enough


Looks like Disney changed their minds and caved to the CCP again... Sad.

 

LTR

Don't Look Back In Anger
Administrator
Staff Member
Founder
All of these new Disney edits to the canon are going to result in Disney releasing a new edition of Star Wars for the fans to throw money at.

E4_jQd4XoAkGLiQ
 

StormEagle

Well-known member
u my saver!!111
insert semi-coherent squee!squee! noises

I feel so dumb for looking at "without" for a decade or two and never wondering what it does ...

BTW - have any of you experienced a run-in with a fan for whom Ben/Rey is the best thing that ever happened to Star Wars?

Didn’t the Raylos actually harass Adam Driver to try to get him to divorce his actual wife so that he could marry Ridley?
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top