mrttao
Well-known member
1. Jewish authorities can go fuck themselves.That Jews are a distinct ethnicity is not up for debate. Certainly not among Jewish authorities for one.
Of course you can find commonalities in genetic groups of varying scale, the difference is in fact a matter of scale. If those royal families were numbered in the millions, and had those genetic traits for sufficient time to sufficient degree, and drifted sufficiently from the populations they surrounded, they would be considered separate ethnicities.
2. Everything is up for debate
3. I didn't argue it is not an ethnicity. I disagreed with 1 of your specific arguments about the genetic component of what makes a jew a jew.
There are multiple different jewish ethnicities, each one of them has far more in common with its parent ethnicity than with other jews. And they are barely held together by a common thread (victim complex / "antisemitism") rather than genetics.