East Palestine Ohio Train Crash & Poison Gas Plume Megathread

Cherico

Well-known member
Okay am I crazy or is there a reasonable explanation for why all these trains are derailing so near each other time wise like is it’s weather conditions in all these different states or are all our tracks just magically failing all at once. It’s weird and I wish all the state governments involved did a investigation into whoever is in charge of track and train maintenance and upkeep this is getting ridiculous.

That would be Pete he is in charge of transportation and this is his only job.
 

hyperspacewizard

Well-known member
That would be Pete he is in charge of transportation and this is his only job.
I’m mean closer to on the ground level (the state or company manger someone who should be looking at these trains and tracks semi regularly) I’m just suspicious of all this happening so close together. One accidental sure but five all with in a week or two of each other feels planned to me.
I’m wish Pete would do his job too or face some kind of consequence but I just want an explanation and a fix to all these derailments.

I’m sure the actual workers where sounding some kind of alarm for years or months but where ignored that’s usually how that goes.
 

Marduk

Well-known member
Moderator
Staff Member
Okay it’s still crazy that so many are happening so close to one another no matter the causes behind them maybe it’s just being reported on more but the frequency hasn’t changed? I know that happens sometimes with stuff like this.
The media has decided that it's a topic to talk about due to few high profile ones.
Meanwhile, the full statistic, averaging since the 90's, is several derailments per day.
From 1990, the first year the BTS began tracking derailments and injuries on a yearly basis, to 2021, there have been 54,539 accidents in which a train derailed. That's an average of 1,704 derailments per year.
 

hyperspacewizard

Well-known member
The media has decided that it's a topic to talk about due to few high profile ones.
Meanwhile, the full statistic, averaging since the 90's, is several derailments per day.
Thank you I appreciate the info while on one hand that stops the conspiracy part of my brain holy crap that’s a lot and needs to be fixed like Cherico said every bit or Americas infrastructure needs to be reviewed and fixed or replaced.
 

Prince Ire

Section XIII
For a bit of added context, the owners in that case were found innocent on manslaughter charges and while they had to pay a fee of $75 per worker, they received over five times that amount per worker in payouts from their insurance company.
Okay am I crazy or is there a reasonable explanation for why all these trains are derailing so near each other time wise like is it’s weather conditions in all these different states or are all our tracks just magically failing all at once. It’s weird and I wish all the state governments involved did a investigation into whoever is in charge of track and train maintenance and upkeep this is getting ridiculous.
~1700 trains derail per year in the US.
 

Bear Ribs

Well-known member
For a bit of added context, the owners in that case were found innocent on manslaughter charges and while they had to pay a fee of $75 per worker, they received over five times that amount per worker in payouts from their insurance company.
Even worse, that was the fifth time it happened to the owners, each time mysteriously when the garment they were manufacturing went out of fashion and they'd need expensive replacements of the factory equipment unless it happened to burn down and insurance companies would pay for replacement manufactories.

And two years later they were caught locking their workers in a firetrap again... and got fined a grand total of twenty dollars.
 

PsihoKekec

Swashbuckling Accountant
bfe220ab71346102.jpeg


Many blame the precision scheduled railroading along with cutting costs in maintenance, for such state of matters in a first world nation. Basically, the personnel numbers are cut to minimum or bellow it (it looks great in quarterly report to shareholders), maintenance is often outsourced to a lowest bid contractor (it looks great in quarterly report to shareholders), while tight schedules leave a little slack for any inconvenience.
 

Marduk

Well-known member
Moderator
Staff Member
bfe220ab71346102.jpeg


Many blame the precision scheduled railroading along with cutting costs in maintenance, for such state of matters in a first world nation. Basically, the personnel numbers are cut to minimum or bellow it (it looks great in quarterly report to shareholders), maintenance is often outsourced to a lowest bid contractor (it looks great in quarterly report to shareholders), while tight schedules leave a little slack for any inconvenience.
So, shit breaks because someone doesn't maintain the train parts or railroad sections.
Why are insurers and regulators ok with this, especially for hazmat transports? It doesn't take a genius to figure out that ignoring such problems will lead to accidents and they will have to pay out.
If that happened in aircraft or even ships, the insurer would drop the offender like a hot potato.
 

Rocinante

Russian Bot
Founder
So, shit breaks because someone doesn't maintain the train parts or railroad sections.
Why are insurers and regulators ok with this, especially for hazmat transports? It doesn't take a genius to figure out that ignoring such problems will lead to accidents and they will have to pay out.
If that happened in aircraft or even ships, the insurer would drop the offender like a hot potato.
The amount they need to pay out is probably smaller than all the bribes they get.

And the amount the companies get fined is less than the insurance payout they get.
 
Last edited:

Karmic Acumen

Well-known member
Apparently, the CDC changed toxicity info on vinyl chloride days before the derailment.

"The CDC update changed the lethal exposure from 100PPM to 100,000PPM. The lethal exposure level had remained the same for 17 years before the CDC decided to update the number just prior to the derailment, where highly toxic chemicals spilled or were burned off, leaving a chemical stench in the air nearly two weeks later."


Weird, huh?
 

Bacle

When the effort is no longer profitable...
Founder
So, shit breaks because someone doesn't maintain the train parts or railroad sections.
Why are insurers and regulators ok with this, especially for hazmat transports? It doesn't take a genius to figure out that ignoring such problems will lead to accidents and they will have to pay out.
If that happened in aircraft or even ships, the insurer would drop the offender like a hot potato.
Because unlike aircraft and ships, trains are much more fixed to specific infrastructure, which is owned by a decreasing number of companies, and new rail lines can take decades to get approved, never mind built.

And that's before you get to the overworked, underpaid, and nearly wage-slave conditions some railroads operators in the US force on their employees.

All that matters to the US rail companies is quarterly earnings, not the long term.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top