As a spectator after the fact, I could tell from early on that you'd misread him to include Muslims in those who would potentially be killed as idolaters when he had clearly excluded them. When you play that kind of rhetorical game you gotta make sure your details are right. Otherwise you spend "a dozen replies" asking the same loaded question that unbeknownst to you is loaded with a blank.
You know, I actually took the time to read through some of the article you link here.You do realize that the 7 laws of Noah are to be applied to the whole world all of mankind yes.
Seven Laws of Noah - Wikipedia
en.wikipedia.org
In Judaism the rightful punishment for idolatry is death. Now that means lots of dead Buddhists, Shinto, Hindus, etc. But more importantly Christians since Jewish commentary has generally said that Christianity is idol worship and is not monotheism(unless you are unitarian)
Now sure Jews are like 1 percent of the population and won't be able to wipe out millions. But the same argument applies to Muslims they won't be able to militarily invade and occupy Christian nations. So are we talking about what the religion says should be done, or what it is capable of doing?
Sure Islam is stronger, but the victory condition of each is different. Sure Islam conquering Christian lands is bad, very bad 2nd class citizenship and Dhimmitude. But at least Christianity is still allowed to be, and is not illegal.
Your point? This isn’t about practicality. This is about the law on the books. Islam orders the enslavment of Christians and Jews. Judaism orders that the legal penalty for idolatry is death. Those are facts I’m not smearing either religion when I say this it’s not an insult or whatever.
My post that you were replying to was entirely about the practical threat of Judaism vs Islam.
You are talking about practical? Then both arguments are stupid because Islam can’t conquer the world either that’s not practical it won’t happen.
They can and will try, and they have slaughtered and enslaved millions over the centuries in their efforts.
So comparative religion. Do you think Judaism is a special religion and it’s the true religion?
You're both assuming things of me that are false, and asserting things that aren't rational.
How so? My position is that there is very little differance between false religions. There might be some academic thing. But one false religion is not more noble or good than another. Islam and Judaism are false, they have a grain of truth that being monotheism. But neither are complete.
The difference is that Islam has been waging war against Christianity almost non stop since it's founding. Judaism hasn't been even slightly dangerous since the Jewish revolts against the Romans.
Agree.No matter how bad Izrael is,turks are worst.
Can confirm because...well I dated three of them.
I see hard to believe or hope for.
