Neoreacshunary Kat Sez - NRx Memes And Stuff

ATP said:
But we still must fight.Saint Joanna of Arc said,that if knight would fight,God would send victory.And she defeated englismen,when everybody else thought that it was impossible.
We need miracle,true - but it would not happen,if we do not act.We must gave God chance to act.
Click to expand...

Holy Fools and Blessed Idiots are a thing.
 
ATP said:
But we still must fight.Saint Joanna of Arc said,that if knight would fight,God would send victory.And she defeated englismen,when everybody else thought that it was impossible.
We need miracle,true - but it would not happen,if we do not act.We must gave God chance to act.
Click to expand...

That is true. But hope can be a disadvantage - if you have it and you lose it, it is worse than if you never had it.
 
ATP said:
But we still must fight.Saint Joanna of Arc said,that if knight would fight,God would send victory.And she defeated englismen,when everybody else thought that it was impossible.
We need miracle,true - but it would not happen,if we do not act.We must gave God chance to act.
Click to expand...
Joan of Arc is but a myth, victory was due to the French reorganising their army and attriting English forces, she was a disposable figurehead, while experienced professionals really led the army.
 
PsihoKekec said:
Joan of Arc is but a myth, victory was due to the French reorganising their army and attriting English forces, she was a disposable figurehead, while experienced professionals really led the army.
Click to expand...

They led the army,but start winning only under her command.
 
Last edited:
PsihoKekec said:
Joan of Arc is but a myth, victory was due to the French reorganising their army and attriting English forces, she was a disposable figurehead, while experienced professionals really led the army.
Click to expand...
Eh, I have only ever seen conflicting statements about that
 
ATP said:
They led the army,but start winning only under her command.
Click to expand...
She never commanded the army, she was only a figurehead and the French were winning battles and skirmishes before she showed up. She was just a propaganda tool to lift the morale.
 
PsihoKekec said:
She never commanded the army, she was only a figurehead and the French were winning battles and skirmishes before she showed up. She was just a propaganda tool to lift the morale.
Click to expand...
Then why they could not win any battle before ?
 
ATP said:
Then why they could not win any battle before ?
Click to expand...
They won multiple battles before they started using her for propaganda. In between the Agincourt and Orleans, La Brossniere and Bauge were clear French victories along with couple of resisted sieges.
 
PsihoKekec said:
She never commanded the army, she was only a figurehead and the French were winning battles and skirmishes before she showed up. She was just a propaganda tool to lift the morale.
Click to expand...
Never underestimate the value of morale; because more often than not, it's proven to be the deciding factor in war. Even if boosting it was all she did, she still served her country with distinction, risking her life in the process, and deserved far more than what she got in the end.
 
Largo said:
Why Israel?
I mean, I can think of reasons why this meme picked Israel. None of them are good reasons.
Click to expand...

Israel in this context I would see as a "for example" - hardly the only one.
Consider the case of a Japanese-American who vocally argues that the USA should be open to immigration to all, with no ethnic identity of its own, etc etc.... but that his ancestral country of Japan should remain monoethnic because reasons.
The double standard raises questions.

GoldRanger said:
Okay, I skimmed the thread. The reason the meme says the person flees to Israel is clearly to imply that disloyal Jews are behind the machinations that ruin society, and said Jews meanwhile free themselves of the consequences of their actions by fleeing to the place they're "really" loyal to. Textbook antisemitism.
Click to expand...

Are you denying that there are Jews who behave like that? Such people exist. Every ethnic group in this world has some criminal elements, and Jews are not an exception. Doesn't mean everyone in that nation is like that.

Imagine if anytime we tried to discuss the problems caused by the South American drug cartels, lots of people would refuse to acknowledge that the cartels even existed, left they get accused of being anti-Latino?

And this is all a bit tangential to the real problem with "Civic Nationalism" as a practical concept.
 
Scottty said:
Israel in this context I would see as a "for example" - hardly the only one.
Consider the case of a Japanese-American who vocally argues that the USA should be open to immigration to all, with no ethnic identity of its own, etc etc.... but that his ancestral country of Japan should remain monoethnic because reasons.
The double standard raises questions.



Are you denying that there are Jews who behave like that? Such people exist. Every ethnic group in this world has some criminal elements, and Jews are not an exception. Doesn't mean everyone in that nation is like that.

Imagine if anytime we tried to discuss the problems caused by the South American drug cartels, lots of people would refuse to acknowledge that the cartels even existed, left they get accused of being anti-Latino?

And this is all a bit tangential to the real problem with "Civic Nationalism" as a practical concept.
Click to expand...

But Israel is not refusing to acknowledge that wokeism exists. Neither do "Jews" as a collective. There are all kinds of Jews in America, conservative as well as liberal, even if most vote Democrat that doesn't mean all Jews support the woke progressive movements. Leave us and our country out of your petty internal race issues.

EDIT: "Some Jews exist like that", sure, then why emphasize them over the other Jews, or over other ethnicities? The only reason is to "wink wink, nudge nudge, we know who is REALLY behind all this".
 
civic-nationalism.jpg
 
Scottty said:
Israel in this context I would see as a "for example" - hardly the only one.
Consider the case of a Japanese-American who vocally argues that the USA should be open to immigration to all, with no ethnic identity of its own, etc etc.... but that his ancestral country of Japan should remain monoethnic because reasons.
The double standard raises questions.
Click to expand...
I'm trying to figure out whether this is specifically targeted at me or not. But as GoldRanger said, that this meme specifically raises all sort of alarm bells. It's no different from how you'll find liberals arguing about how ethno-nationalist states shouldn't exist, but for some strange reason Israel is the only country they target with that attack.
 
Last edited:
Largo said:
I'm trying to figure out whether this is specifically targeted at me or not. But as GoldRanger said, that this meme specifically raises all sort of alarm bells. It's no different from how you'll find arguing about how ethno-nationalist states shouldn't exist, but for some strange reason Israel is the only country they target with that attack.
Click to expand...

I'm sure that has nothing at all to do with the massive double standard of ethnonationalism for Israel always but never ever for anyone else.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 0, guests: 1)
Back
Top