• The Sietch will be brought offline for HPG systems maintenance tomorrow (Thursday, 2 May 2024). Please remain calm and do not start any interstellar wars while ComStar is busy. May the Peace of Blake be with you. Precentor Dune

Web Content Why is "booktube" overwhelmingly leftwing?

Lord Sovereign

The resident Britbong
I mean seriously, every Book You Tuber, or one that commits itself to the craft of writing, is lefty. Without fail all of them have turned on JK Rowling for her "transphobic views" and I'm just wondering why. Is there something about fantasy, sci-fi or just general fiction that attracts lefties like moths to a flame? That doesn't seem to apply in the same way to film reviewers, or at least since Mauler bent TLJ defenders over his knee and spanked them.
 

Lord Sovereign

The resident Britbong
Probably because most authors in general are leftist, most English departments are leftists, et cetera.

Hell, even Brandon Sanderson and Orson Scott Card were against Trump, and they are about as conservative as you get in mainstream science fiction in America.

To a lesser extent Shadiversity counts, but his political orientation is Castles.

One would think there's a market for genuine conservatives in both book tube and the actual writing industry. As someone who wants to be a writer, I have considered making a writing channel. Then again, I'd probably get banned quickly. "If you want proportionate representation, make one person gay out of a named cast of fifty people" wouldn't go down well with the usual crowd.
 

Captain X

Well-known member
Osaul
One obvious reason is that sci-fi basically got taken over by leftists going all the way back to the 1930s. This has allowed them to gatekeep to an extent, and it has only gotten easier for them to do so. Because of this, sci-fi has a reputation for being "progressive," using itself as a platform to get secret messages past censors and the like through the use of allegory, which in turn has drawn more lefties to it because the idea of secret messages makes them feel smart for figuring them out, and being able to put them into their own work. And I imagine there's also something of a bandwagon effect going on.
 

Lord Sovereign

The resident Britbong
One obvious reason is that sci-fi basically got taken over by leftists going all the way back to the 1930s. This has allowed them to gatekeep to an extent, and it has only gotten easier for them to do so. Because of this, sci-fi has a reputation for being "progressive," using itself as a platform to get secret messages past censors and the like through the use of allegory, which in turn has drawn more lefties to it because the idea of secret messages makes them feel smart for figuring them out, and being able to put them into their own work. And I imagine there's also something of a bandwagon effect going on.

So essentially any righty that would like to write sci-fi, or fantasy, or would like to have a go at book tube, has their work cut out? It is a humbling thing to realise just how far back society's current woes go.
 

ATP

Well-known member
One obvious reason is that sci-fi basically got taken over by leftists going all the way back to the 1930s. This has allowed them to gatekeep to an extent, and it has only gotten easier for them to do so. Because of this, sci-fi has a reputation for being "progressive," using itself as a platform to get secret messages past censors and the like through the use of allegory, which in turn has drawn more lefties to it because the idea of secret messages makes them feel smart for figuring them out, and being able to put them into their own work. And I imagine there's also something of a bandwagon effect going on.

So,we have soviet science fiction now ? It would be funny,but since we have soviet USA president,then why not ?
 

AnimalNoodles

Well-known member
I mean seriously, every Book You Tuber, or one that commits itself to the craft of writing, is lefty. Without fail all of them have turned on JK Rowling for her "transphobic views" and I'm just wondering why. Is there something about fantasy, sci-fi or just general fiction that attracts lefties like moths to a flame? That doesn't seem to apply in the same way to film reviewers, or at least since Mauler bent TLJ defenders over his knee and spanked them.

Because publishing is dominated by women.
 

ParadiseLost

Well-known member
I wonder what it would take to start up a publishing company?

Publishing doesn't mean all that much when Amazon has a massive share of the market.

Amazon sells 50%+ of print books and 75%+ of Ebooks.

And really, anyone can sell on Amazon.

If you just used Amazon's distribution network to sell books, you could make a deal with printing companies and sell them yourself on Amazon. Of course, I'd be shocked if you managed to make something profitable.

Self-publishing is simply the future.

Sometimes, people talk about how physical book sales are still 10x more than kindle book sales, but that ignores two important realities:

1) Print books are more expensive and resellable simply MUST be sold at a higher price than kindle books;

and 2) An author must sale way more print books to make a proper income.

2 is especially important, as it essentially guarantees self-published full time authors will eventually outnumber traditionally published full time authors.

For example, say John Doe wants to be a full time author, and to go full time, he needs to hit $60,000 in income.

With a traditional publishing model, his book might sell for $20, and as a first time author, he might get $4 per copy sold. In order to make $60,000, he has to sell 15,000 copies, or $300,000 worth of books.

With say, the Amazon model, he can sell at $9.99 and get about $6.90, meaning he only has to sell ~8700 ebooks, or $87,000 in merchandise.

Needless to say, its easier to sell a $10 product than a $20 product, all else being equal.

He only has to sell about 60% of the number of books, and he can do it at 50% of the price.

The biggest issue is the marketing. If you can do the marketing yourself, you're set.
 

Val the Moofia Boss

Well-known member
To a lesser extent Shadiversity counts, but his political orientation is Castles.

One would think there's a market for genuine conservatives in both book tube and the actual writing industry. As someone who wants to be a writer, I have considered making a writing channel. Then again, I'd probably get banned quickly. "If you want proportionate representation, make one person gay out of a named cast of fifty people" wouldn't go down well with the usual crowd.

There is the newpup movement. The most prolific newpup authors I can think of are Brian Niemeier, David V. Stewart, and Jon Del Arroz.

If you want to write books, David V. Stewart's channel is a treasure trove of info on writing tips, how to design your covers, how to publish your book, how to grow your brand, etc.

The hardest part is growing your brand.

I wonder what it would take to start up a publishing company?

Old pup is a dead end. Don't wait for gatekeepers to choose you. Choose yourself.

Publishing doesn't mean all that much when Amazon has a massive share of the market.

Amazon sells 50%+ of print books and 75%+ of Ebooks.

This. People stick with what they already know and that's Amazon. Going to Barnes & Noble, creating an account, inputting your payment info, and buying a book there is too much of a hassle for most people. Also, people only really leave reviews for books on Amazon, and reviews are very important in getting people to buy your book.

That being said, Amazon has been steadily getting worse over the years. It is becoming impossible for customers to find what they want, and they don't know whether or not what they are buying is good. This has resulted in customers simply no longer buying books from Amazon. Amazon's search engine algorhythym doesn't show customers what they want. Amazon is trying to extract money from authors by allowing authors to buy advertisements for their books that make them appear in searches. Other publishers have success because they have quality control. People are okay buying books from them because they know it will be a good book. Some people think those other book stores will get a leg up soon.
 

Aaron Fox

Well-known member
Historically, books and novels have been used to literally tell everyone various hypocrisy and ugly shit that the general populous didn't know that their society has been keeping behind the curtain, so to speak. This opened the door to what would become SciFi in general... and back in the 1930s until the careers of men like Issac 'I wrote a book in every genre during his lifetime' Asimov took off. It took off again after Necromancer (aka the first cyberpunk novel) was published and it combined fiction's tendency to reveal the ugly shit of reality with sci-fi elements.

If it wasn't for books like The Jungle (which, by the way, helped us make food and medicine actually healthy), we would be in a shittier position overall.

That's why books have been 'left wing' and people forget that.
 

ATP

Well-known member
Let me get a clarification first:
You are wondering why english speaking intellectuals in an artistic field, who also interact on social media, are socially liberal?

Anyways, if you are so intent on finding RW writers, I suggest finding some retired Marine. They hate everyone, and are unlikely to be of intellectual bent.

No need.Kratman arleady created entire series about woke Earth,second Earth where people made the same countries like on OLD and made the same history,and where his alter ego is conqering such Earth.

And i would be OK with it,if he not copy-pasted history from Eart to Eart 2.
Basically all nations /or rather trouble makers from them/ was send to places when they lived on Eart,left,degenerated to 17th century level technology - and they ,knowing how history looked like,copied it.
So we have equivalent of 20th century Earth with wokes taking over after two WW,with USA,UE and China exactly like in our times.
Not possible.
 
Last edited:

Users who are viewing this thread

Top