Serious question about anti-Semitism.

Can you ever not make shit about 'whiteness' and your obsession with how 'the Jews' are just another group going against 'whites'?
I mean it’s the thread topic and I was responding entirely to the post at hand. If I wasn’t talking about antisemitism and by extent Jews then that would be entirely off topic. In this case I was pointing out how there are lots and lots of groups that will go extremely hard against even the slightest wiff of antisemitism.


Here’s the ADL attempting to get Tucker Carlson fired, for example. As such, acts like this will be heavily condemned and seen as evil.
 
Ah, I see. The more you know! Cheers.

Jews also made up over 25% of donations to the Republican National Convention as well. In 2008 21% voted for McCain, 30% for Romney, and 24% for Trump in 2016 and 22% in 2020... it had actually dropped to 17% support in 2018 and likely due to the issues pertaining to Charlottesville. Since the FDR era Jewish support for Republicans has ranged from 10% for Barry Goldwater in 1964 to as high as 39% for Ronald Reagan in 1980. Trump is like two percentage points below the average Jewish support for Republicans.
 
Jews also made up over 25% of donations to the Republican National Convention as well.

A quarter of the total donations to Rs but half of the total donations to Ds is a hell of an influence, not just on each party separately but on American politics as a whole. And, if you're here, I think it's safe to assume we all generally think that a net impact swinging American politics towards the dems is a negative.
 
A quarter of the total donations to Rs but half of the total donations to Ds is a hell of an influence, not just on each party separately but on American politics as a whole. And, if you're here, I think it's safe to assume we all generally think that a net impact swinging American politics towards the dems is a negative.
If Jewish Americans aren't donating as much to R's, perhaps the R's should consider WHY that is, and look at maybe changing some planks of their platform.

Too many in the GOP seem to act like they are OWED the money and loyalty of people simply for not being Dems.

Maybe if the GOP humbled itself and stopped acting like it's shit don't stink, it'd have a better image among certain groups.

This isn't to say the Dems don't have similar problems with feeling they are owed people's votes, and an even bigger problem with blatant anti-semitism among it's ranks.
 
If Jewish Americans aren't donating as much to R's, perhaps the R's should consider WHY that is, and look at maybe changing some planks of their platform.

Too many in the GOP seem to act like they are OWED the money and loyalty of people simply for not being Dems.

Maybe if the GOP humbled itself and stopped acting like it's shit don't stink, it'd have a better image among certain groups.

This isn't to say the Dems don't have similar problems with feeling they are owed people's votes, and an even bigger problem with blatant anti-semitism among it's ranks.
What specifically should conservatives do to court Jewish votes? Because the right in our nation kisses more Israeli ass then the left. So helping their fellow Jews does not seem to be enough. Do these liberal limousine jews want to basically just stop conservatives from being conservative? Be another wing of the democratic party.
 
What specifically should conservatives do to court Jewish votes? Because the right in our nation kisses more Israeli ass then the left. So helping their fellow Jews does not seem to be enough. Do these liberal limousine jews want to basically just stop conservatives from being conservative? Be another wing of the democratic party.
I would point to the same image problems the GOP has with a lot of other minority groups; too many people who seem to view the white, Christian perspective/life as the central axis of American culture and identity.

And with the Jews in particular, the whole 'support Israel because of the prophecies in the Book of Revelations and desire for them to happen' crowd among American Evangelicals probably does not help things at all.

Also, don't expect someone who is Jewish to share the same views as the Orthodox Jews or be innately 'conservative'.
 
I would point to the same image problems the GOP has with a lot of other minority groups; too many people who seem to view the white, Christian perspective/life as the central axis of American culture and identity.
The GOP politicians and party don’t lol.


If Jewish Americans aren't donating as much to R's, perhaps the R's should consider WHY that is, and look at maybe changing some planks of their platform.
because politically Jews lean towards liberal internationalism lol. We get the Orthodox vote typically as well as some of the Zionist vote, but the why is in their politics, and to change the planks to court more of the Jewish vote would be things like supporting gun control, open borders, supporting mega corporations, bigger government, higher taxes, adopting all left wing social issues, and becoming Democrats basically. That’s an extremely dumb idea, literally what you are advocating for is RINO politics, to say, “hey right wing base of people, go fuck yourself. We aren’t going to represent what you want, but we are going to court more liberal and minority voters by abandoning what you actually want, and expecting you to just vote for us even though we do not appeal to our actual base at all, because at least we aren’t the Democrats.” Are you a fan of the Lincoln Project by chance?


And with the Jews in particular, the whole 'support Israel because of the prophecies in the Book of Revelations and desire for them to happen' crowd among American Evangelicals probably does not help things at all.
Ah, so the smear campaign of the new atheists to bring a tiny fraction of randos to be the prominent face?
 
Last edited:
I would point to the same image problems the GOP has with a lot of other minority groups; too many people who seem to view the white, Christian perspective/life as the central axis of American culture and identity.

And with the Jews in particular, the whole 'support Israel because of the prophecies in the Book of Revelations and desire for them to happen' crowd among American Evangelicals probably does not help things at all.

Also, don't expect someone who is Jewish to share the same views as the Orthodox Jews or be innately 'conservative'.

The GOP has an image problem with minorities because the Democrats have been lying about them with full support of the (Democrat) media ever since they realized that racism wasn't cool anymore.

No amount of pandering can reverse this problem. The only thing that will help is improving communication skills for telling the truth.
 
No amount of pandering can reverse this problem. The only thing that will help is improving communication skills for telling the truth.
Minorities also across the board lean politically left. Their views are left wing on most issues. Blacks tend to be more anti-gay than whites and Hispanics tend to be Christians, so social conservatism and economic populism can pick up more minorities but it can’t pick up a majority. Jews, on the other hand, are the most left wing and liberal demographic in the nation and as a group have the most sway and control over democrat politics. The current democrat party reflects what their interests are more than any other group. To try to appeal to them would be to somehow outdo the Democrats in being Democrats.
 
Can you ever not make shit about 'whiteness' and your obsession with how 'the Jews' are just another group going against 'whites'?
I dunno about whites,but Poland is attacked by Russia,Germany,leftist and jews.All blame us for german or soviet crimes.
 
I would point to the same image problems the GOP has with a lot of other minority groups; too many people who seem to view the white, Christian perspective/life as the central axis of American culture and identity.

And with the Jews in particular, the whole 'support Israel because of the prophecies in the Book of Revelations and desire for them to happen' crowd among American Evangelicals probably does not help things at all.

Also, don't expect someone who is Jewish to share the same views as the Orthodox Jews or be innately 'conservative'.
Most American Christians are idiots heretics who don't know how to interpret the Bible what else is new. But the support for Israel has very little to do with Revelations. Most of the people who butcher the Bible to support Israel use Genesis "I will bless those who bless you, and curse those who curse you." They think Jews are the chosen race of God.
 
Yeah, Barcle, you've been in a right wing space for, what, 1 year? 2? 4 years at this point?

Have you ever seen revelations brought up by a right winger for pro or Anti jew/Israel opinions in all your years here? Or is that something only left wingers bring up as their explanation for why right wingers support israel?

You still do not seem to have internalized how much of what you "know" about the right are just lies, or effectively so.

Like, think. When did mainstream Christianity decide Jews were critical to Armageddon, which is something to be accelerated? When the crusaders were driving out/killing the Jews in Jeuruselem? When did the Catholic church abandon the idea that revelations describes the events of the fall of Roman empire?

What Christians are we talking about?
 
The idea that conservatives support Israel because of some kind of end time prophesy is completely absurd. It’s a lie that leftists tell so that they can claim that Republicans are anti-semites despite their typically strong support for Israel. I’ve seen it often repeated on SB but I don’t recall ever talking to a conservative who believed that. Even among Fundamentalist Christians, who are a minority among Republicans, it’s a fringe belief and not a factor in the GOP’s or America’s attitude towards Israel.

Republicans who like Israel overwhelmingly do so for secular reasons, though more moderate religious motivations are a factor: like Judaism’s ties to Christianity, their central role in the Bible, or even that Jews are God’s chosen people and that helping them gets God’s blessing.

For the most part, “minorities” (not just racial groups and Jews but also women and alphabet) support the Democrats because they are leftists and trying to appeal to them would involve going further to the left. Would that work? Of course not, the Republican Party has been trying that for decades and when they move to the left, then the Democrats can themselves move even further to the left. When you abandon your principles to become more like your opponent, you lose even when you win, because your victory only serves their agenda and not the one your party once fought for. Which is probably a major reason why the GOP isn’t very good. The salt has lost its saltiness, to paraphrase the Bible.

To some degree, various demographic groups that the leftists venerate have been tricked by leftist media control to think that conservatives are bigoted. The real problem, though, is that those supposedly underprivileged demographic groups support the Democrats for the gibs, not because they actually think they are persecuted.
 
To some degree, various demographic groups that the leftists venerate have been tricked by leftist media control to think that conservatives are bigoted. The real problem, though, is that those supposedly underprivileged demographic groups support the Democrats for the gibs, not because they actually think they are persecuted.
In the case of the American Jewish demographic it’s one of the most wealthy, well educated demographics that the world has ever seen with disproportionate representation in every aspect of power and influence, and given how money and donations and lobbying works have more sway over democrat policy in determining what it is. It’s not a demographic the right could hope to take by changing anything because that demographic as demonstrated works more to set what Democrat is and to a lesser extent Republican policy rather than being the people who these policies are trying to capture.
 
The idea that conservatives support Israel because of some kind of end time prophesy is completely absurd. It’s a lie that leftists tell so that they can claim that Republicans are anti-semites despite their typically strong support for Israel. I’ve seen it often repeated on SB but I don’t recall ever talking to a conservative who believed that. Even among Fundamentalist Christians, who are a minority among Republicans, it’s a fringe belief and not a factor in the GOP’s or America’s attitude towards Israel.

Republicans who like Israel overwhelmingly do so for secular reasons, though more moderate religious motivations are a factor: like Judaism’s ties to Christianity, their central role in the Bible, or even that Jews are God’s chosen people and that helping them gets God’s blessing.

For the most part, “minorities” (not just racial groups and Jews but also women and alphabet) support the Democrats because they are leftists and trying to appeal to them would involve going further to the left. Would that work? Of course not, the Republican Party has been trying that for decades and when they move to the left, then the Democrats can themselves move even further to the left. When you abandon your principles to become more like your opponent, you lose even when you win, because your victory only serves their agenda and not the one your party once fought for. Which is probably a major reason why the GOP isn’t very good. The salt has lost its saltiness, to paraphrase the Bible.

To some degree, various demographic groups that the leftists venerate have been tricked by leftist media control to think that conservatives are bigoted. The real problem, though, is that those supposedly underprivileged demographic groups support the Democrats for the gibs, not because they actually think they are persecuted.
In the case of the American Jewish demographic it’s one of the most wealthy, well educated demographics that the world has ever seen with disproportionate representation in every aspect of power and influence, and given how money and donations and lobbying works have more sway over democrat policy in determining what it is. It’s not a demographic the right could hope to take by changing anything because that demographic as demonstrated works more to set what Democrat is and to a lesser extent Republican policy rather than being the people who these policies are trying to capture.
Have conservatives ever considered principles don't put food on the table, but gibs will?

The absolute hate for welfare programs on the Right is one of the biggest reasons the Left is able to paint the Right as heartless.

Automation is destroying the paradigm that conservatives built their whole world view around when it comes to work and life. The Left understands this, the Right seems to just want to stick it's fingers in their ears and repeat mantra's about the free market.
 
Have conservatives ever considered principles don't put food on the table, but gibs will?

The absolute hate for welfare programs on the Right is one of the biggest reasons the Left is able to paint the Right as heartless.

Gibs are unpopular with the Jewish Right, at least as far as I've seen, although if you or someone else has counter-examples, go for it.

Edit: As in, it seems more unpopular than it is with the rest of the (mostly White) Right (in contrast to say Black/Mexican Right where it's probably unpopular but more popular than with the White Right). Here using Ethnicity X Right to mean those on the Right who are X, not those on the Right who are explicitly pro-X.
 
Have conservatives ever considered principles don't put food on the table, but gibs will?

The absolute hate for welfare programs on the Right is one of the biggest reasons the Left is able to paint the Right as heartless.

Automation is destroying the paradigm that conservatives built their whole world view around when it comes to work and life. The Left understands this, the Right seems to just want to stick it's fingers in their ears and repeat mantra's about the free market.
This I will agree with you on to a degree. We shouldn't just have flat out gibs for nothing, but we should bring back something like the Civillian Conservation Corps. So that people will be given a stipend for being loyal citizens who can be called up to work on projects that are needed. However this is dodging the point everyone is making.
 
Gibs are unpopular with the Jewish Right, at least as far as I've seen, although if you or someone else has counter-examples, go for it.

Edit: As in, it seems more unpopular than it is with the rest of the (mostly White) Right (in contrast to say Black/Mexican Right where it's probably unpopular but more popular than with the White Right). Here using Ethnicity X Right to mean those on the Right who are X, not those on the Right who are explicitly pro-X.
Well, if the amount of Jews who are pro-gibs outweighs the amount of anti-gibs Jews, perhaps being more pro-gibs would increase the amount of Jews who vote R.

It seems like pretty simple math to me.
This I will agree with you on to a degree. We shouldn't just have flat out gibs for nothing, but we should bring back something like the Civillian Conservation Corps. So that people will be given a stipend for being loyal citizens who can be called up to work on projects that are needed. However this is dodging the point everyone is making.
I would have no objection to bringing back the CCC, and think it would be a great idea.

However, that isn't what 'gibs' are; gibs are things Food Stamp's, WIC, the 'stimulus' checks, and UBI.
 
Have conservatives ever considered principles don't put food on the table, but gibs will?

The absolute hate for welfare programs on the Right is one of the biggest reasons the Left is able to paint the Right as heartless.
The welfare state has also done fuck all for people except expand the role of government and been a way to pay people for votes and fuck over the natural social charities and institutions.


conservatives built their whole world view around when it comes to work and life. The Left understands this, the Right seems to just want to stick it's fingers in their ears and repeat mantra's about the free market.
Not really and not anymore. That’s more establishment politics, not what’s in vogue with the people. I certainly don’t. Now the mantra is bring back jobs from overseas, end free trade, rebuild American industries, cut down on immigration which takes away jobs from the American people. America First, and making the American people come first once again. Americanism, not globalism.




Well, if the amount of Jews who are pro-gibs outweighs the amount of anti-gibs Jews, perhaps being more pro-gibs would increase the amount of Jews who vote R.

It seems like pretty simple math to me.
No lol, because it’s an all encompassing world view that makes the differential, not a single issue. Most of them adhere to left wing social values and liberal internationalist politics and neoliberal capitalism, or just straight up internationalist socialism. Changing one thing doesn’t increase the vote, especially considering that this is the highest educated and one of the highest and most active political participants. This means that most are not single issue voters either. Certainly, if Trumps Israel boner couldn’t increase it dramatically increased welfare programs certainly won’t, especially as Jewish people are quite literally the last demographic who needs any sort of welfare what so ever. Nearly half of all Jews make a six figure a year income or more. It’s the wealthiest, most employed, highest income demographic in the nation.

Now, what you are also missing out is that a significant portion of the right doesn’t like welfare, they vote for the right because they don’t support welfare. If welfare is your big, number one issue, the only way you’d vote for the right is if they somehow beat the democrats in terms of the welfare they offered. In the inverse, the vastly larger support base of the Republicans who don’t want that, well what you are advocating for is for politicians and political representatives to go “fuck you people who voted for me and what you want, I’m going to do the exact fucking opposite of that in an attempt to get other people to vote for me so I can get re-elected, and basically take your votes and your support and your money for granted as a total given and not represent your interests at all.” Once again, what you are advocating for and are supportive of is definitional RINO politics, which makes it utterly bizarre to me that you’d also be a Trump supporter.
 
Last edited:

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top