Alternate History Vivat Stilicho!

stevep

Well-known member
Sounds like the period of relative stability and peace in the west is coming to an end with major war inside the Islamic state and also probably between it and Rome. The big questions are probably how will Constantine compare with his father as a war leader and whether any other groups will seek to cause trouble while he's away in the east.

Hopefully the Indo-Romans will quickly crush the Muslim incursion - although too late for their slaughtered subjects but it sounds like the horrendous combination of bad luck and poor leadership is continuing for the Huna and their likely not going to last much longer. Which would open the path for much greater Islamic conquests.

The distant settlements in N America are possibly starting to solidify under the church there, which will have impacts on its future, probably both good and bad.
 

ATP

Well-known member
Forget to write about that - but muslims now:
1.Enter cyvil war
2.Provoken romans and their allies
3.Attacked indo-romans who are China client state - and China Emperor could not show weakness.
4.Attackes Hunas again,althought they were fighting each other.

It seems,that long deserved beating is going after them.
 

stevep

Well-known member
Forget to write about that - but muslims now:
1.Enter cyvil war
2.Provoken romans and their allies
3.Attacked indo-romans who are China client state - and China Emperor could not show weakness.
4.Attackes Hunas again,althought they were fighting each other.

It seems,that long deserved beating is going after them.

With the probable exception of 2) as China is so distant I would agree but I get the feeling that like the empire the Muslims have a degree of 'protection' in terms of being ensured at least a lot of success.

The Huna are probably in terminal decline given centuries of bad government and wasted opportunities but the other issue of course are the Khazars who have a personal axe to grind. If anything is likely to go very badly for Islam here I would expect the most likely location their position could collapse would be in Iran.
 
706-709: Renewed Hostilities

Circle of Willis

Well-known member
706 was the first full year of the reign of Rome’s latest Emperor, Constantine VI. Though alike his father in appearance, the new Augustus had spent his formative years with his mother in Constantinople, and resembled her in nature and thought more than the late Aloysius I, who was well known to be a boisterous warrior and ladies’ man: he was more introverted and cautious in his dealings, a scholarly sort more at home conversing with poets and historians rather than in the saddle or the imperial pavilion on campaign, and much praised by the Church for his greater self-discipline – though his wife the Stilichian princess Maria was a full decade older than him, Constantine appeared resolutely dutiful in keeping his marital vows, and even if he had a mistress or bastards they have been entirely lost to history, completely unlike the case with his father. If he could have, this new Emperor would have retreated to an ivory tower or at least spent the first years of his reign attending to domestic affairs, such as political reform and struggling to uphold the uniformity of Latin.

But Constantine could not, for Aloysius had left the empire in the middle of preparations for war against the Muslims and the strategic situation – with the Caliphate rapidly descending into civil war and their Donatist ally having provoked the Holy Roman Empire with increasingly numerous and ferocious raids – making this year an especially excellent year to start hostilities. Constantine himself was a proven veteran, having fought in the last few wars his father had waged against Caliph Abd al-Rahman and acquitted himself well enough on the battlefields of Libya & Egypt; while not quite as mighty and fearless a warrior as Aloysius, nor as audacious a commander, the second Aloysian Augustus had built a reputation as a competent (if also rather cautious and uninspiring) leader. Certainly he had enough smarts to recognize that 706 was a good year in which to strike, and that this opportunity might be fleeting while his own domestic concerns were not pressing, and so he did finish Aloysius’ war preparations and gird himself for conflict with the Caliphate, albeit unenthusiastically.

So after officially investing his son Aloysius Junior as the new Caesar and leaving him as the imperial regent back in Trévere (although in practice governance of the Occident would actually be carried out by his appointed councilors and magistrates, on account of the heir to the purple being a lad of sixteen) and having his friend Dagobert of the Franks appoint a nobleman they both trusted, Rainfroi (Frenkisk: ‘Ragenfrid’) de Vernon, as Mayor of the Palace in that federate kingdom, Constantine made haste to join his mother Helena and then the army assembled at Antioch. While at Constantinople, the Augustus linked up with his brother-in-law Thomas Trithyrius and also alerted their other brother-in-law Kundaçiq Khagan that it was finally time to move against the forces of Islam, and received a favorable reply from the Khazar leader – for after all he had not forgotten his own oath of vengeance against the Banu Hashim. Through the Patriarch of Carthage he also contacted King Dankaran of Kumbi, who pledged to once more fight with Rome against their common enemy in Hoggar.

AyWUFrT.jpg

Flavius Constantinus Augustus Sextus, age 36, girded for war with Dar al-Islam almost immediately after taking up the purple. While strongly influenced by his mother, and consequently much more inclined toward administrative and scholarly pursuits than his predecessor, the new Emperor had already dutifully campaigned under Aloysius before and was far from being some meek bookworm

Both the Aloysians and the Ashina did have spots of family drama to overcome before they could set out to do battle with their shared Muslim enemy, however. In the former’s case, the Empress-Mother did not only assist her son with organizing additional supplies and Eastern Roman troops for the fight ahead, but also advised him to immediately have his remaining (important) half-brother Germanus disposed of, lest the latter use his absence as an opportunity to seize the purple. The Augustus dismissed this advice however, reasoning that Germanus was stuck in Gepid territory far from any of the imperial centers of power, and did not have even the modest estates and wealth that their eldest brother Sauromates had as a base from which to try his hand at usurpation. Moreover, Constantine was wary of starting his reign off with fratricide and baseless tyranny, which was what arbitrarily murdering his half-brother without even the vaguest suspicion that he was actually plotting anything would have amounted to in his eyes. He was firm in expressing that he would do what had to be done if indeed Germanus should raise a hand against him, but also warned his mother that he expected her to desist from taking ‘rash action’ in the matter, as he (and his father before him) had strongly suspected she’d done with Sauromates.

Ironically it was another of Helena’s lawful children, though another half-sibling to Constantine, who would prove to be a more conscious threat to the new Emperor. Irene, Helena’s oldest child by her hated first husband Tryphon, tried to persuade her own husband Kundaçiq to attack Rome instead of the Muslims, asserting that they could blindside her half-brother and rule as far as the uttermost western sea as not only Khagan and Khatun but also Roman Emperor and Empress. Unfortunately for her Kundaçiq thought his wife’s scheme laughably mad, knowing well that she was motivated primarily by envy and resentment toward her younger half-siblings who had been well-beloved by their mother while she was shunted off to the steppe at the earliest convenience (something she had complained about more than enough in Atil), and in any case bore no grudge against the Romans that would motivate him to use even this flimsy excuse to attack them.

The civil war between the first and second branches of the Banu Hashim was well-underway by the time the Romans and Khazars made their move. While both sides’ armies were still primarily comprised of Arabs with elite ghilman regiments, by far the forces of Caliph Abdullah counted many more such slave-soldiers in its ranks than those of the Abbasid princes, and found additional support from the remaining Persian aristocrats whom they could reach as well. In another break from tradition, Abdullah was the first Caliph to not personally lead his armies into battle, since he knew his limitations well – instead he gave this duty to Nusrat al-Din, the Turkic slave-lieutenant who had already begun to prove his martial acumen in contending with the late Aloysius Gloriosus. Nusrat led his master’s army to victory against the Abbasid princes Jalil and Khalil twice this year, first repelling their initial drive on Kufa in the Battle of Burs Nimrud[1] and then pursuing them into the latter’s territory, where he defeated them again in the Battle of Nahavand; in both engagements the Senior Hashemites’ ghilman proved invaluable, and Abdullah’s chroniclers would lavish praise upon Nusrat and his fellow Turks for their ferocity and versatility as heavily-armored lancers and horse-archers as well as the Ethiopian ghilman’s skill with longbows. Obviously however, the necessity of waging this civil war against their cousins left the Senior Hashemites’ frontier (already weakened by Aloysius’ last great raids) vulnerable to the Romans, and Constantine was able to bowl over Nisibis and other Upper Mesopotamian towns with ease as well as pushing down to Rafah & Gaza in his opening strikes.

SRjnaCd.jpg

Nusrat al-Din, the Turkic ghulam generalissimo and right hand of Caliph Abdullah, directing the flow of the Battle of Nahavand. The trend of Caliphs pushing more of their responsibilities onto slave-lieutenants truly began to take off with him and his master – it remained to be seen whether this would escalate to the point of the ghilman doing, well, pretty much everything in the name of their overlords

Of the three Abbasids, it was Ismail in the northeast who had the smallest part to play in the war against both their cousins and the Romans – because his was the domain most heavily targeted by the Khazars. Kundaçiq Khagan and his hordes poured over the Jayhun[2], as the Arabs had taken to calling the Oxus, and immediately began to lay waste to Islamic Khorasan. Aided by the remnants of the Southern Tegregs whom they had absorbed, the Khazars sacked Hazarasp and Āmul before storming towards Merv, where the middle Abbasid son had been assembling his army – initially to aid his brothers against their cousin, but now with the intent of stopping the Khazars. In the autumn battle which followed, Ismail’s half-marshaled host was scattered and he himself barely escaped with his life, leaving Khorasan vulnerable to another continued Khazar rampage scarcely a decade after it had barely recovered from Kundaç and Kundaçiq’s first assault into the region.

As for the Alid branch of the Banu Hashim, they were still too busy with their own troubles to meddle in the conflict between their cousins (and said cousins’ external enemies). In northwestern India Abduljalil got as far as Bhind before he ran into the host of Salanavira, which although smaller than the armies the latter’s father had led against his own, was wielded more skillfully by the rebel Huna prince. The Arabs were defeated in the engagement which followed, and Abduljalil retreated over the Chambal River. No sooner had he crossed, though, did he receive news which he believed was a Godsend – the victorious Salanavira had been assassinated by an agent of his brother Rudrasimha, disguised as a mere courtesan; suffice to say, the Muslim assault into northwest India could now continue. His brother Hussain similarly was defeated as he marched directly from Jaguda (also known as Alexandria-in-Opiana to the Belisarians and other Romans), facing a harsh rebuff in the mountain passes of Bactria, but was able to turn the tables and push the Indo-Roman army back after retreating to more favorable ground in the Bolan Pass. Nobody did him the favor of murdering the enemy leader however, and Zamasphes & a large portion of the Indo-Roman host survived to fight another day; moreover, the king also called upon his overlord Emperor Zhongzong for aid against the Islamic interlopers – now the time had come for the Indo-Romans to see what all that tribute they had been coughing up for the Later Han’s benefit was truly worth.

xdhAdO5.png

Mural of Chinese troops on the march, having been dispatched by Zhongzong to assist his westernmost vassal Zamasphes of the 'Later Ionians'

707 saw the anti-Muslim alliance pressing their advantage on all fronts. After establishing his headquarters amid the dilapidated fortifications of old Nisibis, Emperor Constantine pushed southward from that largely-ruined city & Harran to the west toward Callinicus and Singara, which the Arab conquerors had taken to calling Raqqa and Sinjar. The Romans did recapture Raqqa first, as Constantine handily defeated the heavily outnumbered Arab defenders in the marshes around the town with a two-pronged attack that included a Ghassanid-Kalb flanking force moving in on them from the west. However they had more difficulty in overcoming the defense of Sinjar, where the local Banu Taghlib tribe who’d lived in the area since before Islam’s arrival had since converted to the new religion and fiercely fought back against Roman efforts at reconquest, slowing the Emperor’s southward march toward the mostly-ruined city itself.

While Thomas Trithyrius and his son (Constantine’s nephew) Demetrius were enjoying some success in pushing toward the Sinai, by far the largest Roman success in the south (or overall) this year was in Hoggar. The aged King Stéléggu (Afríganu for ‘Stilicho’) of Africa led not only his own African troops, but also the overall expedition into Hoggar even though the Carthaginian exercitus had formally been placed under the command of the general Cassiodorus. He did not get far – dying before even crossing the border into Hoggari territory, as his servants found while trying to rouse him from a mid-day nap during an especially hot summer day; another contemporary of Aloysius & Helena, and another savior of Constantinople at that, thus left the Earth. Nevertheless his eldest son Yusténu (Augustine, later Afr. evolution of the earlier rendition 'Austinu') seamlessly assumed both the African throne and command of the combined Afro-Roman host, for which the second Stilichian prince Guséla (Lat. Caecilius, Berber ‘Kusaila’) declined to challenge him, and the trio had pushed into Hoggar by August.

Before doing anything else, the Stilichians and Cassiodorus took great pains to secure their supply route through both the desert and the mountains of Hoggar, as well as clear routes of communication between themselves – none involved had forgotten how past Roman and federate armies had been broken up, isolated in the rough terrain and destroyed piecemeal by the vicious Donatists in the sixth & seventh centuries. That done, they adopted a strategy of attrition to try to grind down the men of Hoggar, fighting to capture the Berbers’ few towns of note and to lock down oases and wells in particular, while also rebuffing Donatist raids and ambushes in the knowledge that they had more men to spare than their hated enemy. Their Kumbian allies also pushed through the sands of the Sahara to assist them in this endeavor from the south. In this manner Cassiodorus, Yusténu & Guséla drew a noose around the necks of their rivals Mazippa & Cutzinas, slowly but surely pushing the Donatists from the low ground (and its oases & scanty pastures) toward the high ground, where although the Hoggar Mountains from which their kingdom derived its name provided them with a nearly impregnable natural fortress, the heretic Berbers also had progressively fewer means with which to replenish their stocks of food & water. It would be a slow strategy, but a more promising one than any which the Romans had tried before.

ZWhygsC.png

An African skirmisher of the Stilichian army on patrol in the high hills and mountains of Hoggar

Abdullah was content to maintain a defensive posture against Constantine while concentrating his resources against the Abbasids to the northeast, confident that what forces he’d left behind in the west could contain the Romans while he brought his rebellious kin to heel. Consequently he ordered Nusrat al-Din to press on against Jalil & Khalil ibn al-Abbas, following up on his victory at Nahavand the year before with additional triumphs at Isfahan and Bishapur which split the brothers’ lands and armies back up in two. Nusrat also took the lead in recruiting local Persians to fight for him, promising to return portions of their ancestral estates to them as well as to accord a fair share of the loot after each battle to them if they should convert to Islam (assuming they haven’t done so already) and pledge their lives to Abdullah & his heirs, allowing him to not only rapidly replenish his losses (while the Abbasids remained dependent on Arab settlers) but also expand his ranks altogether, even if the new recruits were not as skilled or heavily armed as his trusted fellow ghilman. While the Caliph was the one who came up with this strategy and Nusrat merely implemented it, the fact was that Abdullah remained in Kufa while Nusrat was the one actually bartering & making connections with the Persians, something the Turkic slave-lieutenant would remember well into the future…

Up north, Ismail found himself being forced to join up with his younger brother Khalil and add what little remained of his strength to the latter’s in order to combat the Khazar threat, which by this point had overrun his fiefdom and were encroaching on the latter’s from two directions. From the northeast Kundaçiq Khagan surged out of Khorasan to menace Nishapur and finish off the Persian city of Abiward[3], already left in a sorry state by the repeated assaults of one nomadic invader after another and then the Arabs. Meanwhile from the northwest, Kundaçiq’s sons (and therefore also Constantine’s nephews) Balgichi, Bulan and Kayqalagh were attacking through Azerbaijan, at times maneuvering through Armenian territory to bypass Arab defenses and raiding as far as Paytakaran[4] (also known to the Romans as Caspiane). Leaving their eldest brother Jalil to face Abdullah’s loyalists alone for the time being, the two managed to lure Kundaçiq into an engagement on favorable ground in Mazandaran and fought him to a standstill at the Battle of Mount Baduspan late in 707, buying themselves a respite from his fury.

n5xNGLN.jpg

Kundaçiq Khagan of the Khazars on the southern shore of the Caspian Sea

Further still to the east, Abduljalil had Salanavira’s army on the backfoot after their leader was conveniently killed for him by his own brother, and managed to push as far as Kannauj before Salanavira’s son Buddhatala managed to rally the Indians and deal him an unexpected reversal. Making things worse, Rudrasimha was on the move and recaptured Indraprastha from the token garrison left by Al-Azad and barely reinforced by Abduljalil himself, sending the Alid prince their heads while scattering the rest of their corpses to the cities he controlled to demonstrate to his subjects that he was in fact able to resist the Muslims after all. Abduljalil determined that rather than try to stand his ground and get crushed between the advancing Huna pretenders, he should retreat back toward the Thar Desert where his brothers on the Indus might still be able to aid him, and hope that the Indians start fighting one another again in his absence.

The other Alid prince going on a foreign adventure found himself taking a step forward and then two back, as well. From Bolan Pass Hussain pushed Zamasphes back in the direction of Jaguda over the course of 707’s first half, only to find the Indo-Romans had received reinforcements from an overlord the Muslims had been vaguely aware of – Zhongzong had sent a detachment of 10,000 to support his tributary, which while positively pitiful in size by the standards of the average Chinese army, was more than enough to hold off one of the five Alids and his lone army. The combined Later Han and Indo-Roman host dealt a sharp defeat to Hussain’s forces in the Battle of Panah south of Jaguda, driving the Muslims back toward Sindh with much bloodshed. Hussain himself managed to survive and retreat to the Bolan Pass, where he planned to fight a second battle against his pursuers in the hope of turning the tables on them once more.

708 saw further Roman advances against the disunited House of Submission on both the eastern and southern fronts. Constantine himself was rebuffed in difficult fighting in the Sinjar Mountains, after which he broke off his attack on Sinjar itself and instead redoubled efforts to the southwest where he faced less resistance, working with the Ghassanids and Banu Kalb to recapture Circesium from the Muslims (who had taken to calling it al-Qarqisiya) and seizing the entirely newly built town of Al-Bukamal (so named after the Islamic Arab tribe which had settled & built it, the Kamal) by the end of the year. The Trithyrii managed to temporarily cut Egypt off from the rest of the Caliphate by seizing the Sinai for six months before being driven out by the ghulam captain Izzat al-Habashi, and the elder Stilichians slowly but surely continued their campaign to strangle Hoggar while their youngest brother Muru (Lat. ‘Maurus’) held off an Islamic attack on Leptis Magna.

Acknowledging the mounting Roman pressure on his western flank and the Khazars aggressively pushing in from the north, Abdullah ordered Nusrat al-Din to bring his cousins to heel with greater haste. The Turkic general acquiesced and first assailed Jalil in southern Persia, who could no longer count on help from his brothers on account of the aforementioned Khazars. The eldest Abbasid prince could not withstand him for long and surrendered after being dealt another defeat in the Battle of Shiraz, having been persuaded to do so by his wife and ministers who were hoping to avoid the city’s sack after his army was routed within sight of its gates. After sending Jalil and his family to Kufa, Nusrat next turned his sights to the north, where the younger Abbasid princes were struggling against the Khazars.

1Y0neSL.png

Abdullah receives the submission of his cousin Jalil ibn al-Abbas, delivered to him unfettered but unmistakably defeated by Nusrat al-Din, in Kufa

While Kundaçiq Khagan licked his wounds and reordered his horde in the first half of 708, his sons remained on the offensive across the Caspian all year, aggressively pushing into Azerbaijan with continued support from Rome’s Georgian and Armenian federates. The Islamic fraternal team was ultimately defeated by its Khazar counterpart in the Battle of Barzand, compelling them to retreat from the Caucasian frontier; making things worse, after July Kundaçiq was back on the move and was once more threatening Mazandaran, on top of razing lowland towns outside the shelter of the Alborz Mountains such as Bastam and Damghan. With such odds closing in on them and Nusrat al-Din now on the march against them as well, the remaining Abbasid princes surrendered in the belief that at least their cousin Abdullah would not shed their blood, unlike the vengeful Kundaçiq Khagan.

In that they proved to be correct, as Abdullah did not feel any need to kill his kinsmen once he had them at his mercy. He did however tear up the agreement he had made with their father al-Abbas and deprive them of much of their power, intending to hand out much of their estates to men more loyal to him and to directly subordinate their tenants & armies to his direct control, and further placed them under house arrest in Mecca. The impressed Caliph showered his general with treasure, a free choice of wife (normally ghilman had their marriage to another slavew-woman arranged for them by their master) and high office: Nusrat declined the office of wazir al-sayf (army minister), still preferring to command armies in the field rather, but swayed Abdullah into installing one of his friends among the ghilman in that position instead. Abdullah had gotten the first half of his wish: he had defeated his overmighty and unruly cousins, or at least one branch of them. Now however, he had to turn his attention to the second half – dealing with the dual Roman-Khazar threat – in which his servant Nusrat would continue to be his most important asset.

While the partially consolidated Caliphate was reorganizing its forces for the fight ahead, and Abduljalil was doing the same in al-Hind while also waiting for Rudrasimha and his nephew Buddhatala to bleed themselves further, Hussain had no time to do anything similar in Bolan Pass. The Indo-Romans and their Chinese allies engaged him in the pass immediately, and while the terrain helped even the odds somewhat, his more numerous enemies’ heavier armor still gave them the advantage when it came to close-quarters combat. Parties of lighter Indo-Roman skirmishers familiar with said terrain had discreetly maneuvered through the Toba Kakar Mountains flanking the pass ahead of Zamasphes’ arrival, frustrating Hussain’s attempt to attack the allies from above with arrows and boulders. Ultimately the Muslims were defeated and overrun after nearly two weeks of fighting both in and above the actual mountain pass, Hussain himself managing to escape only thanks to the loyalty of his retainers who laid down their lives to prolong that of a descendant of the Prophet. Finding the other Alids beyond the Bolan Pass to be in disarray, Zamasphes reasoned that he should not stop with Hussain but rather attack them all now, and hopefully neutralize the Muslim presence south of his border before they could sort out their issues and come back – stronger and more unified – for another round with him & his people.

Ucxj94F.jpg

Later Han and Indo-Roman forces clearing the Bolan Pass of its Islamic defenders

709 was the year in which Nusrat al-Din’s talents were first put to large-scale use against the enemies of Islam, with the hope that it wasn’t yet too late to salvage the situation abroad. He first marched against the Khazars with the combined strength of his own army and those of the defeated Abbasids, maneuvering to prevent Kundaçiq Khagan from linking up with his sons along the southern shore of the Caspian Sea. Aided by the scant few houses of Persian nobility to have managed to persist in rocky Tabaristan up till this point, chief among them cadet branches of the long-fallen Houses of Ispahbudhan and Mihran, Nusrat managed to relieve the siege of Amol by the elder Khagan’s main host while a secondary detachment of Muslim troops under his trusted right-hand Abu Sa’id al-Askari (himself another Turkic slave by birth, and ironically one of Khazar origin at that) fended off the Khazars who had struck south of the Alborz Mountains at Simnan. Having knocked Kundaçiq back on his heels for a short while, and leaving the defense of the northeast to Abu Sa’id, Nusrat next moved west and routed the sons of the Khagan at the Battle of Astara, successfully ambushing them while they feasted to their recent successes in the burnt-out ruins of that coastal town.

Nusrat had no time to rest on his laurels, because with the Khazars having been put in check, he now had to fend off the Romans. He launched an audacious attack into Constantine’s northern flank through Armenian territory, surging through the highlands around Lake Urmia and emerging near the headwaters of the Upper Zab at Aqra’[5]. Along the way he also gathered scattered bands of Sempadian holdouts, too few and ill-equipped to be useful in battle but genuinely helpful in guiding his army more speedily through the Armenian mountains. From there he initially marched northwestward with the intent of clearing Roman garrisons from Nisibis & its environs, but changed direction and instead moved directly westward after his scouts alerted him to Constantine’s own movement back north from the banks of the Euphrates to try to secure his rear lines in Upper Mesopotamia – the stage was set for the new Emperor to have his first confrontation with Islam’s new premier generalissimo.

mOgKca4.jpg

The sons of Kundaçiq (Kayqalagh, Bulan and Balgichi Tarkhan) on the retreat from the burning Astara, where they have just been defeated by Nusrat al-Din

This first great battle came at the heavily depopulated village which was Carrhae, but recorded under its original name of Harran by the Arabs. Nusrat al-Din had moved faster than Constantine anticipated and positioned his army of 20,000 immediately south of the town, while the Romans had not expected to meet him in combat until they had at least reached the Mountain of Nisibis[6] where they would have the advantage. Regardless, Constantine elected to give battle and formed his army of 30,000 up accordingly: he would lead the Antiochene legions and paladins in the center, placed his Ghassanid and Slavic federates on the left, and gave the Bulgars and Banu Kalb the role of covering his right. If Nusrat al-Din thought he could easily repeat Surena’s triumph on this battlefield 750 years ago, he was soon disabused of the notion – the Romans’ auxiliary horse- and camel-archers gave his own mounted skirmishers as good as they got. In general the Roman cavalry bested its Islamic counterpart on the first day of the battle, and ironically it fell to the Islamic infantry (thought to be vastly inferior to its Roman counterpart) to save the day, which they did in a spirited defense of their fortified camp within Carrhae itself.

The Romans retired toward sunset on the first day, expecting to finish the battle on the day after, but naturally Nusrat had other ideas. After reorganizing and resting his troops for a few hours, and despite having himself been wounded in the battle at the Muslim camp, he launched another attack at night. Constantine had actually kept his guard up in anticipation of night raids, but thought the Muslims would have been too disorganized and badly bloodied to attempt a full-blown assault on his own camp past midnight: nevertheless the Romans fought back fiercely and managed to hold the Arabs back at their camp’s fortifications, though some of their best units suffered the highest human toll in the fighting as they worked to prevent the Muslims from getting anywhere near the Emperor.

The two sides committed to a third round of hostilities on the afternoon of the second day, and this time the Muslims had the advantage: understanding that his numbers were still inferior, Nusrat arranged his army in oblique order and concentrated his strength against the Roman right. His overwhelming assault put the Banu Kalb to flight, while the rearward disposition of his weaker center and right drew the Roman center and left into a position to be rolled up by his victorious leftmost division; but the valor of the Bulgars, whose Kanasubigi Uturgur forsook a chance to retreat in favor of dying with glory, wasted enough time and lives on the part of the Arabs for Constantine to realign his army and break out of the trap Nusrat had constructed. The Romans safely withdrew to their original intended destination in Upper Mesopotamia, while Nusrat al-Din had proved himself to be the most important general in the Hashemites’ employ since Talhah ibn Talib.

odfv8Sq.jpg

Uturgur the Bulgar charges off to find his glorious death on the battlefield of Carrhae after informing Constantine's messenger of his decision. While he certainly got his wish, he also (intentionally or otherwise) bought enough time for the rest of the Roman army to escape Nusrat al-Din's trap and march on to the fortresses of Upper Mesopotamia

While the senior branches of the Banu Hashim had fallen back together to try to stop their bleeding against exterior enemies, the Alids continued to deal with their own mounting problems in isolation over in Al-Hind. The Belisarian army poured out of the Bolan Pass to drive the Muslims into the sea, while Hussain scrambled to warn his brothers that they needed to set aside their petty infighting and once more unite against this oncoming threat from the north (which he had provoked into attacking them in the first place). At first the Alids could not even decide who among them was to lead their efforts against the Indo-Romans, but Al-Azad’s younger brothers grudgingly agreed to fall back in line behind him (as the most experienced and battle-proven among their ranks) after Zamasphes not only captured Hussain’s temporary seat at Sibi, but also the fortified town of Khangarh[7] which had been allotted to the third brother Husam, in both cases using mangonels constructed by his Chinese engineers to make quick work of the Hashemite defenses. Only Abduljalil sat the conflict out, keeping his eye on the warring Indians, while all four of his other brothers strung their forces together in a bid to stop the Indo-Romans from sweeping them all into the sea.

====================================================================================

[1] Borsippa.

[2] The Amu Darya.

[3] Near modern Kaka, Turkmenistan.

[4] Beylaqan.

[5] Akre, Kurdistan.

[6] Mount Izla.

[7] Jacobabad.

My apologies for this update taking a bit longer than even I expected to release, I've been feeling under the weather this past week (a poor way to start the new year unfortunately). But I have been feeling well enough that I think I've turned a corner today so hopefully I'll be able to return to my usual schedule for future updates. Also while this has been a pretty 'Big Western-Eurasian Three' (HRE, Islam, Khazars) update by necessity as the new war between them erupts, I plan to shift gears a little and explore goings-on among the nations at their periphery a bit more next time as we leave the first decade of the eighth century.
 

stevep

Well-known member
Glad to hear your feeling better and hopefully a full recovery soon.

The Muslims have been damned lucky so far but are losing ground and being stretched over multiple fronts. Whether they will continue to hold or something will break could be the big issue. Alternatively that some other problem will occur for the empire [internal unrest] or Khazars [possibly being challenged by some other group?] If not the forces of Islam could take some serious territorial as well as material losses.

It could be a mistake to pressure the Hoggar so hard rather than just screening them as its tying up a fair amount of resources that could be used to supply further pressure on the Caliphate, possibly regaining a good chunk of N Africa and threatening at least raids on Egypt which would distract at least some efforts.

Of course with Nusrat al-Din and his fellow Turks being so crucial to the defence of the Caliphate sooner or later its likely that someone will decide that the Caliphate is better off in Turkish rather than Arab hands, or at least some more equal role for the non-Arab followers of Islam. Which is something those Persian converts might also agree.

Anyway have to see what develops. Many thanks for another great chapter. :)
 

PsihoKekec

Swashbuckling Accountant
There is no need to apologize for anything, your health comes first.

Unfortunately for her Kundaçiq thought his wife’s scheme laughably mad,

But once he is gone, his sons might prove more receptive.

I think strangling Hoggar is a good decision, they have been pain in the ass for centuries, they need a good putting down, or they will hit the Stillichians in the rear at the worst possible moment.
 

ATP

Well-known member
Thanks for another good chapter.
Muslims would survive,at least partially - but we would have turkish sultans replacing caliphs earlier.
I bet,that China reaction to islam would be nope after they saw with their own eyes,that it is religion of conqest.
But - we could have christians in China here.And not nestorians,like in OTL but more or less orthodox.
Probably in Japan later,too

Ethiopia should join war - it is probably their last chance to finish muslims in Egypt.

Donatists - they could be finished off this time,too.
 

stevep

Well-known member
There is no need to apologize for anything, your health comes first.

Fully agree.

But once he is gone, his sons might prove more receptive.

Possibly but it would depend on the circumstances. If the Roman/Khazar alliance is winning the war against Islam but with still a lot of fighting left and the empire is united and not threatening the Khazars then it would be a bloody stupid thing to do. If Rome is getting hostile for some reason or suffering serious internal problems and Islam isn't as great a threat then it might seem an attractive idea.

I think strangling Hoggar is a good decision, they have been pain in the ass for centuries, they need a good putting down, or they will hit the Stillichians in the rear at the worst possible moment.

Possibly but are they ever going to be more than an irritant? The Muslims are the big threat and the emperor is making an all out effort to knock them back a good bit at least. Getting back the region of N Africa up to and including Cyrenaica before it becomes strongly Islamised would I think be more useful to the empire. I doubt given the roots its already put down and that it has at least one very good general that Islam isn't going to be defeated so decisively that its pushed out of former Roman lands and Egypt as well would bitterly oppose Roman reconquest due to the persecution that would follow but at least a buffer for Carthage would be useful.
 
710-714: One fire dims, another rises

Circle of Willis

Well-known member
In the west, 710 was not only a year of war, but also the first year in which the Roman Caesar Aloysius first enters the historical record as an independent player in any regard rather than a satellite of his father. No longer content to laze about Trévere and doubtlessly eager to start making a name for himself, the prince was recorded as taking the initiative in two regards. Firstly, in response to an uptick of hostile activity on the part of the Continental Saxons, he worked off of the foundation first laid by his grandfather to engage in the time-tested Roman tactic of divide et impera – rather than marching an army (whose best elements he didn’t have, because Constantine took them to the Middle East) into their territory himself, he incited those Saxons who had converted to Christianity and cultivated friendly ties to Rome over the past few decades to attack their pagan kindred for him, so that he need only expend a few squadrons of cavalrymen to support them rather than risk his life and numerous resources on a punitive expedition.

o7vzLjL.jpg

A rather fanciful depiction of Aloysius Caesar outside the imperial capital of Trévere, shortly after reaching the age of majority and beginning to undertake independent action in the far western reaches of the Holy Roman Empire

Secondly, when confronted with Wendish (Lat.: ‘Veneti’) raiders – specifically, the tribe of Sorbs, distant kin to the Serb federates settled in Moesia – harassing his eastern frontier out of Germania Slavica in the early summer, this time Aloysius Junior really did ride forth with a thousand horsemen and drove the raiders into a trap set by the Lombards & Thuringians in the valley of the Saale River. In the ensuing ‘Battle’ (really a large skirmish) of Saalfeld the Wendish interlopers were badly beaten, while Aloysius retook what booty & captives the Sorbs had tried to run off with and further captured their leader Ctibor, son of their chief Horislav, among the few scattered survivors. The Caesar used Ctibor’s life as a bargaining chip in talks with the latter, extracting reparations and a promise to never raise Sorbian arms against the Empire again from Horislav which would be undergirded by a hostage exchange (Ctibor was released and replaced by his own young son, Cestmir, who Aloysius gave a place in the princely household as a pageboy).

Off in the east Constantine would have been gladdened to hear that his son and heir was out earning achievements on his own, for he needed the good news to balance out the bad – his mother Helena died in her sleep in the autumn of 710, aged sixty-five. Having spent the spring and summer months trading blows with Nusrat al-Din in a fruitless attempt to find weak spots in the opposing Islamic general’s positions, the Emperor had to spend the last months of the year traveling back to Constantinople for his mother’s funeral, having always been closer to her (despite their periodic disagreements) than to his father. The dowager empress was grievously mourned in the eastern provinces, where she had been well-regarded as an intermediary between her semi-barbaric husband and the Greek aristocracy: they wondered whether her son would try to change the unofficial accord which had given them a comfortable degree of autonomy under Aloysius I’s reign.

HQnpHt3.jpg

Funeral procession of the dowager-empress Helena to the Church of the Holy Apostles, where she would be laid to rest among her ancestors as befitting the last of the Sabbatians. Hers was a much more austere and somber affair than the proceedings which Aloysius I had insisted on for himself

The Greeks need not have wondered long, as Thomas Trithyrius too departed from the Palestinian theater, leaving his son (and Helena’s grandson) Demetrius in command there, and was appointed Praetorian Prefect of Constantinople and the Orient shortly after Helena was laid to rest. Constantine, it seemed, was wise enough to hold no wish to wrangle with the Eastern Senate and provincial nobility (so-called dynatoi) while he was still at war with the forces of Islam. In any case, and in accordance with her final wishes Helena herself was buried not with her husband (and later her descendants) at the new mausoleum of the Aloysian emperors outside Trévere, but rather with her ancestors beneath the Church of the Holy Apostles in Constantinople: a final testament not only to the troubled nature of their marriage but more importantly that the late empress-mother belonged to the Sabbatic dynasty by birth (and was the last of that bloodline to depart from the Earth), not a mere extension of the Aloysian one, and that she never forgot her roots; as well as that in life she had ruled over the eastern provinces as Aloysius’ co-equal in all but name – provinces which she would not abandon even in death, it seemed.

Speaking of Dar al-Islam, they were not inclined to give Constantine any respite to mourn his mother. Even as Abdullah had a letter offering his condolences sent from Kufa to Constantinople, Nusrat al-Din continued to pressure the fortresses of Upper Mesopotamia, although they held firm against his army this year thanks to the repairs Helena and Constantine had worked on in the preceding years. Izzat al-Habashi also launched a hard push along the coast of the Sinai against Demetrius Trithyrius, driving the latter out of Rafah and Gaza before the Roman general and his Banu Kalb allies were able to fight him to a standstill in the Battle of Ascalon. While the Muslims had so far been of no help whatsoever to their Donatist allies (who were still getting slowly ground down by the Stilichians), they had managed to reverse many of the Roman advances outside of Upper Mesopotamia by the time 710 ended.

The same could not be said for Abdullah’s Alid cousins in Al-Hind, now mostly occupied by having to deal with the wrathful Indo-Romans and Chinese called down upon them by the folly of Hussain. With the exception of Abduljalil, Al-Azad led his brothers to confront the Christo-Buddhist counterattack, first meeting Zamasphes in combat at Qandabil[1] – or as the non-Muslims still called it then, Ganjaba. The Muslims took up a strong defensive position on a hill, but were pushed off said hill by the heavily-armored Chinese troops in a furious clash; Hussain himself was killed, ostensibly nobly sacrificing himself to repent for his foolishness having brought this northern threat down to menace his kin in the first place, but more likely Al-Azad gave him rearguard duty to try to eliminate one of his four competitors. Nevertheless the youngest Alid prince, Al-‘Arab, led a mounted counterattack which pushed the pursuing Chinese & Indo-Roman cataphracts back and prevented the Battle of Qandabil from ending in a total disaster for his family. Still this seemed to only delay the inevitable, as Zamasphes continued to remain on the offensive while his fractious enemies remained on the backfoot – by the end of 710 the four Alids and their remaining soldiers had been pushed far down the Indus, and were stuck under siege in Sehwan (which Zamasphes recorded under its old name, Sindomana).

weE3n3R.jpg

Clash between Indo-Roman and Arab heavy cavalrymen in the dunes of Gedrosia

Come 711, Aloysius continued to act autonomously, this time trying to further rebuild Rome’s relationship with its long-wayward province of Britannia. In addition to expanding commercial ties, the Caesar also negotiated the marriage of the Ríodam (‘great/high king’ – Brydany[2] rendition of Latin Riothamus, Old Brittonic Rigotamos) Coréné’s (Lat. ‘Corineus’) ten-year-old grandson Artur d’Avalon[3] (Bry. for ‘Artorius’, evolving from Bretanego ‘Arturo’) to his similarly young kinswoman Claire d’Armorique, herself the daughter of the incumbent Armoric Duke Clair (Lat.: ‘Clarus’) and thus great-granddaughter to his own uncle Rotholandus (Francesc ‘Rodéland’, Gallique ‘Roland’). The Pelagian Romano-British had long shared an affinity with the Bretons of Armorica, to whom they shared blood ties which began with some British refugees fleeing the province in the aftermath of Flavius Constantine’s failed war for the purple against Stilicho and the first wars with the Anglo-Saxons, but the ruling Rolandines of that land were committed Ephesians and a bastard cadet-branch of the Aloysians besides. Consequently, while hailed by the continental Romans and the immediate Pendragon household as an important step forward in reconciling their nations, the new British princess-by-marriage was viewed with suspicion (or even hostility) by many of her husband’s future subjects, who feared she was the latest Trojan horse deployed to bring Britannia back under ‘Ephesian tyranny and sin’.

Matters elsewhere conspired to pull the Caesar’s attention away from his environs, as well as his increasingly visibly pregnant wife Himiltrude, later in the year. Down in the far south the Stilichian campaign against Hoggar was moving a little faster this year, as the brothers & their allies achieved two significant breakthroughs: in the north the Africans overcame the scorching-hot gorges beyond the town of Arak, which had represented the last high-water mark of Roman advances against the Donatists under Emperor Stilicho, while in the south the warriors of Kumbi wrested away control of the important oasis town of Tamenghest. Following the death of King Mazippa from old age and stress, his successor Cutzinas appealed to the Muslims to do something – anything – to relieve the pressure threatening to cave his kingdom in on all sides.

The solution was provided Izzat al-Habashi, who launched feints into southern Palaestina to keep Demetrius Trithyrius and the Kalb in a defensive posture while plotting a second major attack on Lepcés Magna (Lat.: ‘Leptis Magna’) for most of the year. When he struck, the Romans did not expect any success on his part: King Yusténu’s brother Muru had ably defended the city against the army of Islam a few years before, after all, and their mastery over the seas would make a prolonged siege impossible for the Muslims to pull off. Indeed Al-Habashi did not gamble on a siege – instead he moved to take Lepcés Magna by storm relying on the numerical weight of his Abyssinian and Egyptian reinforcements, the skill and ferocity of his (also mostly fellow Abyssinian) ghilman, and the connivance of the Jewish community of the city, some of whom responded favorably to his spies’ overtures and promises of not only better treatment but also high office under Islamic rule.

With the bulk of Africa’s strength still bearing down on Hoggar, Aloysius left his pregnant wife to march down to Italy with the remaining mounted elements of the Treverian exercitus, assume command of the exercitus of Ravenna and from there be transported by sea to relieve Lepcés Magna under his father’s orders. By the time he had crossed the Alps however, Lepcés Magna had already fallen – Muru was killed trying to defend a sabotaged gate and the Muslims went on to sack the city which had held them back twice in the past, but for whom the third strike turned out to be a most unlucky charm. Consequently the Caesar sailed for Cartàginu (Lat.: ‘Carthago’) instead, hoping to collect whatever strength he still could in the African capital and add it to his own army before confronting Al-Habashi: the Ethiopian ghulam general remained on the offensive, seeking to conquer as much of Africa as he could before the remaining Stilichians turned back from Hoggar, and would have to be stopped before Aloysius could even think about trying to retake Lepcés Magna.

Siege_of_Amorium.jpg

Comes Muru and his men, unable to close the gates of Lepcés Magna, mounting their last stand against Izzat al-Habashi's forces using what defenses of the city they still had at their disposal

While Emperor Constantine rebuffed the Caliph’s invitation to negotiate, hoping that his son would be able to reverse this significant setback, and instead continued to trade blows with Nusrat al-Din, the third great ghulam leader in Abdullah’s employ was looking to score some achievements of his own. Abu Sa’id al-Askari had little success in pushing Kundaçiq Khagan out of Khorasan, but he did at least manage to hold the aging Khazar ruler back in the mountains of Tabaristan, while also having more success in repelling the latter’s sons in Azerbaijan. Most notably Al-Askari was able to trick Balgichi Tarkhan into leaving Tabriz with the expectation of engaging the Muslims in a pitched battle, only to then outmaneuver him and capture the lightly-defended city; the embarrassed eldest son of Kundaçiq was unable to retake Tabriz and had to retreat further north, away from the shores of Lake Urmia.

In Al-Hind, the end seemed nigh for the Alids as their rations dwindled to almost nothing in Sehwan. Only the sacrifice of the third brother Sa’ad, not coincidentally also the biggest eater among the sons of Ali, ensured they had even lasted that long; he gallantly sallied from the city with a few hundred volunteers one night and promptly died from Indo-Roman arrows. Or so saith Al-Azad – Al-‘Arab, the youngest and now the only other son of Ali remaining in the city with him, suspected his eldest brother had tricked Sa’ad into charging off to his death (which would indeed have freed up more food for them, and also eliminate another competitor in peacetime if they should survive this war) with false promises of support for his ill-fated midnight ride.

For a few more weeks, the two brothers continued to jointly pray for salvation so long as Zamasphes had them besieged. But after Abduljalil finally resolved to aid his brothers rather than risk being cut off from all support from the rest of the Caliphate if they were to be destroyed, attacking the Indo-Roman/Chinese army from behind and driving them from the field in conjunction with a desperate all-out sally from within Sehwan, Al-‘Arab immediately confided his suspicions in his second brother. The younger sons of Ali regarded their eldest brother as Qabil[4] come again, certainly not to be trusted and (although they couldn’t quite countenance killing him with their own hands) hopefully to be disposed of by their enemies before he manages to set up that same fate for them, just as he almost certainly had already done with their other brothers.

fKn5cP0.jpg

Abduljalil ibn Ali meeting with his remaining brothers, Al-Azad and Al-'Arab, after relieving the Siege of Sehwan

In early 712, Aloysius landed at Cartàginu and stopped only to muster 2,000 reinforcements (all that could be summoned out of the city on such short notice) before hastening southeastward to meet the advancing threat of Izzat al-Habashi. No sooner did he receive word that his wife had given birth to their son, who was named Leo after the late Helena’s grandfather (and thus contributed to the early Aloysian tradition of alternating the names of their heirs between past Western and Eastern Emperors), did he also engage Al-Habashi’s host near the port of Gergis[5]. While the Roman army was larger, more of its elements were green recruits from Italy & Africa than the Caesar would have liked, and few of the elite Romano-Germanic paladins had remained rather than ride to the Levant with his father, so he had to hope that the paladins of Italy (mostly drawn from the remaining aristocratic families of Ostrogothic heritage) would suffice; conversely, the Islamic army had been worn down by fierce resistance on the part of the Christian Berbers of the Nafusa Mountains, who had slowed Al-Habashi enough for Aloysius to arrive in-theater without immediately coming under siege in Carthage in the first place.

Aloysius sought to use his greater numbers to envelop the Arab army, bringing forth Patriarch Sésénnéu (Lat.: Sisinnius) II of Carthage and the relics of the African patron Saint Simon to hearten his less dependable African troops. For his part, Al-Habashi countered with an audacious and forceful assault on the Roman center with the intent of breaking through to the Caesar’s position and ending his life, hopefully causing the collapse of his army. This strategy was nearly successful despite Aloysius packing most of his professional troops (particularly the infantry legions of Trévere) into his center, foiled only by the valor of his candidati bodyguards who fought off the death-squad of mubarizun Al-Habashi had assigned with bringing him the Roman prince’s head at the cost of their own lives. Unable to bring the engagement to an early and decisive conclusion, and feeling the weight of the Roman numbers slowly but surely pressing in against him over the course of the day, Al-Habashi retreated after a few hours and left the Romans in possession of the battlefield.

Despite having been defeated in the Battle of Gergis, Al-Habashi managed an orderly retreat out of Africa Zeugitana and back eastward along the Libyan coast, while young Aloysius was initially too rattled by his brush with death and his army too battered to immediately give chase. Likely he would have made the retaking of Libya much harder for the Africans & Romans, had he not been killed in an ambush by the Berbers of Nafusa on his way back to Lepcés Magna some weeks after the battle. Heartened by this news, Aloysius informed Yusténu & Guséla to keep applying pressure to Hoggar while he dealt with the Muslims in Libya. Al-Habashi’s second-in-command and now successor Amr ibn Qayyim al-Ansari was not so daring as his superior, and essentially allowed the Caesar to march unopposed onto Leptis Magna in favor of pulling all his troops behind the mostly-intact walls of that decidedly not-so-intact city.

ruOkTVj.jpg

A candidatus bodyguard of Aloysius Caesar strikes down one of the Islamic champions deployed as battlefield assassins by Al-Habashi at the climax of the Battle of Gergis

In the Levant, the battle-lines were beginning to firmly stabilize as Africa increasingly became the focal point of Roman-Arab hostilities instead. In the spring Constantine attempted a joint offensive with the Ghassanids and Banu Kalb to secure the upper length of the Euphrates and shut Islam out of eastern Syria, but this strategem was foiled due to Nusrat al-Din managing to defeat their armies separately before they could fight their way to the intended rallying point at Sipri, which the Arabs called Asfirah[6]. Nusrat mounted his own offensive in the late summer and early fall months, intending on pushing the Romans out of Upper Mesopotamia once and for all, but this time the Augustus managed to lure him into engaging on favorable (to the Romans) ground around the Mountain of Nisibis and soundly defeated him. When the Caliph once again offered to negotiate peace terms, Constantine was more receptive this year, although the talks broke down in short order – he was adamant about both holding all of his territorial gains and having Lepcés Magna returned to the Empire, both conditions which were unacceptable to Abdullah.

Further to the east, while the Alids continued to struggle to survive against Zamasphes, Abu Sa’id al-Askari was finding that the army left to him had hit their limit on the Khazar front. He had managed to push the royal Tarkhans back up the western coast of the Caspian and beyond the mouth of the River Aras (as the Arabs called the Araxes), but could go no further. Islamic attempts to regain further territory beyond that river were repelled by the recovering Khazars, and a better-prepared King Gurgen of Armenia also decisively shut down an effort by Al-Askari to support his superior Al-Din’s Mesopotamian offensive by pushing into the Armenian kingdom – after facing determined Armenian-Georgian resistance in the Battle of the Akera River and the failure of Sempadian partisan support to materialize, Al-Askari withdrew rather than risk overreaching and exposing his position in the southeastern Caucasus to the Khazar tarkhans. Kundaçiq Khagan seemed content to hold on to his gains in Khorasan and just aggressively raid Islamic Persia this year, but was committed to not negotiating a separate peace with the Caliph – his old oath of vengeance and sense of honor compelled him to not abandon Constantine and the Romans.

8880PlN.png

Gurgen Mamikonian, King of Armenia, overseeing some of his troops training ahead of the Battle of the Akera River

Beyond the borders and troubles of the Roman world and its immediate great neighbors, trouble continued to brew in Britannia. The Ríodam Coréné passed away in the last weeks of 712’s winter, and while he was an ailing old man whose demise from natural causes could easily have been predicted by any observer who beheld him, hardline Pelagian devotees elected to consider his death to be retribution from on high for his policy of rapproachment toward the Romans – freedom of will and choice did not mean freedom of choice, as they would describe it. These Pelagians would doubtless have been further infuriated by his son and successor Bedur’s (Britt.: ‘Bedwyr’, Gall.: ‘Bedivere’) commitment to staying the course, and their displeasure manifested in the outbreak of a rebellion in the mountains of Cambre[7] before the year was out, which culminated in the acclamation of his cousin Brogeual (Britt. ‘Brochvael’) d’Ésc[8] as a rival high king in Gloué[9] in the week after Christmas.

713 saw the Romans and Muslims each making their last major attempts to redraw the geopolitical map of western Eurasia in this round of fighting. In the west Aloysius continued to keep Lepcés Magna under siege, having the Roman navy blockade it by sea while on land his legions not only invested the city but also successfully fought off Islamic efforts to relieve Amr al-Ansari out of Egypt throughout the year. Al-Ansari himself did not have sufficent rations to withstand a long siege, having lost a good deal of Al-Habashi’s marching supplies while being harried by Berber guerrillas on his way back to the city, and sued for terms near the end of the year in an attempt to extract himself from Lepcés Magna.

With their homeland secured by the timely intervention of the Caesar, the Stilichians had a free hand to redouble their attacks on Hoggar and achieved another big breakthrough this year. After so many centuries and another seventeen days of hard fighting, they & their Kumbian allies finally managed to grind their way to the Donatist capital of Abalessa (although Prince Guséla was killed along the way, as the Donatists managed to drop a boulder on his tent while he was sleeping inside it) and capture it by storm in spite of the blistering Saharan heat and rough mountain terrain in their way. While some of the Donatist population managed to flee into the Hoggari gorges west of the city (those who could not were exterminated by the Afro-Roman army, enraged beyond all reason by the three centuries it took to get to this point and the determined Donatist defense), Cutzinas preferred to fall with his city rather than have it be said that he was a coward in the face of the sinful Ephesians, and Yusténu duly avenged his brothers by taking the king’s head in turn.

F7uX0Q2.jpg

African troops breaking into the Hoggari capital of Abalessa. After three hundred years of incessant raiding, limited punitive expeditions, and the occasional disastrous failure, the Ephesian Christians of North Africa finally had their ancestral Donatist archenemies dead to rights and were determined to ensure the latter could no longer ever threaten them again

While Hoggar’s population centers had been overwhelmed by the forces of Ephesian Christianity (although Donatist resistance continued to linger in the caves and gorges of Hoggar), further in the east Nusrat al-Din and Emperor Constantine met for three more great battles in an effort to shift the pendulum of war. In the first months of the year Al-Din shifted his focus southward, defeating Demetrius Trithyrius in the Second Battle of Ascalon and placing Jerusalem under siege, but he was pulled back northward after Constantine launched additional offensives out of Upper Mesopotamia to relieve pressure on Palaestina. The Augustus and Islam’s incumbent foremost generalissimo met at the Second Battle of Sinjar, Ras al-Ayn (or as the Romans still called it, Resaina) and finally Constantina[10]: the Muslims won the first two battles, but Al-Din overextended his forces in his counterattack and was badly beaten after Constantine found his second wind in the third. Following these clashes and further inconclusive fighting in the eastern Caucasus, the Emperor and the Caliph agreed to a truce and to once again try to reach a peace agreement.

In Britain, the civil war between the lawful Ríodam Bedur and the usurper Brogeual rapidly came to a climax as the latter marched directly on Lundéne[11], expecting to settle the succession in a single decisive blow. In hopes of acting so quickly as to prevent either the English or the Romans from having any chance to invade his country, Bedur duly rose to meet his cousin’s challenge and engaged the rebels on the road to his capital near Hydropole[12], both men risking their lives on the front line of their armies in keeping with Pelagian tradition (which demanded that kings and generals lead from the front so as to set an example for their underlings). This decision proved more fatal for Brogeual than it did for Bedur – within half an hour the usurper had been felled by a javelin through the face, after which his army quickly surrendered. Having seen off one rebellion, Bedur was now confident enough to call a synod at Lundéne with the intention of finessing Pelagian doctrine.

There he and his supporters among the British Church proposed a ‘Semi-Pelagian’ position which taught that humans were born untainted by sin and with the free will to choose between salvation or damnation, but also that they would grow in faith by the will of God. Unfortunately for him the hard-line Pelagian bishops and priests believed this to be erroneous doctrine, introduced not to clarify existing Pelagian teachings or allay domestic unrest but rather as a first step toward submission to Ephesian dogma, and vigorously rejected it on those grounds. The Ephesians in Lundéne and the Holy Roman Empire also rejected this middle position, instead firmly upholding the synergistic doctrinal position which held that God was involved in every step of the road to salvation including its beginning (furthermore, they would not deviate from the other orthodox position that all men were born with the taint of original sin, which the Semi-Pelagians still rejected). It would seem that religious conflict in Britannia would continue to swell and escalate after all, despite Bedur’s attempt at a compromise.

mQss6JG.jpg

The Ríodam Bedur at the Synod of Lundéne, 713-714, surrounded by those bishops he could find who were supportive of his 'Semi-Pelagian' compromise and facing off with the hard-line Pelagians. His efforts to find a compromise that would indefinitely keep the Romans at bay without also fueling civil unrest in his own kingdom were not going very well as of this time, to put it mildly

Elsewhere, beyond the opposite limit of even the maximal Roman border in the East once attained by Emperor Sabbatius, the Alids moved towards their final major confrontation with the Indo-Romans at the Battle of the Gomal River. Here at first the Muslims nearly had the victory, baiting their enemies into crossing the river with a feint retreat before assailing the Indo-Roman vanguard with their full might and using catapults to attack the bridge the foe had just marched over; but Zamasphes’ engineers had prepared numerous boats precisely for the case that his army may need to cross without using a contested bridge. Ultimately the Muslims were defeated and Al-Azad killed by an arrow in the chaos (fired, perhaps, not by any Indo-Roman or Chinese soldier but by one of his own brothers’ men), but the Indo-Romans and Chinese had suffered their heaviest casualties to date and Abduljalil & Al-‘Arab survived to rally the remaining Islamic troops.

At this point the remaining Alid brothers sued for peace and offered to both cede their mountainous hinterland (of those still in Muslim hands, the most important town in that region was Qiqan[13]) and all their territory near the headwaters of the Indus to the Indo-Romans, as well as to pay tribute to China. Zamasphes was skeptical of their terms and wished to carry on the fight until he had finished off the Alids altogether, but was persuaded to accept this agreement by the Chinese general Li Lun, who thought it a good enough deal and was weary of fighting so far from his homeland. Thus did the Alids manage to largely settle their fratricidal internal issues and live to fight another day, albeit at a rather steep cost to themselves – including, in Abduljalil’s case, having to pass up on an opportunity to further expand his own domain in India.

The early months of 714 was where the Khazars mounted their own final attempt to alter their border with Dar al-Islam, as Kundaçiq Khagan – conspicuously missing from the tentative trucial agreement between Constantine and Abdullah, which he had expressed vocal support for but not actually committed to himself – launched a surprise winter offensive out of Khorasan. However, his sons were not able to support him in the west, allowing Abu Sa’id al-Askari to blunt his assault in the Battle of Saanabad[14] in March. Only after this final gambit had been foiled and under further urging from his Roman brother-in-law did the elderly Khagan agree to join the truce and peace talks, which would be held at Erevan[15] near the Armenian border with the Caliphate.

The Peace of Erevan would adjust the borders of Western Eurasia in favor of Christendom and the Khazars, but not by nearly as much as may have been expected at the outset of this conflict considering that the Hashemites had started out in a civil war. The Romans kept their gains in Upper Mesopotamia, including many important fortress towns (of which Nisibis was the most prominent) which they could now restore, but failed to acquire any meaningful amount of buffer-space in Syria or especially Palaestina, much less cut Egypt off from the rest of the Caliphate. They also managed to avoid the embarrassment of losing any territory to the Muslims, at least – Lepcés Magna was returned to African hands, Amr al-Ansari’s position there having clearly become unsustainable. Al-Ansari was also required by treaty to not only return the plunder and slaves taken from the sack of the city, but further abandon the treacherous Jewish elders who had helped his late superior Al-Habashi take the site in the first place to Roman justice: naturally Aloysius Caesar and King Yusténu immediately had them killed, and their chief Anan bar Elijah – held responsible for persuading the others to sell the city out to the Muslims in exchange for ‘high office’ under the new regime – was hanged from Lepcés Magna’s highest remaining tower above his compatriots.

As for the Khazars, they gained a significant swath of territory in Khorasan, and a good deal less in the eastern Caucasus. Kundaçiq was able to preserve his conquests between the Amu Darya and the Aladagh & Alborz mountain ranges, placing him in control of almost the entirety of the Caspian Sea’s eastern shoreline. On that same body of water’s western coast however, the Khazars were only able to advance their control as far as Ardabil, while the Armenians’ hold on the western shore of Lake Urmia was also affirmed once more by the Muslims. The vast majority of Persia proper and large parts of Azerbaijan remained under Islamic authority, and Abdullah now finally had the time & breathing space to reorder it to his liking with his troublesome cousins defeated & foreign enemies kept at bay.

The Caliph would not be the only monarch to use the time between this great war and the inevitable next one to engage in some housecleaning, that was for certain. The Augustus Constantine did not even reach Constantinople before he called an ecumenical council (specifically in Miletus, south of Ephesus in Ionia), ostensibly with the intention of heading off various theological controversies between the Eastern & Western Patriarchates before they metastasized into much worse problems – such as the filioque, a single line found in Latin renditions of the Nicene Creed – as well as finding an alternative olive branch with which to bring the British Church back in line with the rest of Ephesianism.

8Pm0FSO.jpg

Ephesian bishops arriving for the Council of Miletus, 714

However, Constantine was in truth more interested in resolving political tensions related to the expanded size and scope of the Roman Patriarchate (namely that the vast and still-expanding ranks of Germanic & Slavic converts did not feel represented in the still heavily Italian, and specifically urban-Roman, dominated Holy See). Concocting a religious doctrine upon which to justify the Roman imperial office and especially a good reason as to why the Aloysian dynasty should have an undying claim upon it constituted an important secondary objective for the Emperor, as well. Ironically however, the first issue raised at the Council of Miletus once all the attending prelates had been seated would have nothing to do with any of those issues: the Carthaginian delegation, led by Bishop Gradzéanu (Lat.: ‘Gratian’) of Yunéga[16], communicated their Patriarch’s and King’s desire to harshly punish the African Jewry in general for the treachery of the Jews of Lepcés Magna, which after all had cost the latter’s youngest brother Muru his life on top of thousands of other Christians killed or enslaved.

While Constantine remained at Miletus, his heir Aloysius made his way back to Trévere, not only to reunite with his wife and newborn son but also to take up an interesting proposal coming out of Britannia. The troubles of the Ríodam Bedur clearly were not at an end, as the British high king was attacked by assassins while conducting a regular tour of his realm in hopes of inspiring his skeptical subjects and shoring up support for his rule. While he and his bodyguards managed to dispatch the would-be regicides, Bedur strongly suspected that the assassins were Pelagian zealots infuriated by his continuation of his father’s Roman-friendly policies and willingness to compromise with Rome on theological issues. His response was to offer to send his own heir Artur to Nantes, the capital of Armorica, both so that the latter might be brought up alongside his wife and for safety’s sake while also avoiding placing him under direct Roman custody in Trévere; this was one compromise the Aloysians could certainly live with. However, although it safeguarded the Pendragon heir’s life, this choice would prove to be yet another one which cost Bedur more esteem in the eyes of his own Pelagian subjects.

====================================================================================

[1] Gandava, Pakistan.

[2] ‘Britannic’ – Later British Romance, evolving out of Early British Romance or ‘Bretanego’ after another two centuries of separation from Rome. Brydany would have been considered truly its own Romance language, not a mere dialect of Vulgar Latin: no longer bearing any great resemblance to Italian unlike its predecessor, I had in mind instead a strong French/Gallo base (since historical British Romance was said to take a good deal after Gallo-Romance) with an added Welsh/Breton flair to distinguish it from continental Romance.

[3] Glastonbury Tor, then still an island surrounded by unreclaimed fens.

[4] The Islamic name for Cain.

[5] Zarzis.

[6] As-Safira.

[7] Cambria – that is to say, Wales.

[8] Isca Augusta – Caerleon.

[9] Glevum, or Caerloym – Gloucester.

[10] Viranşehir.

[11] Londinium – London. This Brydany rendition takes more after the Briton/Welsh translation of London’s Latin name, ‘Lundein’, than it does after the French ‘Londres’.

[12] Dorchester-on-the-Thames. The village may have been referred to as ‘Hydropolis’ in Greek & Latin, hence its Brydany rendition as ‘Hydropole’.

[13] Kalat.

[14] Mashhad.

[15] Yerevan.

[16] Unica Colonia – Oran.
 

stevep

Well-known member
Well the Donatist are pretty much destroyed and the Pelagians are clearly on their last legs. Bedur and his father have made a probably fatal mistake trying to compromise between two sets of extremists which of course means their hated by both. With the growing strength of the empire the kingdom would probably have seen some sort of invasion which with a 5th column already in place and the Anglo-Saxons to the north resisting would also probably be fatal. Caught between the proverbial rock and hard place. :( Similarly with the Saxons in Germany the omens are looking dark.

Similarly there is another pogrom against the Jews, which of course will make them even more friendly to the less brutal Muslims so its likely to back-fire. I get the feeling that the lack of all the powers to really roll back Islam to any significant degree will come back to bite them when they are less powerful and Islam less divided.

Is the comment about the filioque going to lead to another schism as OTL although possibly with the Papacy far more isolated this time? Another possible clash might be on icons although with Islam having markedly less success here - albeit the rulers involved don't know how much worse it could have been ;) - the iconoclastic movement could be markedly less powerful both because the assault of Islam hasn't been as overwhelming as OTL and hence its more likely to be seen as an influence from a foreign enemy.

A lot going on but the current war between the two main Abrahmic sects is currently at a stalemate. However that even a united empire combined with a powerful Khazar empire and the Chinese backed Indo-Romans could only make small gains suggests that Islam is going to be a greater problem in the future.

Although it might have one issue expanding its faith in already conquered lands. With less room for looting and expansion with the resulting gains of power and wealth there could be less incentive for people to convert to Islam.
 

shangrila

Well-known member
Morale and prestige is hard to judge, but this is the first time Islam has indisputably lost to the infidel. Not failed to conquer, or a raid got ambushed, or stalemated, but flat out lost on multiple fronts without any balancing gains elsewhere. Historically, this didn't happen until the Byzantine defeat (and eventual conquest) of the Emirate of Melitene in the 9th Century, also taking advantage of a Fitna, that associated with the Anarchy at Samara. And that, objectively much less than what happened here, caused anti-Caliphal riots throughout Islam. The Abassid Caliphate never really recovered, and steadily lost authority to various warlords.

Here, moving that a century and a half earlier means the Arab aristocracy and warrior caste hasn't completely become indolent, perhaps making it harder for slave soldiers to completely take over, but on the other hand, it's a much bigger hit.
 

Circle of Willis

Well-known member
Indeed the Donatists have been crippled - probably permanently - in Hoggar at the very least, although exiles might be able to take their doctrine deeper into Africa (whether they'll fizzle out or might get to the point of a Donatist equivalent to the Canadian Pelagian sanctuary all the way in Cameroon or whatever, of course, I can't say). It's definitely cause for celebration in Carthage & elsewhere though, the Ephesians will be thinking that it's about time they got rid of that particular pest after 300 years of being annoyed/aggravated by them.

Speaking of Pelagians, the Romano-British are in a pretty much impossible spot right now, with a reinvigorated (H)RE under proven leadership that's increasingly thinking about swallowing them up and already has a reliable ally on their sole land border to the north. The Pendragons are trying to walk the tightrope of simultaneously keeping the Romans happy so they don't get flattened in an invasion, while also not outright becoming Roman subjects and abandoning the Pelagianism that they've held to for 300 years, but it sure looks like that rope's about to snap from under their feet. In any case with the Romans proper resurgent, as the Donatists have found out and as the Britons are on the verge of also finding out, it's definitely a bad time to be a heretic on the Roman periphery in general.

Rome's advantage re: the filioque, other than the Aloysians being western-based emperors whose seat still falls under Roman ecclesiastical jurisdiction, is that they can present a unified front on the issue with Carthage; the African Church seems to have been supportive of adding the filioque and the theology behind it from Tertullian to Augustine. However the Carthaginians' staunch Augustinianism is likely to cause other problems at the Council of Miletus, considering one of its stated purposes is to extend an olive branch to the Pelagians whose theology is totally at odds with theirs.

Other than that, the filioque in & of itself may not necessarily lead to a schism - my understanding is that historically the Orthodox were mainly pissed the Pope declared it canonical on his own authority (which can't happen ITL, what with there still being a universally recognized Emperor & church councils) rather than because they found the addition completely intolerable theologically, and the Byzantines nearly accepted it at the Council of Florence except for the defiant Mark of Ephesus. But who knows, depending on how it's handled it could blow up in Emperor Constantine's face, or at least contribute to ill-will on the part of the Eastern Churches, or even get derailed to the point where no definitive decision is taken if the opposition to it is severe enough.

Yeah, Abdullah may have finally gotten a handle on issues within his dynasty, but it might be a 'out of the frying pan and into the fire' scenario. The Hashemites have already had to deal with people opposing their authority before, now such 'Kharijites' will be able to argue that they care more about their own power & security than about spreading Allah's truth & the Ummah - could new leadership not do better than the descendants of Muhammad, who aren't his equal and are apparently increasingly corrupt with each new generation? The Caliph better act fast to restore his prestige, but since Rome & Khazaria are obvious no-gos, Nubia's still holding to the Baqt treaty and Bactria/Sogdia is protected by the Later Han, that realistically just leaves India as an avenue for expansion in the short term. (Very unfortunate for the Hunas and other non-Muslims living in the subcontinent, although they have also had a little respite to try to get their house in order)
 

ATP

Well-known member
Indeed the Donatists have been crippled - probably permanently - in Hoggar at the very least, although exiles might be able to take their doctrine deeper into Africa (whether they'll fizzle out or might get to the point of a Donatist equivalent to the Canadian Pelagian sanctuary all the way in Cameroon or whatever, of course, I can't say). It's definitely cause for celebration in Carthage & elsewhere though, the Ephesians will be thinking that it's about time they got rid of that particular pest after 300 years of being annoyed/aggravated by them.

Speaking of Pelagians, the Romano-British are in a pretty much impossible spot right now, with a reinvigorated (H)RE under proven leadership that's increasingly thinking about swallowing them up and already has a reliable ally on their sole land border to the north. The Pendragons are trying to walk the tightrope of simultaneously keeping the Romans happy so they don't get flattened in an invasion, while also not outright becoming Roman subjects and abandoning the Pelagianism that they've held to for 300 years, but it sure looks like that rope's about to snap from under their feet. In any case with the Romans proper resurgent, as the Donatists have found out and as the Britons are on the verge of also finding out, it's definitely a bad time to be a heretic on the Roman periphery in general.

Rome's advantage re: the filioque, other than the Aloysians being western-based emperors whose seat still falls under Roman ecclesiastical jurisdiction, is that they can present a unified front on the issue with Carthage; the African Church seems to have been supportive of adding the filioque and the theology behind it from Tertullian to Augustine. However the Carthaginians' staunch Augustinianism is likely to cause other problems at the Council of Miletus, considering one of its stated purposes is to extend an olive branch to the Pelagians whose theology is totally at odds with theirs.

Other than that, the filioque in & of itself may not necessarily lead to a schism - my understanding is that historically the Orthodox were mainly pissed the Pope declared it canonical on his own authority (which can't happen ITL, what with there still being a universally recognized Emperor & church councils) rather than because they found the addition completely intolerable theologically, and the Byzantines nearly accepted it at the Council of Florence except for the defiant Mark of Ephesus. But who knows, depending on how it's handled it could blow up in Emperor Constantine's face, or at least contribute to ill-will on the part of the Eastern Churches, or even get derailed to the point where no definitive decision is taken if the opposition to it is severe enough.

Yeah, Abdullah may have finally gotten a handle on issues within his dynasty, but it might be a 'out of the frying pan and into the fire' scenario. The Hashemites have already had to deal with people opposing their authority before, now such 'Kharijites' will be able to argue that they care more about their own power & security than about spreading Allah's truth & the Ummah - could new leadership not do better than the descendants of Muhammad, who aren't his equal and are apparently increasingly corrupt with each new generation? The Caliph better act fast to restore his prestige, but since Rome & Khazaria are obvious no-gos, Nubia's still holding to the Baqt treaty and Bactria/Sogdia is protected by the Later Han, that realistically just leaves India as an avenue for expansion in the short term. (Very unfortunate for the Hunas and other non-Muslims living in the subcontinent, although they have also had a little respite to try to get their house in order)

Donatists would survive as exiles in Cameroon,or not.
Pelagians would fall,either from cyvil war or Romans.But,survive in Canada.
Popes could get cardinal system election earlier.
Filioque should not made schizm this time.
Muslims - if they do not conqer India,cyvil wars would finish them.
They still could go to Chad,where Sa culture existed with its city-states.In OTL they conqered them in 16th century after 500 years of fighting.
Now,it could be faster.
Or,christians could save them.

Jews - after their last fuck-up,all cities near muslim territories would banish them.It would be suicidal to do otherwise.

Wends - they could be christianized now,and turned into HRE subject without OTL germanization.

P.S Sea voyages - i stil think,that Africans should find searoad to Carribean,HRE send ships to Baltics,conqer prussian tribes and reopen Amber road,and chineese eventually found Australia.
Japan could send colonist to North America using Kuro-sivo,too.
 

shangrila

Well-known member
Another thought: the Islamic Golden Age has effectively been eliminated. Historically, it was essentially the reigns of Harun al-Rashid and his 3 succeeding sons before things fell apart during his grandsons' time first with a fundamentalist reaction against rationalism, and then quickly into the Anarchy at Samara.

Without conquering Syria (and the first Caliphate centered there), there wouldn't be nearly as much influence from Greek philosophy and proto-science. Even Alexandria got its population drained during the last war. Persian high culture eventually won over Greek in Islam historically anyway, but Greek influence here would be utterly minimal. And I'm not sure about Persian culture either, the Persians have been beaten down for a long time in this timeline. So from where do the Arabs gain higher culture?

And there would never be the period of essentially unopposed triumph enjoyed by Harun al-Rashid, with the Anarchy equivalent and the ascendance of the Turkic slave soldier moved up a century and a half.
 

stevep

Well-known member
Another thought: the Islamic Golden Age has effectively been eliminated. Historically, it was essentially the reigns of Harun al-Rashid and his 3 succeeding sons before things fell apart during his grandsons' time first with a fundamentalist reaction against rationalism, and then quickly into the Anarchy at Samara.

Without conquering Syria (and the first Caliphate centered there), there wouldn't be nearly as much influence from Greek philosophy and proto-science. Even Alexandria got its population drained during the last war. Persian high culture eventually won over Greek in Islam historically anyway, but Greek influence here would be utterly minimal. And I'm not sure about Persian culture either, the Persians have been beaten down for a long time in this timeline. So from where do the Arabs gain higher culture?

And there would never be the period of essentially unopposed triumph enjoyed by Harun al-Rashid, with the Anarchy equivalent and the ascendance of the Turkic slave soldier moved up a century and a half.

Interesting point. They do still have some wealthy territories, although only gained with markedly more fighting than OTL and as you say Iran/Persia has been a basket case for quite a while with assorted groups conquering and fighting over it.

Are you assuming that the realm of Islam will fairly quickly degenerate into more intolerant religious bigotry, which would remove its prime advantage over the empire?

One other factor of course with the Khazar's having a much larger empire and the Indo-Romans and Later Han being significant powers - albeit a long way away - is how many Turkish slave/mercenary soldier will they have a capacity to recruit? Could they end up with some groups such as Persians playing more of that role than OTL.
 

shangrila

Well-known member
Are you assuming that the realm of Islam will fairly quickly degenerate into more intolerant religious bigotry, which would remove its prime advantage over the empire?

I was more thinking on what makes the Arabs of real life one of the major civilizations of humanity, and not yet another bunch of tribal conquerors that temporarily squatted on a greater civilization before being evicted by someone else. Many tribal conquerors were "tolerant" in that they didn't really care what their tax payers did as long as they paid, and they quickly disappear after their time in the sun as they either get assimilated or scattered after eviction.

Arabs successfully overwrote many ancient civilizations dating back to the very beginning of civilization itself, something neither the Romans nor the Persians managed in their centuries of rule over the same territory. The Golden Age period of combining Greek and Persian and uniquely Islamic no doubt played a part in that. Here, maybe Arabs and Islam just become another set of conquerors of Persian civilization.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top