Scooby Doo
Well-known member
I am making this thread due to the Raiden vs Excal Deathbattles and due to the insane amount of Warframe wankery that's been going on the last year. There's a lot of blatant fanboyism spreading out of context claims and outright fanfiction level of claims about Warframe and have misleaded the public on their power levels for versus debates.
As speaking from someone of Mastery Rank 16 who farmed frames like Gara/Garuda/Yareli from scratch and unlocked all the cosmetics from Steelpath even doing all of Deimos solo on Steelpath I am pretty familiar with the setting and can safely say that the community grossly over estimates the universes vs potential and relies argument wise on a lot of headcanon and fanfiction for most arguments instead of relying on actual feat representation.
This indicates I've long since completed a major story Arc of the setting, so basically me getting far into the story and knowing about the lore and narrative.
Finally, I got 1,000+ hours and 91% completion rate. I am an extremely credible source on the abilities of the Warframe setting.
This thread will focus on debunking common misconceptions while pointing out abused fallacies by the community and at the same time point out why Raiden would crush Excalibur.
Not only does Excalibur not scale this method of arguing is called an equivalence fallacy. Best described in the analogy below
Warframe debaters erroneously assume ALL Warframes are with in the same physical capability because they're apart of the same faction which isn't true and this especially is so in the case of Excalibur and Atlas, the argument is no different from saying "If Batman had 1% of the strength of Superman than he should have no issue of destroying a city with one punch, after all they're both Justice League members and fight the same type of enemies" it's a flawed argument that ignores context.
The Atlas feat as of 2022 is the sole greatest physical feat in the setting that no Warframe has ever come close to replicating and Atlas per his profile
Atlas is the only one with such claims/feats/statements being made to him and no other Tenno, Deathbattles and many Warframe fanboys erroneously assumed this can be applied to Excalibur which its blatantly contradicted on several instances. While Excalibur does possess great strength it is NO WHERE near Atlas, Excalibur's best strength feat thus far is in the Orokin Era by destroying a large section of an Orokin dropship with a fully charged Paris Prime Bow. (Which may have not been entirely pure strength)
Which while superhuman due to the size and thick plating of the vessel, it is not close to the level of Atlas. To be 1% of Atlas according to DeathBattles the Warframe Excalibur would have to be capable of exerting and withstanding forces up to 40 Megatons, which is 80% of the Tsar Bomba. To put this into perspective visuals wise Excalibur should be displacing thousands of kilometers worth of dirt and earth with a single attack, he doesn't and this is consistent.
Atlas and Excalibur having the same power rating means nothing, Volt who has the same power rating as Excalibur is hundreds if not THOUSANDS of times faster than Excalibur
In the main canonical trailer for Warframe an Orokin Era Excalibur (Who would be easily the second strongest if not THE strongest version to be debated due to having the best equipment available) going all out is only able to make a blast that consumes 35 people which is more a result of his energy projection than sheer strength.
Impressive blast right? This is the crater after wards
This Excalibur wasn't weakened in any shape or form nor was he constrained by game play mechanics since it was a cinematic (A favorite argument to make on why they don't perform the fanfic level feats they say Excalibur can perform) there is literally no reason for Excalbur to not have just swung his sword one direction and carve a new valley in the other direction instead of taking over a minute to kill literal fodder.
We literally see Excalibur's Kunai get stuck on a Grineer soldiers helm, are you going to genuinely argue that Grineer infantry are wearing armor that can withstand MEGATONS worth of kinetic energy and not only fail to break but also not get sent flying to the horizon from sheer force?
WHERE ARE THE MEGATONS?
WHERE ARE THE KILOTONS?
If Excalibur had 0.1% the strength of Atlas there wouldn't be a Orokin Dropship or even Grineer body left to see. If anyone who sees this post still disagrees go ahead and post a feat of Excalibur doing anything close to 1% of the feat Atlas performed.
-----
Part 2 to follow below.
As speaking from someone of Mastery Rank 16 who farmed frames like Gara/Garuda/Yareli from scratch and unlocked all the cosmetics from Steelpath even doing all of Deimos solo on Steelpath I am pretty familiar with the setting and can safely say that the community grossly over estimates the universes vs potential and relies argument wise on a lot of headcanon and fanfiction for most arguments instead of relying on actual feat representation.
This indicates I've long since completed a major story Arc of the setting, so basically me getting far into the story and knowing about the lore and narrative.
Finally, I got 1,000+ hours and 91% completion rate. I am an extremely credible source on the abilities of the Warframe setting.
This thread will focus on debunking common misconceptions while pointing out abused fallacies by the community and at the same time point out why Raiden would crush Excalibur.
#Debunking number 1. Excalibur does absolutely NOT scale to Atlas
Not only does Excalibur not scale this method of arguing is called an equivalence fallacy. Best described in the analogy below
Warframe debaters erroneously assume ALL Warframes are with in the same physical capability because they're apart of the same faction which isn't true and this especially is so in the case of Excalibur and Atlas, the argument is no different from saying "If Batman had 1% of the strength of Superman than he should have no issue of destroying a city with one punch, after all they're both Justice League members and fight the same type of enemies" it's a flawed argument that ignores context.
The Atlas feat as of 2022 is the sole greatest physical feat in the setting that no Warframe has ever come close to replicating and Atlas per his profile
"The brawler, the strong. Master of Earth and Stone, he alters the environment with incredible force" 0:13-0:21
"Moving mountains is no easy task Tenno" 1:40-1:45
Atlas is the only one with such claims/feats/statements being made to him and no other Tenno, Deathbattles and many Warframe fanboys erroneously assumed this can be applied to Excalibur which its blatantly contradicted on several instances. While Excalibur does possess great strength it is NO WHERE near Atlas, Excalibur's best strength feat thus far is in the Orokin Era by destroying a large section of an Orokin dropship with a fully charged Paris Prime Bow. (Which may have not been entirely pure strength)
Which while superhuman due to the size and thick plating of the vessel, it is not close to the level of Atlas. To be 1% of Atlas according to DeathBattles the Warframe Excalibur would have to be capable of exerting and withstanding forces up to 40 Megatons, which is 80% of the Tsar Bomba. To put this into perspective visuals wise Excalibur should be displacing thousands of kilometers worth of dirt and earth with a single attack, he doesn't and this is consistent.
Atlas and Excalibur having the same power rating means nothing, Volt who has the same power rating as Excalibur is hundreds if not THOUSANDS of times faster than Excalibur
Here Excalibur is but a mere statue to Volt, debunking the fallacy that all Warframes are equal to each other in physical performance.
In the main canonical trailer for Warframe an Orokin Era Excalibur (Who would be easily the second strongest if not THE strongest version to be debated due to having the best equipment available) going all out is only able to make a blast that consumes 35 people which is more a result of his energy projection than sheer strength.
Impressive blast right? This is the crater after wards
This Excalibur wasn't weakened in any shape or form nor was he constrained by game play mechanics since it was a cinematic (A favorite argument to make on why they don't perform the fanfic level feats they say Excalibur can perform) there is literally no reason for Excalbur to not have just swung his sword one direction and carve a new valley in the other direction instead of taking over a minute to kill literal fodder.
We literally see Excalibur's Kunai get stuck on a Grineer soldiers helm, are you going to genuinely argue that Grineer infantry are wearing armor that can withstand MEGATONS worth of kinetic energy and not only fail to break but also not get sent flying to the horizon from sheer force?
WHERE ARE THE MEGATONS?
WHERE ARE THE KILOTONS?
If Excalibur had 0.1% the strength of Atlas there wouldn't be a Orokin Dropship or even Grineer body left to see. If anyone who sees this post still disagrees go ahead and post a feat of Excalibur doing anything close to 1% of the feat Atlas performed.
-----
Part 2 to follow below.