Movies Dungeons and Dragons: Honor Among Thieves

The Whispering Monk

Well-known member
Osaul
Went and saw D&D a couple nights ago with the kids.

We had a good time!

I didn't go in with lot of expectations, and I've been avoiding reading details and reviews.

On the characters: I think they did a good job of showing characters with all their inherent flaws. Some of it was over the top like Holga's total lack of tact, which was quite fun at some points, or the Paladin's epic attempt to be a Vulcan! Frankly, it was pretty well written in regards to the character interactions and dialogue. Frankly, it was on point with feeling like it was a group of roleplayers in a game of D&D!
In addition, I have to concur with some others that the character development was well done as well. None of the party members felt like a throw away add-in that was just there for others to use for growth.

The pacing was the only thing that felt a bit off. There were 2 or 3 scenes that felt like they went on a bit too long...the graveyard where they have to commune with a series of undead to get to the critical point was funny, but felt like it was a bit too repetetive. Thankfully, there were enough differences that it wasn't painful and it didn't force me completely out of the story.

The plot was well done. I like how they used Forge as the betrayer and didn't waste a lot of time trying to make it some sort of big reveal later in the movie. He may not have been the big baddy, but his role was not insubstantial. Characterization of the baddies was well done in this regard. Even Mrs. Red Wizard herself was interesting.

All in all, I'd probably give this one 4.5 out of 5 Stars. It was fun! It had characters that had character. And, amazingly enough for a fantasy movie (or any movie really) there were consequences to choices made. I also loved that the idea of family was so central to the story. Too many fantasy/action movies are just about the ass-kicking and getting the girl.
 

Val the Moofia Boss

Well-known member
I saw the new D&D movie. It was okay.

First, I didn't really like the visual look of the film. The movie looked very dark, very dim. It was hard to make out detail at points. It also had a desaturated look. Not a fan of the color grading. Also not a fan of the aesthetics. The movie has an overall cheap artstation look. Also, it is 2023, and yet the creatures still look like fake, weightless 3D CGI models rather than the life-like believeable fantasy races and creatures in LotR or Narnia or Avatar or the Orcs from the Warcraft movie. A lot of the environments also looked fake too. The movie didn't look awful but it just didn't look very visually pleasing to me, which is a big F for a fantasy film.

Soundtrack was also completely forgettable.

The actual moment to moment story is okay enough, though I got bored enough at one point to get out of my chair and go to the bathroom. The story point with the daughter was rather irritating. The red witch villain was a nothing character so the finale was not compelling, also felt too much like a capeshit fight. I did not like the mage or the druid.

The dragon's weight causing the hanging platform to unbalance was neat. The colisseum setpiece where the layers of blocks are slowly being removed and they dive into the gel was also neat.

Wouldn't rewatch.
 

Argent

Well-known member
I watched in theaters and it was worth going. Overall a fun fantasy adventure. It also inculdes enough D and D tropes, references so that any fan will like it while managing to appeal to a wider audience.

As from as the special effects they where what I expect from a blockbuster, the acting was decent and Holga was great. The actors really played into their classes.

So while not going to win any rewards it is a decent movie and gives me hope snice this the frist D and D movie I have seen that is decent.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top