Search results

Eh. the whole "MiB somehow managed to defeat the wizarding world's greatest tools" premise makes it an unfair fight. That said, just due to individual competence MiB will win even if you ignore that line.

OP specifically specifies what the MiB has though. If OP just said "MiB vs HP" without specifying what MiB has then it would be fine to bring up the comics. But OP did specify what they have

No, you didn't. I wrote debate posts 3 times and 3 times you replied to them by flinging crap back instead of addressing any of my points. As a consequence of that I realized you are not trying to honestly debate, you are trying to "win". Until you change your ways I am just going to debate...

True. I am finally replying in kind. Why would I waste my time writing a cerebral reply when all I get is crap flung at me after each time? You want to fling crap, well here is a load of crap in your face right back. I gave you several chances durig this conversation and each time you...

You are an ignorant buffoon who starts internet arguments for the purpose of winning, fails at winning, all the while patting himself over the back for your imagined "victory". There is no point in debating with you, because you do not want to debate in good faith, you want to win.

And that is where I stopped reading. If you are going to be a jerk about it I don't have to waste my time on you.

I have never seen a "wizards are idiots" complaints about harry potter ever that had to do with that assumption. Wizards ARE idiots. This comes entirely 100% from reading the harry potter books and has nothing to do with any assumptions. They have zero concepts of safety, or security, or logic...

I never watched the movies. I have watched some scathing reviews about failures listing all the many ways in which they fucked up. As far as I am aware though, what I said applies to both book and movie verse. In both cases the wizards are idiots. They are comically inept.

I should note that I am not arguing that potterverse will win. I am arguing about specific individual points like the mechanics of unplotable. The main issue with potterverse is that everyone is a moron. While MiB is made up of hyper competent individuals. Potterverse has the tools necessary...

Oh as for mental compulsion... that is the muggle repelling charm. That one is mind control that only affects muggles that compels them to ignore locations as if it does not exist.

It cannot be mere mental manipulation. It removes it from all maps in the entire world. When you make a lake (for example) unplotable, every single map on earth that depicts this lake will change to remove it from the map. The earth is actually larger than muggles believe, they just do not...

They do not use any holograms. In fact they are incredibly bad at bending light like that. Harry's invisibility cloak is a priceless ancient artifact attributed to a deity (The Death) and impossible to recreate. The closest they get is a chameleon like spell which helps a bit. But they never...

Wizards don't use holograms / mass illusions. Are you thinking about the platform 9 3/4? Remember how they smashed into it when it was closed? it is either a portal that teleports people, or a spell that lets people phase through solid matter. No hologram. Wizards primarily rely on muggle...

This stipulation gives an overwhelming advantage to MiB. Both sides rely very heavily on their secrecy and mindwipe powers. You just took away that power from wizards, meaning only MiB has cloaking and mindwipes. An MiB agent can Neurolize a Wizard, but a wizard cannot obliviate an MiB agent...