Search results

  1. The Whispering Monk

    What If? Star Trek Federation is transported into the 40k galaxy

    @Zachowon I couldn't find the post where you stated what region/segmentum the Feds would be inserted into the 40K verse. Where was it again?
  2. The Whispering Monk

    What If? Star Trek Federation is transported into the 40k galaxy

    The biggest threat to the Fed is going to be if they somehow sod of the IoM and cause a Crusade to be called. A few hundred IoM Warships would be an existential threat to them. The Federation will be trying to figure out what's up with the players in the galaxy, and they are not used to the...
  3. The Whispering Monk

    What If? Star Trek Federation is transported into the 40k galaxy

    The Tau do actually use the Warp. They just skim across it in microjumps that don't tend to really immerse them completely. Slower than the rest of 40K Warp travel, but also generally much safer. Eldar and Necrons definitely cheat though. Not necessary but appreciated. Totally fair POV. I'd...
  4. The Whispering Monk

    What If? Star Trek Federation is transported into the 40k galaxy

    :ROFLMAO: Certainly, and I'm not saying I won't be party to any discussion because the OP isn't what I'd do. Merely making an opinion known. The reason I lean that way is because the Feddies have been inserted INTO the 40K'verse. In my mind, that means they are then subject to the same...
  5. The Whispering Monk

    What If? Star Trek Federation is transported into the 40k galaxy

    @Zachowon Your post, but I disagree with this decision, simply because it immediately removes one of the key environmental factors in all of 40K. Trek now gets to play around and ignore it...cuz. I would have gone with subspace just being the Warp. Trek is lucky enough to exist in a 'verse...
  6. The Whispering Monk

    What If? Star Trek Federation is transported into the 40k galaxy

    Hadn't really thought of this...but it's likely to make combat warp jumps exceedingly useless and downright suicide. Ship warps into combat range, crew attempts to shrug off the warp effects, while the IoM vessels shoot at them willy nilly.
  7. The Whispering Monk

    What If? Star Trek Federation is transported into the 40k galaxy

    IF trek cloak actually works against 40K sensors. I have doubts about that.
  8. The Whispering Monk

    What If? Star Trek Federation is transported into the 40k galaxy

    Why? They are energy based torpedoes.
  9. The Whispering Monk

    What If? Star Trek Federation is transported into the 40k galaxy

    Only problem for the Feds is that I'm not sure their weapons will penetrate Void Shielding... Cue power level arguments. <Monk takes himself away to hide...with popcorn>
  10. The Whispering Monk

    What If? Star Trek Federation is transported into the 40k galaxy

    Picard was wrong for lying about what was going on. It's that simple. He felt he knew better then his command what should happen. He should have lost his rank abd been cashiered without benefits. "Oh, you don't like it Picard? Go make some wine."
  11. The Whispering Monk

    What If? Star Trek Federation is transported into the 40k galaxy

    @Zachowon have you stated what era of ST gets ported to the Grimdark?
  12. The Whispering Monk

    What If? Star Trek Federation is transported into the 40k galaxy

    Scanners would have trouble picking out the individual 'nids. you'd be better off just bombing them. Especially with the amount of energy transports use. 'Course, I'd LOVE to see what kind of adaptations the nids would come up with after facing the Feddies!
  13. The Whispering Monk

    What If? Star Trek Federation is transported into the 40k galaxy

    It's how the Tau were able to convert a number of outlying Imperial worlds.
  14. The Whispering Monk

    What If? Star Trek Federation is transported into the 40k galaxy

    Can we agree to just get rid of any Infinity Gauntlets out there...no matter where they come from? That means no Q, no wormhole aliens, nothing. The Federation will have to survive on its own. And holy Hannah...has it EVER done that when faced with an existential threat? Because...I'm having...
  15. The Whispering Monk

    What If? Star Trek Federation is transported into the 40k galaxy

    I don't see an expansion from the Feds till they get a much better idea of what they've fallen into. Of course, an expansionist Federation is MUCH more likely to cause the IoM to come try and curbstomp them.
  16. The Whispering Monk

    What If? Star Trek Federation is transported into the 40k galaxy

    Which is why I asked. Because NO ONE in 40K has FTL sensors except the finicky warp prescience. And sensors are capable, but nothing like Trek's god-eye level sensors.
  17. The Whispering Monk

    What If? Star Trek Federation is transported into the 40k galaxy

    @Zachowon I honestly see them losing the subspace sensors completely b/c the Warp is not something consistent or predictable. This would mean several things: -loss of FTL communication -loss of FTL sensors -still likely able to FTL travel, but will be much more dangerous as they won't be able...
  18. The Whispering Monk

    What If? Star Trek Federation is transported into the 40k galaxy

    I think the issue for Feds will be that when it goes wrong for the Vulcans, and it will, they will pop off even worse than the other psykers just because they've got all that bottled emotion for Chaos to play with. The other point is that a pyker suffering the perils of the Warp may just open...
  19. The Whispering Monk

    What If? Star Trek Federation is transported into the 40k galaxy

    Another question for the Federation @Zachowon Will the Federation citizens experience spontaneous awakening of Psykers? I mean, it feels like that would be pretty much guaranteed to happen.
  20. The Whispering Monk

    What If? Star Trek Federation is transported into the 40k galaxy

    @Zachowon Does the Federation's tech work in the 40K'verse? -Does the presence of the Warp FUBAR ST warp engines or their subspace scanners? I'm assuming that subspace scanners would be drastically affected by the Warp. I'm not assuming that all the toys ST gets to play with will be as...
Top