On one hand I can understand the reasoning for the lockdown. Civil, polite forum, etc. Better than handing out suspensions left and right.
On the other hand - what is the problem with people frothing at one another on the web? It is not that they can harm one another ...
Is there actual danger...
The latter.
I second the suggestion to keep SB/SV/AH-com/Long Long Trail/whatever bitching to some roped-off "enter at your own risk" space. I imagine that members who are not exiles from those sites are not particularly interested in reading about them.
I see the "affairs of other boards do...
Speaking of sticky threads - how about axing/merging 9/10ths of existing ones. I personally find it off putting when half of the 1st page is made up of stickies. Or maybe the sticky section could be collapsable (a setting remembered by the forum)?
IMO would be nice.
Going back to the OP:
1 - I have nothing of value to contribute;
2 - IMO a site can do much worse than copying SB's breakdown. I'm new here hence not used to the layout, but I have a feeling that there is some duplication and/or too fine hair splitting. Or that's simply me being the FNG. There...
Re "going forward" - do we need the "new member", "well known member" titles? Or points for "achievements"?
Personally I see them as childish or distracting, tempting me into low content shitposts :) as to pad my record.
I know, I just said that IMO it's childish and silly, but I'm only human...
My ideal for a political section is the Hyde Park at Warships1 - it was very lightly moderated.
IIRC anything short of death threats was allowed. I'm fairly sure I've seen posts starting with "only a brain dead puppy kicking leftard/fascist moron like you ... " - which I absolutely do not mind...