Search results

  1. A

    AG-Center retreats just before Bagration, avoids destruction

    I think tha without Hitler ,or without Sralin knewing everything about USA,you would be right. But Sralin knew about A bomb,so he could not made peace,when USA would take all otherwise.And Hitler would help him making no retreat order again and firing anybody who disobey. Soviets would just rid...
  2. A

    AG-Center retreats just before Bagration, avoids destruction

    I agree that german could stop soviets for 6-9 months,but not longer.And as long as Hitler lived he would never agree to peace,becouse in canon he always wonted from Sralin too much. 1.Sralin wonted Europe,not Asia. 2.It was Zhukow mistake.Other generals did not made them 3.Sralin wont screw...
  3. A

    AG-Center retreats just before Bagration, avoids destruction

    1.Still,as long as Hitler lived,there would be no peace with soviets,becouse he wonted peace with Alliess.Which would be impossible as long as democrats ruled,which mean at least till 1946.By that time,germany would glow in night. And Sralin started WW2 to get part of Europe,not hold his own -...
  4. A

    AG-Center retreats just before Bagration, avoids destruction

    Sorry for late answer. 1.FDR would fight as long as Sralin wonted,and Sralin wonted separate peace with Hitler,but dude was not interested.You want separate peace - kill Hitler first. 2.German would not use navy to get supplies on Belarus - that is difference.Fire support was less important...
  5. A

    AG-Center retreats just before Bagration, avoids destruction

    I hope that you are right,becouse that mean free Poland when A bomb drop on Berlin.But,highly unlikely,becouse : 1.Kurland could hold thanks to german navy - no such thinh on Belarus. 2.Soviets need 50km or less good terrain to attack - and i am sure they would found it on 420km front 3.Soviets...
  6. A

    AG-Center retreats just before Bagration, avoids destruction

    1.Soviets could gather even close to 1000 guns per km,and they had few lines of fieldguns wheel by wheel.It was even better for them,becouse only one crew in unit knew how to properly aim,rest only knew how to quick reload. Terrain? no problem for them,soviets could operate on terrain impossible...
  7. A

    AG-Center retreats just before Bagration, avoids destruction

    All true - but it still helped soviets more.They really would gather 800 fieldguns per km,and send penal battalions after initial barrage.Then destroy bunkers which massacred such battalion and get through. Repeat every time they meet fortified line. And send one dyvision per km where they were...
  8. A

    AG-Center retreats just before Bagration, avoids destruction

    From Germans,not nazis.And germans would still lost ,becouse Hitler would fire Kluge and gave "no retreat" order. Soviets need 1-2 months to replenish casualties.Even if that would be 3 months,they would still destroy AG center in 1944. Only difference would be some free countries in...
  9. A

    AG-Center retreats just before Bagration, avoids destruction

    Wiki is good for nothing,Rokossowski was soviet,and for them heritage was unimportant.Otherwise Sralin would create georgian empire. Nikołaj Iwanow was right when he was dissident,and is right now. And yes,they were waiting.Book is working on soviet documents - hence at least 13 soviets calls to...
  10. A

    AG-Center retreats just before Bagration, avoids destruction

    Do you truly belive in wikipedia and Putin ? becouse both are not good resources. IIf you want resource, professor Nikołaj Iwanow read all soviet reports which are not secret and in 2010 wrote book "Powstanie Warszawskie widziane z Moskwy" - my translation,Warsaw Uprising see from Moscow...
  11. A

    AG-Center retreats just before Bagration, avoids destruction

    1.Offensive which took over Romania 2.Yes,he waited.And under Radzymin 220 german tanks attacked 344 soviets,destroing 58 of them.Soviets still outnumbered them.Month later the same soviet army had 500 tanks.And still did nothing. 3.In OTL they had strenght to take over Balkans waiting till we...
  12. A

    AG-Center retreats just before Bagration, avoids destruction

    Soviets gathered forces for next main offensive about september 44 - so they would destroy AG Center then,becouse Kluge would be arleady fired. Which means - nothing really change,becouse in OTL Sralin waited 5 month for germans to destroy Warsaw for him. Now,he would not wait,but result would...
Top