Search results

  1. A

    1920-what if soviet defeat Poland

    1.Nope.They considered themselved as "locals" till german-paid dudes teach them,that they are lithuanians. 2.Against,nope.Not me - polish aristocrat who had land there,since then he knew that people there do not speak one language and used polish when try speak to dudes from other villages,and...
  2. A

    1920-what if soviet defeat Poland

    Unfortunatelly,only in polish books.Volume 2 is about WW1 - i do not read volume 1,becouse it was about personal life,agriculture,and Petersburg inner politics. But,Vol2 is very interesting - for example,russians could defest germans in 1914,but there was german clique who prevented russian army...
  3. A

    1920-what if soviet defeat Poland

    Said german supermegaultranationalist who try show german as innocent victims of bad poles after WW1. polish magnat Hipolit Korwin -Milewski ,who had lands there,wrote in his memories /70 lat wspomnień-70 years of memories/ that lithuanians do not use one language but local ones.As a...
  4. A

    1920-what if soviet defeat Poland

    1.Lithuanians state,and modern nation,was both made by germans.In 1914 there were maybe 500 people who considered themselves"lithuanian" - almost all sponsored by germans rest - they were locals,teached that they are lithuanians during german occupation in the end of WW1. 2.Everything is...
  5. A

    1920-what if soviet defeat Poland

    So,basically we had two scenarios : 1.soviets attack Germany and get beaten with or without Allied help.New White Russia, no Poland. 2.Soviets are smart enough to ally with germans, and they are for sure dump enough to buy it.Soviets take part or all of Europe, backstab germans, prepare for next...
  6. A

    1920-what if soviet defeat Poland

    Yes,soviets was mostly mob.Mob welcomed by all leftist and most minorities,but still mob. That is why they need alliance with Germany - to use their experienced troops and commanders to take over Europe, and backstab them later. Any alliance with soviets was suicide, but...germans in OTL was...
  7. A

    1920-what if soviet defeat Poland

    To win over entire Europe, soviets need Germany and local socialists help.That could be done, Germans belived,that they could made deals with soviets in OTL,and socialist everywhere belived in Lenin Earthy Paradise. Of course, even then Foch&others could still beat them. And remember - Trocky...
  8. A

    1920-what if soviet defeat Poland

    Nope.They made deal with soviets during and after 1920 - so why stop now ? german belived, that they could control Lenin.If he died and Trocky take over, there would be war and soviet defeat - but with Lenin alive, they would attack France together. With help of socialist and masons there, they...
  9. A

    1920-what if soviet defeat Poland

    do not fear,my polish is almost as bad !!!!! But - germans in OTL was stupid enough to help soviet in 1920,and later helped them develop tanks,planes and artillery.Hitler was smart enough to stop that,but he still fall for Stalin trap and agreed to alliance in 1939. So,germans in my TL would...
  10. A

    1920-what if soviet defeat Poland

    If German do not decide,that Lenin as their agent would be excellent ally against Allies./sorry for bad pun/ They really were stupid enough to do so,and Lenin was pragmatist and act as loyal ally till they come to France. Where useful idiots/socialists and masons/ would welcome soviets. Of...
  11. A

    1920-what if soviet defeat Poland

    Soviet could conqer Europe not becouse they had great army,but becouse every european country save England was close to revolution,and they would be welcome by useful idiots ewerywhere. But - good occasion is one thing, and using it propely is another.And Europe still had reliable soldiers and...
Back
Top