Star Trek The Man/Kzin Wars in Star Trek - Discussion and Brainstorming

AndrewJTalon

Well-known member
Founder
You know, I'm a big fan of Larry Niven's Known Space. And so were the producers of the Star Trek: Animated Series. They adapted "The Soft Weapon" into an episode, after all. But it does make me think: What if you tried to fully integrate the Kzin into Star Trek? In fanfiction, it's possible since we don't have the pesky copyright issues to think about.

What it would do to the Enterprise Era is especially interesting. According to Sulu, the Man/Kzin Wars in the Trek verse happened around 200 years before the TOS era. This means that Earth ran into an interstellar war just a few decades out of World War III.

So let's explore this. Let's say that, as in the Known Space novels, the Kzin had had an interstellar empire. One forged originally with slower-than-light vessels over a thousand years. They weren't seen as a large threat by the Vulcans because they lacked the warp drive-Probably because they conquered worlds without warp drive. However, by Earth's late 21st century, the Kzin had obtained the warp drive and were confident enough to try removing their biggest potential rivals: The Vulcans.

By the 2080s to 90s, humanity had almost fully recovered from World War 3 and were quickly expanding out into local space. Alpha Centauri, Tau Ceti, and many other systems soon became Earth colonies. Mars was terraformed, and Venus was underway to becoming habitable. They had unlocked Warp 2, and their fastest ships were nearing Warp 3.

From the Kzinti perspective however, Earth and her colonies seemed ripe for conquest. As a point to launch their invasion of Vulcan, and as a useful slave species. They thought that after a massive world war humanity would be easy to bring to heel and use their worlds as a beachhead from which to conquer Vulcan space.

Of course, it turned into an utter disaster for the Kzin. Humanity may have still been recovering from its last world war and a whole generation had grown up with a dim view of any kind of conflict after it, but when push comes to shove? The reason humanity tries to avoid going to war is because they are so very, very good at it.

At this time, the Vulcans were engaged in a massive escalation with the Andorians-Their cold war was going hot, and they couldn't afford to give humanity much more support than humanitarian during this conflict. So humanity had to largely fend for itself in this war. While the Kzin were limited to Warp 2 speeds, they certainly had a much bigger fleet. The conflict at one point got bad enough that the Earth colonies of Alpha Centauri were conquered and occupied by the Kzin. However, a breakthrough was made at Utopia Planitia. The Warp 3 engine system came online, and a new generation of antimatter reactor systems followed that provided more power not just for engines but for weapons too. The Vulcans may have helped out a bit here and there as well.

New Warp 3 (and later 4) capable Earth fleets soon decimated the Kzinti fleets, and destroyed their war machine. A smaller series of conflicts with the Kzin would have ensued, with Earth winning each time (especially once the Vulcans were able to assist). They drove them back, further and further, until they were at last reduced to only their home system under the Treaty of Sirius. This would have been a few decades before the NX-01 Enterprise's launch, of course.

So, how would Enterprise have looked in this timeline?

What would the war have been like?

What are some interesting stories that might be told about this era?

And what are the implications for the future history of Trek?
 

Urabrask Revealed

Let them go.
Founder
So, how would Enterprise have looked in this timeline?
In my opinion, the same as the original one. Out of universe, the design is simply too iconic to do away with.
In-universe, the Enterprise was intended to be a exploration and diplomacy ship, not a warcruiser.

What would the war have been like?
Bad. Humanity, as already stated, just came out of a world war and now have to enter another? I imagine the Federation to punch hard with whatever they have at hand to finish the war as fast as possible. I doubt anyone would've turned a blind eye to outright warcrimes as Humanity defines it tho.

What are some interesting stories that might be told about this era?
I... got nothing for now. Perhaps a planetary siege, or something like that line?

And what are the implications for the future history of Trek?
Well, with a victory over the Kzin, and the integration of the defeated, the Federation would command more respect from the Klingons. Conversely, the Klingons would also antagonize them more because they promise a good fight and honor if a battle is won.
 

Tryglaw

Well-known member
At this time, the Vulcans were engaged in a massive escalation with the Andorians-Their cold war was going hot, and they couldn't afford to give humanity much more support than humanitarian during this conflict.

The kind of support to actually matter would be high technologies, not humanitarian feel-good stuff.
Depending on technological support being provided or not, or maybe Andorians being less restrictive and more willing to sell the good stuff, this would shape Earth's relationship with both powers. With Earth being friendly towards whoever helped out - kinda sorta B5 situation with E-M War and Narn Regime selling Earth advanced weapons.

So, how would Enterprise have looked in this timeline?

Truth to be told, I've always despised the Akira-prise design, totally no creativity...
Early Enterprise would probably follow the lineage you can see in Starfleet Museum, for Romulan War / Early Federation period.


Or this:
fleet_starfleet_1.gif


What would the war have been like?

Hard fought no doubt, this in an un-tapped gold mine for creative writers, how the war could have been like. Also, with warp drive still being a major hurdle, we could see actual carrier doctrine being applied, with warp-capable carriers carrying impulse-only strike craft into battle... (hint, hint)
:D

What are some interesting stories that might be told about this era?

About all of them?
;)
From first contact, careful "poking around" by both sides to get a measure of each other, via escalation of tensions and start of hostilities all through the war to the bitter end...

And what are the implications for the future history of Trek?

Humanity will be much more militaristic, especially if the Romulan War comes right afterwards, with the Romulans seeing the defeat of the Kzin as a sign of things to come and deciding to deal with Earth before it becomes too much of a threat...
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top