Rank Basic Sci-Fi Infantry

[Husky_Khan]

Say a B-1 Battledroid from Star Wars with a standard E-5 Blaster Rifle is worth ONE point!

How would you rank, based on a point scale, the following basic infantry from various settings, on a basic point system using the B1 Battledroid being worth One point as a scale.

1. Starfleet Ensign (Star Trek Circa-2375): Equipped with a Type-3 Phaser Rifle and Type-2 Hand Phaser.

2. Jaffa (Stargate): Standard Armor and Staff Weapon and a Zat Gun.

3. NCR Trooper (Fallout New Vegas): Standard Trooper Armor, Service Rifle, 9mm Pistol, Frag Grenade

4. NCR Patrol Ranger (Fallout New Vegas): Ranger Patrol Armor, Brush Gun, .357 Revolver

5. Imperial Stormtrooper (Star Wars): Standard Stormtrooper Armor, E-11 Blaster Rifle

6. Republic Clone Trooper (Star Wars): Standard Clonetrooper Armor, DC-15A Blaster Rifle, DC-17 Hand Blaster

7. Colonial Marine (AvP): M3 Pattern Personal Armor, M41A Pulse Pulse Rifle w/U1 Grenade Launcher, VP-70 Pistol, M40 HEDP Hand Grenade

8. ISA Marine (Killzone): Ranger Body Armor, M82 Assault Rifle with M303 Undersling Grenade Launcher, M4 Revolver, M194 Frag Grenade

9. COG Gear (Gears of War: COG Trooper Armor, Lancer Assault Rifle, MX8 Snub Pistol, Bolo Grenade

10. Terran Marine (Starcraft): CMC-300 Powered Combat Armor, C-14 Impaler Gauss Rifle, C-7 Stinger Gauss Pistol, Frag Grenade

11. Imperial Guardsman (WH40K): Flak Armor, Lasgun, Frag Grenade

12. UNSC Marine (Halo): Battle Dress Uniform/Armor, MA5B Assault Rifle with Underslung Grenade Launcher, M6E Pistol, M9 Frag Grenade

13. Combine Overwatch Trooper (Half Life): Hard plate Personal Armor, AR2 Pulse Rifle, Frag Grenade

14. Prime Legionary (Fallout New Vegas): Prime Armor, Hunting Rifle, Machete Gladius

15. Stargate Marine (Stargate): SG Vest, FN-P90 Personal Defense Weapon, M9 Beretta Pistol, Frag Grenade

EDIT:

Bonus if you can keep it as multiples of five (5, 10, 15, 20, 50, 100 etc).

 

[Scooby Doo]

B1 Battle Droid = 1 Point
Starfleet Ensign= 10 Points
Jaffa = 10 Points
NCR Trooper = 10 Points
Imperial Stormtrooper= 10 Points
Colonial Marines = 10 Points
ISA Marine = 10 Points
UNSC Marine = 10 Points
Combine Overwatch= 10 Points
COG Gear = 10 Points
Legionary= 10 Points
Stargate Marine = 10 Points
Clone Trooper = 10/20 Points (10 For basic clones but 20 for elite clones like 501st)
NCR Patrol Ranger = 30 Points
Terran Marine = 50 Points

 

[Carrot of Truth]

From what planet are the Imperial Guards from? Because if they are from Catachan they get all the points.

 

[Husky_Khan]

From what planet are the Imperial Guards from? Because if they are from Catachan they get all the points.

Generic Cadian pattern not from Cadia.

 

[Carrot of Truth]

Dude you be calling Catachans basic.

Did... Did you just call yourself out?

 

[Scooby Doo]

Generic Cadiana should be on par with NCR Patrol Rangers but with better equipment so I'd put them on the 30 Point Range.


I don't tier Gary Su's like Catachans because their feats are accomplished by PIS and Plot armor, having enemies suddenly operate at a fraction of their usual physical ability while doing the stupidest things, basically bad writing to make their forces look better than everyone else.

 

[Carrot of Truth]

Generic Cadiana should be on par with NCR Patrol Rangers but with better equipment so I'd put them on the 30 Point Range.


I don't tier Gary Su's like Catachans because their feats are accomplished by PIS and Plot armor, having enemies suddenly operate at a fraction of their usual physical ability while doing the stupidest things, basically bad writing to make their forces look better than everyone else.

I'd say some of the experienced Cadian regiments that have been fighting Orks and Tyranids would be far above NCR patrol rangers but then the shittier regiments that haven't seen any action would bring the average down.

 

[Scooby Doo]

I'd say some of the experienced Cadian regiments that have been fighting Orks and Tyranids would be far above NCR patrol rangers but then the shittier regiments that haven't seen any action would bring the average down.

The amount of fresher Cadians definitely exceed their veterans

To contrast pretty much every NCR Ranger was a veteran NCR trooper that passed a 20% bar (Only 2/10 NCR soldiers pass ranger training) before earning the badge.

I'd say they're roughly compared in terms of average vs average, NCR Rangers are expected to do tasks that would take an entire NCR platoon to do.

 

[Husky_Khan]

Say a B-1 Battledroid from Star Wars with a standard E-5 Blaster Rifle is worth ONE point!

How would you rank, based on a point scale, the following basic infantry from various settings, on a basic point system using the B1 Battledroid being worth One point as a scale.

1. Starfleet Ensign (Star Trek Circa-2375): Equipped with a Type-3 Phaser Rifle and Type-2 Hand Phaser.

2. Jaffa (Stargate): Standard Armor and Staff Weapon and a Zat Gun.

3. NCR Trooper (Fallout New Vegas): Standard Trooper Armor, Service Rifle, 9mm Pistol, Frag Grenade

4. NCR Patrol Ranger (Fallout New Vegas): Ranger Patrol Armor, Brush Gun, .357 Revolver

5. Imperial Stormtrooper (Star Wars): Standard Stormtrooper Armor, E-11 Blaster Rifle

6. Republic Clone Trooper (Star Wars): Standard Clonetrooper Armor, DC-15A Blaster Rifle, DC-17 Hand Blaster

7. Colonial Marine (AvP): M3 Pattern Personal Armor, M41A Pulse Pulse Rifle w/U1 Grenade Launcher, VP-70 Pistol, M40 HEDP Hand Grenade

8. ISA Marine (Killzone): Ranger Body Armor, M82 Assault Rifle with M303 Undersling Grenade Launcher, M4 Revolver, M194 Frag Grenade

9. COG Gear (Gears of War: COG Trooper Armor, Lancer Assault Rifle, MX8 Snub Pistol, Bolo Grenade

10. Terran Marine (Starcraft): CMC-300 Powered Combat Armor, C-14 Impaler Gauss Rifle, C-7 Stinger Gauss Pistol, Frag Grenade

11. Imperial Guardsman (WH40K): Flak Armor, Lasgun, Frag Grenade

12. UNSC Marine (Halo): Battle Dress Uniform/Armor, MA5B Assault Rifle with Underslung Grenade Launcher, M6E Pistol, M9 Frag Grenade

13. Combine Overwatch Trooper (Half Life): Hard plate Personal Armor, AR2 Pulse Rifle, Frag Grenade

14. Prime Legionary (Fallout New Vegas): Prime Armor, Hunting Rifle, Machete Gladius

15. Stargate Marine (Stargate): SG Vest, FN-P90 Personal Defense Weapon, M9 Beretta Pistol, Frag Grenade

EDIT:

Bonus if you can keep it as multiples of five (5, 10, 15, 20, 50, 100 etc).

B-1 Battledroid: 1 Point

Starfleet Ensign: 5 Points
Jaffa: 2 Points
NCR Trooper: 5 Points (The Service Rifle is decent enough but if they were given an R91, Type 93, Marksman or Assault Carbine etc they'd be with everyone else at 10 points)
NCR Patrol Ranger: 30 Points
Imperial Stormtrooper: 10 Points
Republic Clone Trooper: 15 Points
Colonial Marine: 15 Points
ISA Marine: 10 Points
COG Gear: 15 Points
Terran Marine: 30 Points
Imperial Guardsmen: 10 Points
UNSC Marine: 10 Points
Combine Overwatch Trooper: 10 Points
Prime Legionary: 10 Points
Stargate Marine: 10 Points