AHC/PC/WI: A Jewish state in Eastern Europe?

[ATP]

Not sure about polish jews, but Russian jews were conscripted just as often as any other russian and fought just as well as other conscripst in the Russian army, i.e as long as they were constantly supervised and they didn't have a good chance of running away.

During 1920 war they failed as soldiers on both sides,and was good only as torturers in CZK.Led by good polish gentry Dzierżyński.

 

[The Unicorn]

During 1920 war they failed as soldiers on both sides,

Unwilling conscripts beaten and starved generally make poor soldiers, yes.

 

[WolfBear]

During 1920 war they failed as soldiers on both sides,and was good only as torturers in CZK.Led by good polish gentry Dzierżyński.

Apparently Dzerzinsky once tried to get Polish factory workers to rebel against the Russian Tsar, failed in doing this, and was subsequently beaten up by these Polish factory workers in response to this:

The Real Lenin: Traitor, Parasite, Failure

There is a general consensus that Stalin was a sadistic tyrant. But the ghost of his predecessor remains 'handshakeworthy' on the left hand side of the political spectrum. The SWPLy bobos of Seattle, who would not have been long for the Communist world, erected a statue to him in the city...

www.unz.com

Epic fail on his part!

 

[ATP]

Unwilling conscripts beaten and starved generally make poor soldiers, yes.

Polish soldiers was not beaten or starved,and,as a result,peasant consprits fought relatively well.Jewish run or betrayed polish state.
In the same time,jews was good for soviet only as commissars,becouse faced with enemy who was not bound and have rifle,they fled,too.Lenin elite troops was latvian and germans.

And @WolfBear is right about Dzierżyński - poles do not followed him.That is why "polish" soviet goverment in both 1920 and 1945 was made either from soviets or polish jews.