Search results for query: *

  1. ThatZenoGuy

    Star Trek Star Trek Starship Captain Showdown

    The 'type' refers to the overall weapon part of the phaser, but the emitter is seemingly different based on what it's mounted on. The standard lineup of TNG ships all use Type 10 phasers, just with the smaller ships having less of them. If it was more a designation of modernity, the smaller...
  2. ThatZenoGuy

    Star Trek Star Trek Starship Captain Showdown

    Yeah sorry, my mistake, however one must question how high the rates of fire of both ships are, more launchers=/=higher torpedo output. Type 8 phasers are not at all comparable to Type 10, you need to get to the Sovereign class to get higher output phaser banks. Type 8's can fit on a small...
  3. ThatZenoGuy

    Star Trek Star Trek Starship Captain Showdown

    In hindsight looking up the specs for the Enterprise B/Excelsior, I think the Voyager has it beat. 5 dual (10 phasers in total) Type 8 Phasers vs 13 phasers, with at least some being Type 10 (galaxy class sized) 4 Photon Torpedo tubes vs 5 Photon Torpedo Tubes (including at least a couple...
  4. ThatZenoGuy

    Star Trek Star Trek Starship Captain Showdown

    I think there's a few episodes which have moments like "we can't fire torpedoes at this range because we'll destroy ourselves", especially when the shields are weakened/down. I think most starships can handle an indirect torpedo blast with full shields, but it becomes risky when ships are damaged.
  5. ThatZenoGuy

    Star Trek Star Trek Starship Captain Showdown

    No I really mean that when you scan a 3d model of the Warbird, even accounting for empty space, it's 4 times the mass of the Galaxy class for minimal if any greater power in combat. To make an analogy, this is like the Chinese making a four hundred thousand ton ultra-carrier which provides no...
  6. ThatZenoGuy

    Star Trek Star Trek Starship Captain Showdown

    The Galaxy class is of course a powerful warship, multiple alien species basically treat it as a dreadnought. But for it's considerable size, it is not as powerful as it would seem. The only ship worse in this regard that I can think of is the Romulan Warbird, it has 4-5 times the volume of...
  7. ThatZenoGuy

    Star Trek Star Trek Starship Captain Showdown

    The only thing which beats ripped-shirt Kirk is the Gorn. But even the Gorn lost to 'build a cannon out of random garbage' Kirk.
  8. ThatZenoGuy

    Star Trek Star Trek Starship Captain Showdown

    Because the OP specifies "Enterprise B" it can only get the best refit the Enterprise B got in the franchise. Lakota was a one-off refit as far as I am aware of.
  9. ThatZenoGuy

    Star Trek Star Trek Starship Captain Showdown

    Dominion fighters destroyed a Galaxy class because their polaron weapons ignore shields and they rammed it. The phasers on the Defiant do not ignore shields.
  10. ThatZenoGuy

    Star Trek Star Trek Starship Captain Showdown

    This is in the Red Corner's favor. Enterprise D isn't especially good at combat but it's the closest thing there is to a Federation Battleship. The Defiant is a tough, strong little ship but I don't give it good odds against a well captained Galaxy class, and the Enterprise D has had various...
Back
Top