Search results

  1. Scottty

    Philosophy Why Individualism is False

    No, the universal true moral axiom would be that each couple of parents has an obligation to raise their child. These things can have variables, wildcards and conditional branching, you know. Not that I necessarily agree with the idea that a moral principle must be universally valid. There can...
  2. Scottty

    Philosophy Why Individualism is False

    Why not? I can myself come up with arguments for that claim, but I'd like to see yours. Just a bald statement like that is not enough.
  3. Scottty

    Philosophy Why Individualism is False

    I think I'll share some of my own musings, here. This. Back in the Middle Ages when medieval thinkers were developing their political philosophy, feudalism and monarchy were what they knew. So much of their ideas presupposed it as the default form of government, rather than as one of many...
  4. Scottty

    Philosophy Why Individualism is False

    It's bad enough to have the death penalty for arbitrary, trivial things. Even worse for someone to be allowed to be judge, jury and executioner at his sole discretion.
  5. Scottty

    Philosophy Why Individualism is False

    Also, in at least some parts of Europe, a peasant was not allowed to leave his village and go live somewhere else without the permission of his lord.
  6. Scottty

    Philosophy Why Individualism is False

    I'd like to share an inspirational quote I just saw here.
  7. Scottty

    Philosophy Why Individualism is False

    Well, sadly often nowadays only one of the two people is.
  8. Scottty

    Philosophy Why Individualism is False

    Well... I think there's some false alternatives there. Let's start with "an individual cannot exist without society" - "society" is an ideologically loaded term. I would prefer to say that people cannot usually exist without community. Which is not the same thing. I think I read somewhere that...
  9. Scottty

    Philosophy Why Individualism is False

    I feel that what's missing here is a clear definition of what is intended by "Individualism". That word has a range of meaning. Please don't assume that we all already know what you mean.
Back
Top