Search results

  1. Circle of Willis

    Lord of the Rings The Tolkien Thread

    I've always found it hilarious that Movie-Aragorn commits a war crime by murdering the Mouth of Sauron (even if he was being a prick, as should have been expected from the most evil Man in Sauron's employ) in the middle of parley. And before he even got to relay any actual terms from Sauron to...
  2. Circle of Willis

    Lord of the Rings The Tolkien Thread

    Aside from them being meant to represent 'Little England' types, aren't the Hobbits of the Second Age still living in total obscurity around the Anduin, on the opposite side of the Misty Mountains from Eriador where the Shire is located? And the Shire itself wouldn't even be a thing until more...
  3. Circle of Willis

    Lord of the Rings The Tolkien Thread

    This article and the Polygon one it sourced come across as fujoshis trying way too hard to make their slash fanfics canon. Even setting aside the obvious - that Tolkien, being a tradcath born in the 19th century, simply wouldn't have ever written such a relationship into his Legendarium nor...
Top