Search results for query: *

  1. Ash's Boomstick

    What If? What if the Predator Race is put on trial

    The Spartan IIs didn't have the same augmentations as the IIIs, for example they didn't have the chemical based ones that made them aggressive and difficult. But you are correct that Noble Team weren't as bad, so it is possible that they were either able to solve that problem with those few or...
  2. Ash's Boomstick

    What If? What if the Predator Race is put on trial

    The issue with the Spartans IIIs is not only were their families wiped out by aliens, but they themselves have undergone genetic and chemical changes to their bodies that are both unstable and dangerous, this caused mental imbalances and increased psychological damage if not strictly controlled...
  3. Ash's Boomstick

    What If? What if the Predator Race is put on trial

    Ok I'll explain my way of thinking as a mod back then it may help, if I believed that someone was breaching the rules, it didn't matter who it was, they were hit with an infraction. I hit staff members, newcomers, people who had been there for longer than I had. Every one of them was if I...
  4. Ash's Boomstick

    What If? What if the Predator Race is put on trial

    Ok I will quote if that is what you want. In case you didn't notice I said I left the forum due to its politics, I do not follow one side or another, especially American politics due to not being an American myself. In fact I was not aware of what was happening there regarding the left/right...
  5. Ash's Boomstick

    What If? What if the Predator Race is put on trial

    Your knowledge is not the same as I have, likely due to a different upbringing and culture. And yes, I used to be several years ago before i decided that politics was taking the place over too much (I'm apolitical) and had it out with the other staff for their actions, laziness and other...
  6. Ash's Boomstick

    What If? What if the Predator Race is put on trial

    Its quite obvious that the laws as shown in series are based on current day legal practices because it wouldn't be anything else, people have to follow the plot and creating random laws out of nowhere is not going to let that happen. The entire series is set out like that, for hundreds maybe...
  7. Ash's Boomstick

    What If? What if the Predator Race is put on trial

    It also goes against established rules and regulations of a court, whoever wrote it didn't know much about law at all. I believe they were pretty much forced into it because there were no other JAG personnel in the area, which is very much against the rule both in a military (yes Starfleet is a...
  8. Ash's Boomstick

    What If? What if the Predator Race is put on trial

    Except when we see them in Measure of a Man and The Drumhead (possibly) and at least one episode of DS9 and one of Voyager at the very least mention the JAG, not sure if we see anything after that. And yes Roddenbury was quite a moron.
  9. Ash's Boomstick

    What If? What if the Predator Race is put on trial

    Yes they do and usually those officers are member of the Judge Advocate General's office (granted not always in Trek) which is a specific area of the military dedicated to the legal profession.
  10. Ash's Boomstick

    What If? What if the Predator Race is put on trial

    No-one knows how any of this works, sat least give each side an actual lawyer.
  11. Ash's Boomstick

    What If? What if the Predator Race is put on trial

    "The Prosecution: Captain Sisko and Captain James T Kirk The Defense: Captain Picard and Captain Janeway." Why are these all non-lawyer federation officers, they canonically are not allowed to get involved in this (Against the Prime Directive) "The Judge: Captain Sheridan (B5)" This is...
  12. Ash's Boomstick

    What If? What if the Predator Race is put on trial

    These kinds of 'trials' are bullshit from the start, what it is doing is declaring an entire race as fit or unfit due to the actions of a very few of their people. In other science fiction regarding the exact same thing we call these kinds of actions cowardly or reprehensible (And more than one...
Back
Top