Gate fanfic ideas and recs.

[Agent23]

Ok, we all know Gate, we all love Gate, we all agree who best gitrl is.

So, time to make list of all the best fanfics, and perhaps breed a few warrior plot bunnies that can grow into more great fanfics.

 

[Abhorsen]

Ok, we all know Gate, we all love Gate, we all agree who best gitrl is.

So, time to make list of all the best fanfics, and perhaps breed a few warrior plot bunnies that can grow into more great fanfics.

Hate to say it, but I hated gate. It's a great idea done badly, IMO. So I'd love to read good fic, but I'd expect those to be crossovers/something radically different, w/o the main character, just the setting.

 

[Agent23]

Hate to say it, but I hated gate. It's a great idea done badly, IMO. So I'd love to read good fic, but I'd expect those to be crossovers/something radically different, w/o the main character, just the setting.

Well, you can always take the premise and have a totally different universe meet the Saderans.

IIRC there was one where it was crossed over with Metro 2033.

And it is not like you can't write something with more traps or a few genderbends.

 

[Chiron]

How about Gate: Thus the Saderans Fought the Khaleesi. Or any other area of the Game of Thrones/A Song of Fire and Ice Universe timeline or Location.

Or crossover of Gate and Elder Scrolls, or Warcraft, or Warhammer Fantasy Classic, not Age of Sigmar though as its shit. You aren't scamming one buck out me Games Workshop, never again. "Splurges a few thousand bucks on a new Primaris Army like a chump."

 

[Agent23]

How about Gate: Thus the Saderans Fought the Khaleesi. Or any other area of the Game of Thrones/A Song of Fire and Ice Universe timeline or Location.

That might be good, just ISOT the fleet she was using to go to Westeros with into Falmart, or have the Gate open in one of the cities she took.
Whatever happens will be better than what we had in the 8th season of GoT and whatever GRRM will eventually do.

I will see your Khaleesi and raise you one Maid Otaku computer programmer.

Let us just have the Gate open in their version of Tokyo.
Although this will be a curbstomp if the Saderans piss off Tohru or any other Dragonmaid-verse dragon.

The World's Finest Assassin Gets Reincarnated in Another World as an Aristocrat is another crossover I'd love to see, but even though that universe might be a somewhat closer match to Falmart, TWFA mages are a lot more powerful, and if Lugh is there and he disseminates his magical guns, magical artillery and magical rods from god, well, it can turn into a stomp.
And his harem growing even larger.

Or crossover of Gate and Elder Scrolls, or Warcraft, or Warhammer Fantasy Classic, not Age of Sigmar though as its shit. You aren't scamming one buck out me Games Workshop, never again. "Splurges a few thousand bucks on a new Primaris Army like a chump."

TBH I prefer it when the Saderans have to deal with interesting, technologically advanced enemies.

Like, say, Mr. House-run New Vegas, or the Enclave(FO)

Some of the minor factions from Cyberpunk 2077. Saderan invasion vs. Night City will be quite entertaining.V's Yuri harem will grow larger.

 

[Carrot of Truth]

Elder Scrolls would probably work easiest in that Gates opening up there is nothing new and could be chalked up to Sheogorath getting a laugh or something along those lines. The Gate world could be a different Kalpa to explain why their magic may not work the same ect.

 

[Hlaalu Agent]

Elder Scrolls would probably work easiest in that Gates opening up there is nothing new and could be chalked up to Sheogorath getting a laugh or something along those lines. The Gate world could be a different Kalpa to explain why their magic may not work the same ect.

Or it could be a legit "adjacent place", different plane of Mundus (could possible in the cosmology), or maybe, just maybe an entirely different dream- but that would require some finagling to work. But, yes, such things are easily workable. And I'd feel sorry for Gate, because TES is one of those trap settings, like Equestria. It looks far weaker than it actually is, both settings are meat grinders.

 

[Carrot of Truth]

Or it could be a legit "adjacent place", different plane of Mundus (could possible in the cosmology), or maybe, just maybe an entirely different dream- but that would require some finagling to work. But, yes, such things are easily workable. And I'd feel sorry for Gate, because TES is one of those trap settings, like Equestria. It looks far weaker than it actually is, both settings are meat grinders.

The reason I said different Kalpa is because Akavir is basically a different one further in the future, Thats part of the reason they have repeatedly beat the crap out of Tameriel in the lore. In this case Tameriel would be the more advanced kalpa beating up on a younger one.

 

[Chiron]

The Gate opens up on Arda (LOTR) First Age after The Nirnaeth Arnoediad commences and slams into Morgoth's Rear, convincing Ulfang to renege on his deal with Morgoth.

"Kicks back and laughs"

The Gate alternatively opens up in the Second Age on Numenor as Sauron in brought to it.

Or the Gate opens up at the Pelenor Fields just as Aragorn and Eomer have won the day and slam into their exhausted forces.

Or the fun, the shenanigans, and... Wait... Rory and Gandalf teaming up...

...
...

Ah, I'm not the Insurance Carrier for Arda and not responsible for the property damage.

 

[Hlaalu Agent]

The reason I said different Kalpa is because Akavir is basically a different one further in the future, Thats part of the reason they have repeatedly beat the crap out of Tameriel in the lore. In this case Tameriel would be the more advanced kalpa beating up on a younger one.

Possibly, but that is opening a huge can of worms- presuming Akavir is in another kalpa. But, yes, transkalpic travel is probably a good way to explain crossovers, among other things like saying the Dwemer did it.

Anyways, a fun thing might be having the portal open up at the World Wound and them having to deal with all the shenanigans of PF and endless demon hordes. Or if you want insanity, have a portal open up to one of the crazy Paradox Game Mod settings like RF and have everyone just scream.

 

[Agent23]

The Gate opens up on Arda (LOTR) First Age after The Nirnaeth Arnoediad commences and slams into Morgoth's Rear, convincing Ulfang to renege on his deal with Morgoth.

"Kicks back and laughs"

The Gate alternatively opens up in the Second Age on Numenor as Sauron in brought to it.

Or the Gate opens up at the Pelenor Fields just as Aragorn and Eomer have won the day and slam into their exhausted forces.

Or the fun, the shenanigans, and... Wait... Rory and Gandalf teaming up...

...
...

Ah, I'm not the Insurance Carrier for Arda and not responsible for the property damage.

Bonus points if any LotR crossover wrecks Amazon's little project's universe.

 

[Atarlost]

Doesn't Gate have little meddling gods? Crossing a setting like that over with LotR means putting them up against one of the really big fish. There aren't many genuine ex nihilo cosmic creators in fiction. Eru is one of them. And he cares about his creation, at least as an artist.

So any LotR crossover that gets near the cosmology has to answer the question of why Eru is letting some interlopers interrupt his grand opera.

Bonus points if any LotR crossover wrecks Amazon's little project's universe.

Amazon's shitty fanfiction already doesn't follow from the setting.

 

[ATP]

The Gate opens up on Arda (LOTR) First Age after The Nirnaeth Arnoediad commences and slams into Morgoth's Rear, convincing Ulfang to renege on his deal with Morgoth.

"Kicks back and laughs"

The Gate alternatively opens up in the Second Age on Numenor as Sauron in brought to it.

Or the Gate opens up at the Pelenor Fields just as Aragorn and Eomer have won the day and slam into their exhausted forces.

Or the fun, the shenanigans, and... Wait... Rory and Gandalf teaming up...

...
...

Ah, I'm not the Insurance Carrier for Arda and not responsible for the property damage.

What @Atarlost said - petty gods would meet real ONE.To be precise - our God before deluge.It would not end well for them.

 

[Agent23]

Amazon's shitty fanfiction already doesn't follow from the setting.

Ah, figures.
I'd still like to see that overpriced fanfic demolished.

Speaking of popular fantasy franchises, what do you all think of crossing Gate with The Witcher?
I have only seen a bit of the TV show, and I couldn't get into the game because the controls were kinda meh.
They have some pretty powerful magic which can probably offset some of the Saderans' advantage?

 

[ATP]

Ah, figures.
I'd still like to see that overpriced fanfic demolished.

Speaking of popular fantasy franchises, what do you all think of crossing Gate with The Witcher?
I have only seen a bit of the TV show, and I couldn't get into the game because the controls were kinda meh.
They have some pretty powerful magic which can probably offset some of the Saderans' advantage?

I only read books - but,unless Saderans,Witcher world mages was efficient on battlefield.

 

[Agent23]

I only read books - but,unless Saderans,Witcher world mages was efficient on battlefield.

Humm, maybe this warrants a Vs./What if thread of its own.

 

[Chiron]

Doesn't Gate have little meddling gods? Crossing a setting like that over with LotR means putting them up against one of the really big fish. There aren't many genuine ex nihilo cosmic creators in fiction. Eru is one of them. And he cares about his creation, at least as an artist.

So any LotR crossover that gets near the cosmology has to answer the question of why Eru is letting some interlopers interrupt his grand opera.


Amazon's shitty fanfiction already doesn't follow from the setting.

Aside from the Apostles, the Gate Gods have no dominion outside their world and can't go to Arda. But just think about it. Rory traveling with Gandalf who already has a bit of a dodgy reputation. Just imagine it.

 

[ATP]

Aside from the Apostles, the Gate Gods have no dominion outside their world and can't go to Arda. But just think about it. Rory traveling with Gandalf who already has a bit of a dodgy reputation. Just imagine it.

Tolkien was catholic,and created kind of catholic world - only before Deluge.Gandalf is angel of God here,so he do not use force to get his goals only becouse God command him to respect people Free Will.
But,when some apostles of petty gods come and try doing shit,he could use his full power.Which mean,that there would be nothing of Rory left if she picked fight.

 

[Agent23]

Tolkien was catholic,and created kind of catholic world - only before Deluge.Gandalf is angel of God here,so he do not use force to get his goals only becouse God command him to respect people Free Will.
But,when some apostles of petty gods come and try doing shit,he could use his full power.Which mean,that there would be nothing of Rory left if she picked fight.

I thought that his main idea was to create a replacement mythology for the British Isles because the Normans destroyed the records.
That would make it sort of pagan fanfiction.

 

[ATP]

I thought that his main idea was to create a replacement mythology for the British Isles because the Normans destroyed the records.
That would make it sort of pagan fanfiction.

No,becouse he was catholic.He do not included Aslan like figures,but his Eru is our God before Deluge,Abraham and going to Earth as Jesus.
But,it is still our world with our God and our morality.