Buffy the Vampire Slayer, a discussion thread and retrospective

Darmani

Well-known member
get the feeling Whedon was inserting a LOT of his own personal POV into the show.
No it's a marketing tactic. One that if you use one on one is called a grooming tactic

It's basically meant to create a divide between those who might have authority over you
Teens have a lack of supervision and abundance of responsibility with little power outside of reaction and so can promote and get involved in a project but if they know that they're not supposed to be doing it they're more than likely to Triple down as a form of identity and be more malleable to what is being sold.
To be fair another part of it is as a teenager you're much more aware of the b******* that goes on while being utterly powerless to it. As an adult people have to ostensibly respect you because at the very least you have the same level of social threat, unless they know that you are socially a run beneath.

Also let's not kid ourselves adults often are ignorant of the specifics and the difficulties of teen interaction especially as Society changes. the problem is there's a sort of funhouse mirror effect on Buffy. Such as how she talks about being disadvantaged and on the verge of poverty but she has a wardrobe that could probably feed a small nation
Some always hated the series just for having the seemingly microscopic Sarah Michelle Gellar be able to punch up guys. While I wouldn't call the Show out-and-out racist, it did not comport itself well on racial representation in the main show and in the spin-off... I kind of I suppose cringe is the wrong word, but I try not to think too hard about how they handled Gunn. all the more disgusting as they started treating the demons as minorities and an actual minority along with his group that have pre-existing ties were treated as a bunch of psychopaths. Not even a matter of the complex racial tensions that can happen amongst minorities in America, so much as out of control thrill killers
The social commentary got particularly bad. I think the best commentary on Buffy actually came in Venture Brothers, where we have three occult adventure/heroes. One who's a rip off of Doctor Strange. one who's like a sort of older blade. The last the guy who has the voice of Master Shake who's a gay Alchemist

Anyway at one point the Blacula Hunter talks about his origin story, which is how he saw his mother raped and murdered in front of him by a group of Blaculas and it explains so damn much about him. The setup of this scene is to dig deep into a dark tragedy in order so that they can open an event flag effectively. He says this and it's considered the Midway point and dismissed only for someone to go onto an elaborate bit about a personal relatively minor issue I think about them having a bad smell
this pretty much describes Buffy in a nutshell. trivializing very real social problems or tragedy in order to focus on then blow up the indignities of everyday life into full-blown insults and tragedies above set tragedies. On one level it's nice, because it humanizes and lets us know about the human condition. On the other level it's annoying because of what I just said
It's dishonestly presenting it as feminism that annoys me. It gets
I am convinced that when people talk feminism on Tumblr Twitter what they want is a group of male submissives into femme dom. And not the actual dynamics of you know the submissive is actually always in control and all that stuff I mean they basically want the jackass to do what they want and to be able to treat him like a garbage. Hence why Xander is problematic but Willow on Buffy absolutely are not or how if there was ever a fall with a female character find the nearest male character or actual writer and blame them
But getting back to the show....I think the best moments was when Buffy was still in HS, up to the end of Season 3
people always say this but I think it's just because it highlighted the problems since all the other status quo was gone and there was no inertia left. Cuz I would say the problem started with the overall Arc of Buffy returning and how they had to treat her and especially with works like gingerbread. In which the town becoming enlightened and concerned about the very real Horrors in it and Buffy getting a little bit of criticism on how she fights evil being treated as a personal offense and the results of Panic going out of control and everything. It's not that that's not a reasonable story, but it was all done in the service of justifying the characters and it completed the transformation of Witchcraft from a dark art to be used sparingly to borrowing the likeability of Wicca as a underground religion that was persecuted without even necessarily adopting or honoring its actual virtues values and traits
and yet it's 1998, and here they are using medieval weapon mockups
Buffy is a heroic character and so are the kids they're not meant to be gangsters having a bunch of kids working clandestine to kill people with guns would have made that my gang. They do show up in angel but they're also very explicitly shown to be dangerous and someone in effective against demons

do we call these kids were in high school and they were often dealing with hostage situations were the hostiles we're all together. But you have to give some shout out to the fact that they stole a rocket launcher but didn't think to still pistols but to be fair it's one of those more a liability things. You can easily justify having a crossbow as a sports weapon you can make the ammunition yourself in Shop class

they often hit the fact they have something as nasty as a knife let alone a sword or hammer
They had a tendency to favor incidental weapons that they hit on their person to attack all at once like staves up the sleeve or something like that. And also it's a matter of escalation as Darla proved

remember the average per Patrol needs to look not all that dangerous. She often encountered vampires while just hanging out at a bar or something like that.

technically the entire point of the initiative plot line is to decry the whole why don't they just use guns all the time
Also has to prove that those who don't follow those rules are always in the right even when they are evidently not, which is shown time and again in series.
I seriously prefer Angel here. Even though we had a corrupt power that be it was indicative that she herself was a rogue element and even then her corruption was more - I don't know you - could see how it was corruption and not never trust Authority folks. Hell A character like Holtz I don't think ever even had a chance on Buffy. And finally I think that show managed the right balance between Authority and power with Angel often being on the outs of the greater Supernatural Community because while they often played it off as a laugh he just as often Bumbled, did cause problems killing other good guys as well as making things harder for bad guys. And although this is framed in terms of the delusion of his romantic relationship with Buffy it's nice to see all that come to a head when he takes over Wolfram and Hart's and gets told to his face that the Slayer organization just cannot trust him
Thus leading to Connor, a brat kid
you know I never really thought of Connor as a brat. or if he was he was certainly more Justified and have more depth than say Dawn. Overall I just really liked the character and what he brought to the table. For one he was actually Angel's kid as to Dawn who was Buffy's daughter by way of Skipper (as in Barbie) like introduction. His central focus and emotional impact made sense as a result. Why so damn important, because macguffin and prophecy and memory alteration? No he's the child of Angel with a one night stand with his ex. I mean I fully accepted that he was screwed up but the show had reasons for being screwed up. I mean how does he deal with the fact that he was essentially brainwashed to hate his biological father; doesn't know what he is; and also attempted to murder his biological father who was also a monster in and of himself? After that he got groomed and then sexually abused! Then got his head screwed with by Jazmine in two forms.
overall, I mean I feel for the character, but I think that the show always manage to characterize him with depth without being too sympathetic to his f*** ups. As opposed to Spike where... oh haha isn't he just so lovable! hey did he kill a woman or something? oh who cares it's spike.
Xander is the awkward "loser guy" who evolves to be a capable fighter in his own right and while he doesn't have Buffy's power, he can still stand on his own two feet, we had glimpses of that here and there on the show
I think the problem with super Xander fics is that they focus on making him a powerful fighter and not just a good man. I think his ultimate goal should much as ended up as with Angel. to be a good adult man with a strong tie to his community, a sense of self Direction and purposem and not be defined by trying to sort of romantic male ideal so much as achieve it. Such as in season 7 when he's hitting on a girl in order to make himself feel better and dreams of the potentials coming onto him. That just feels so off especially as Nicholas Brendon wasn't passing for young guy anymore (not exactly moral objection just I mean surely Xander's taste in women have AGED with him right?)
they kind of had it sort of at the beginning of season 7 where he had moved to the head of the Construction Group. He had adult friends and ties and the beginnings of a career as well as influence in something like building the school.
In short he didn't have to be the loser guy trying to find himself. He had found himself and he had actually grown up. Even though that included things like leaving his fiancee at the altar.

"I need a marriage in order to make him a man." and considering there's just no ignoring the fact that he was in this entire fight for Buffy long after the point where he should have been over her by then ... him sort of leaving the life but not losing his awareness could be that final step. They sort of hit this at season 7 when the trio has Jonathan come to the realization that he's over High School. Xander was missing that when the development was there. He's an adult now and doesn't need to define himself by the highschool insecurities and developments.
 
Last edited:

Bear Ribs

Well-known member
And speaking of Slayer's equipment....can anyone explain to me the obscene lack of any modern firearms in the show? The proper and effective use of firearms with the right ammunition could be such a useful card, if not a game changer for Slayers and their Watchers....and yet it's 1998, and here they are using medieval weapon mockups. 😦
I don't know if it's the case in this specific instance, but often the answer to that is Network Censors, especially when they're allowed any weapon except a gun. I recall reading the memoirs of a person who worked on Planet of the Apes. The censors wouldn't let the apes have guns, because kids might get ahold of guns and it would cause somebody to get shot playing with them. But the directors successfully argued that kids wouldn't be likely to get ahold of heavier weapons, leading to the Apes having no pistols or rifles but copious amounts of artillery and explosives.

I don't know specifically that Buffy had the same issue, but the pattern of knives, pistols, and rifles being verboten while swords and rocket launchers (ie. weapons the audience can't get access to easily) are A-OK looks very much the same.

That does lead me to wonder about the lawmakers. The Hellmouth is in California isn't it? Could it be that their insane weapons bans are a result of vampires tinkering with the legislature to ensure that nobody has any decent weaponry?
 

Senor Hortler

Permanently Banned
Permanently Banned
I have also been recently rewatching Buffy; I actually still really enjoyed it even if the effects are goofy as hell. The makeup was good; and I like most of the characters.

One thing that did stand out to me as 'early season weirdness' is Xander. Xander was a pretty troubled and dark dude in the first two seasons. That was not something I really remembered.
 

Spartan303

In Captain America we Trust!
Administrator
Staff Member
Founder
Osaul
I have also been recently rewatching Buffy; I actually still really enjoyed it even if the effects are goofy as hell. The makeup was good; and I like most of the characters.

One thing that did stand out to me as 'early season weirdness' is Xander. Xander was a pretty troubled and dark dude in the first two seasons. That was not something I really remembered.


Buffy just has a certain Charm about it that I don't think can ever truly be recaptured. A show that had great writing, great characters and actors, great stories and was just perfect for its time. Few have that in this day and age.
 

Christi

Well-known member
I don't know if it's the case in this specific instance, but often the answer to that is Network Censors, especially when they're allowed any weapon except a gun. I recall reading the memoirs of a person who worked on Planet of the Apes. The censors wouldn't let the apes have guns, because kids might get ahold of guns and it would cause somebody to get shot playing with them. But the directors successfully argued that kids wouldn't be likely to get ahold of heavier weapons, leading to the Apes having no pistols or rifles but copious amounts of artillery and explosives.

I don't know specifically that Buffy had the same issue, but the pattern of knives, pistols, and rifles being verboten while swords and rocket launchers (ie. weapons the audience can't get access to easily) are A-OK looks very much the same.

That does lead me to wonder about the lawmakers. The Hellmouth is in California isn't it? Could it be that their insane weapons bans are a result of vampires tinkering with the legislature to ensure that nobody has any decent weaponry?
It actually made a lot of sense. If humans become aware. Then a lot of the demon problems disappears.
For instance Xander, Willow (before she went witchy), Cordy, Gunn and his gang were teenagers hunting vamps/demons and doing well.
I’m sorry, I don’t care what the show says. The military could do better if trained to handle the threats. Hell society could as well.
People would probably bathe in water supplies blessed by priests. Everyone would walk around with necklaces with crosses, the Star of David, etc.
No one would verbally invite people inside.
Magic would be studied in schools and used by the military/police.
Of course in that world the slayer would live longer. Because they would most likely have a train doctor on call, back up, be paid well, a team ( the fact the Council doesn’t send a witch, medic and Watcher team to back up the slayer is idiotic).
It’s better to keep people uninformed for the bad guys.
 

Ash's Boomstick

Well-known member
It actually made a lot of sense. If humans become aware. Then a lot of the demon problems disappears.
For instance Xander, Willow (before she went witchy), Cordy, Gunn and his gang were teenagers hunting vamps/demons and doing well.
I’m sorry, I don’t care what the show says. The military could do better if trained to handle the threats. Hell society could as well.
People would probably bathe in water supplies blessed by priests. Everyone would walk around with necklaces with crosses, the Star of David, etc.
No one would verbally invite people inside.
Magic would be studied in schools and used by the military/police.
Of course in that world the slayer would live longer. Because they would most likely have a train doctor on call, back up, be paid well, a team ( the fact the Council doesn’t send a witch, medic and Watcher team to back up the slayer is idiotic).
It’s better to keep people uninformed for the bad guys.

Maybe to an extent but the aftermath of any kind of worldwide disclosure would cause so much damage as to be untenable, people would be strung up just for seeming different, witchhunts to make Salem look like a police caution, people trying to 'save the demons' because they are 'misunderstood' and get killed in large numbers. People thinking they can take demons on and get slaughtered in the process because people are stupid, others trying to do what the initiative tried and try to control demons and other creatures.

As horrible as it is to say, keeping it in the shadows gets a few people killed in small numbers and almost as many demons are wiped out in the same time, going full disclosure will get far more people dead in the short term than every would in the long term. Hell the current global climate shows that people can't do what they are told or plan things out to keep themselves safe, how do you think they'd act against a sustained threat to the lives of the entire human race?

I will always go back to Agent K in Men in Black with his line "A person is smart. People are dumb, panicky dangerous animals and you know it."

Small military squads, specially trained groups might all work but large scale deployments and letting all of society know? Yeah not gonna happen if you want humanity to survive.
 

Ash's Boomstick

Well-known member
Its especially bad when you realise the worst of humanity is often worse than most of the demons we see, what if clinically sociopathic or psychopathic people managed to find a way to ascend or to control large groups or just torture people. Rich old people that want to live longer, or those wannabes will make faustian deals to gain more life, more money, more anything.

Humanity in general will do anything they can to improve their lot, while a number won't go near the dark arts or make deals there are a large number that will, due to desperation, anger, arrogance, greed or any number of reasons. People can not be trusted to know about the darker side of things simply because they are people.
 

Senor Hortler

Permanently Banned
Permanently Banned
I'm just imagining someone like Warren actually making it to the world off of the Hellmouth with a motivation beyond 'fuck around with my friends' and it's giving me the heeby jeebies. That man build a life like android, invisibility devices, mind control rays, time control devices, etc. All largely for the expressed purposes of just fucking with people. And he did it in his basement with two of his friends.

Hell, wasn't there an episode where the local college's top 'frat' was literally a demon worshiping cult that let them get into top positions within government? That's about the biggest perverse incentive possible. If 'all' you need to do to become a world leader is toss a few babies into the hellmouth and keep up a monthly payment of virgins then it's a hell of a lot cheaper than dropping a few million on running a campaign.
Might even lead to this:
 

Spartan303

In Captain America we Trust!
Administrator
Staff Member
Founder
Osaul
I'm just imagining someone like Warren actually making it to the world off of the Hellmouth with a motivation beyond 'fuck around with my friends' and it's giving me the heeby jeebies. That man build a life like android, invisibility devices, mind control rays, time control devices, etc. All largely for the expressed purposes of just fucking with people. And he did it in his basement with two of his friends.


If Warren had just let go of his freakin Ego he could have had it made! Each one of those technologies he developed had practical applications in the billions of dollars alone. Yet he couldn't get over the fact a mystically enhanced girl got the better of him. Dude, just take your loss, suck it up, go out and win at life. But no.....what an idiot.

And dude...that video...Had me rolling!
 

Senor Hortler

Permanently Banned
Permanently Banned
If Warren had just let go of his freakin Ego he could have had it made! Each one of those technologies he developed had practical applications in the billions of dollars alone. Yet he couldn't get over the fact a mystically enhanced girl got the better of him. Dude, just take your loss, suck it up, go out and win at life. But no.....what an idiot.
In fairness Warren had...issues with women. He was always a bit demented; but I think killing his girlfriend sent him rocketing off of the deep end into crazy town. All of the trio were some flavour of depressed, nihilistic and suicidal really.

And dude...that video...Had me rolling!
The Onion is comedy gold. Best one is where they teach a gorilla the concept of mortality.
 

Typhonis

Well-known member
Spartan, could you PM me about the rumors surrounding Charisma? I'm a bit curious about what happened.


Also what the hell happened in Season 3? Was it ever explained why Xander played tonsil hockey with Willow? Also why everyone seemed to blame him for the mess and not include Willow?
 

Spartan303

In Captain America we Trust!
Administrator
Staff Member
Founder
Osaul
Spartan, could you PM me about the rumors surrounding Charisma? I'm a bit curious about what happened.


Also what the hell happened in Season 3? Was it ever explained why Xander played tonsil hockey with Willow? Also why everyone seemed to blame him for the mess and not include Willow?


The thing with Willow was a writing decision apparently. The original plan was for Anya to leave the show and meet up with Angel in Los Angeles and working with Doyle the three would be 'reformed' demons trying to do good in the world, working towards redemption. But something happened and Charimsa ended up leaving Buffy and going to Angel and so the writers had to break them up. Rather than just have the two break up amicably like anyone else would they instead opted for the whole fluke thing.

But the original plan for Cordelia and Xander would have had them remain a couple all the way up to season 6. So all the dialogue that they wrote for Anya? It was originally Cordelias, they just swapped out the characters and had Anya perky and Naive where as Cordelia would have been sarcastic and a bit teasing.
 

Tiamat

I've seen the future...
Hell that would have been better. Would also mean Joss wouldn't have to write around the pregnancy. They are living together...it would have been a nice upboost for the series.

Indeed it would have, though I admittedly wouldn’t have minded a Xander/Willow pairing, personally.

Then again, this is BTVS. Call me cynical, but they never seemed to show any happy, stable relationships. Doesn’t make for good tv apparently...
 

Tiamat

I've seen the future...
Xander is the reason Willow is a Lesbian.

Was it? I thought it was Oz. Was never particularly a fan of the character, though he wasn’t terrible either and Seth Green can be pretty damn hilarious.

Honestly, I felt Willow getting turned into a lesbian felt out of left field and rather forced. If she’d turned bisexual like her evil leather-clad alter-ego had in that one episode “The Wish”, it would’ve made more sense...and would have led to some rather interesting situations. A Xander/Willow/Faith troika, anyone...?
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top