Alternate History Ideas and Discussion

Buba

A total creep
Succesful Lithuania state without union with Poland.If they beat Moscov,they could take Siberia later.
Although Divine Wind saves Japan from Lithuanian invasion.
The fearsome shaggy pony riding and sheepskin coat wearing warriors have to contend with Hokkaido only - where they invent roast squid with milk cream. Everything tastes better with milk cream!
 

WolfBear

Well-known member
Yes, they share a long border.

@Buba You can see for yourself here:

Map_of_Central_Asia.png
 

WolfBear

Well-known member
Thanks. I reversed Tajikisitan and Kirgistan in my mind.

Yeah, Tajikistan is the one with the Afghan border. Tajiks, like Afghans, are an Iranian people. Kyrgyz, like Kazakhs, are a Turkic people--and very closely related to Kazakhs, for that matter!

Anyway, how do we make my AHC happen? FWIW, Kazakhstan is currently much richer than Kyrgyzstan is.
 

Buba

A total creep
Anyway, how do we make my AHC happen? FWIW, Kazakhstan is currently much richer than Kyrgyzstan is.
Sorry, beyond my ken.
All I know about the area that Uzbeks, Kirgiz, Kazakhs, Karakalpaks - all these and more were in large measure created by the Soviets in the 1920s.
So, simplest, although I suspect not what you were going for, is for Lenin or Stalin draw the borders differently and not spin Kirgistan off Soviet Turkestan.

As not to double post, here is a map for you @WolfBear
220px-SovietCentralAsia1922.svg.png
 
Last edited:

WolfBear

Well-known member
Sorry, beyond my ken.
All I know about the area that Uzbeks, Kirgiz, Kazakhs, Karakalpaks - all these and more were in large measure created by the Soviets in the 1920s.
So, simplest, although I suspect not what you were going for, is for Lenin or Stalin draw the borders differently and not spin Kirgistan off Soviet Turkestan.

As not to double post, here is a map for you @WolfBear
220px-SovietCentralAsia1922.svg.png

Weirdly enough, the territory that was known as Kirgizstan back then is actually present-day Kazakhstan. Present-day Kyrgyzstan is actually located to the southeast of the Kirgizstan on the map above.
 

TheRomanSlayer

Unipolarists are the New Subhumans
"Plausibility Check: American Civil War Ends in a Korea-like Stalemate"

Basically, have both the conflict between the Union and the Confederacy end in a stalemate, similar to the end of OTL Korean War, but both parties don't recognize the sovereignty of one another.
 

WolfBear

Well-known member
"Plausibility Check: American Civil War Ends in a Korea-like Stalemate"

Basically, have both the conflict between the Union and the Confederacy end in a stalemate, similar to the end of OTL Korean War, but both parties don't recognize the sovereignty of one another.

There's a possibility of this is McClellan wins in 1864. AFAIK, he wanted to get the South to join the Union while protecting their right to keep slavery. But what if huge Northern opposition to this plan of his will block it? Then would Northerners actually be willing to fight the South up to the bitter end?

'PC (Plausibility Check): An eventual partition of the Ottoman Empire even without World War I?'
 

Doomsought

Well-known member
What about getting partitioned between the various European Great Powers?
Backroom dealings for funding the civil war with the princes going to different great powers for support. The promises that the princes make to get support vary, though the Suez Canal features prominently.
 

TheRomanSlayer

Unipolarists are the New Subhumans
There's a possibility of this is McClellan wins in 1864. AFAIK, he wanted to get the South to join the Union while protecting their right to keep slavery. But what if huge Northern opposition to this plan of his will block it? Then would Northerners actually be willing to fight the South up to the bitter end?
I'm wondering if a McClellan victory in 1864 would have been spoiled by a more militant abolitionist faction that would spoil the South's chance of rejoining the Union with the institution of slavery.
 

TheRomanSlayer

Unipolarists are the New Subhumans
The only thing is, how would Lincoln realistically lose the 1864 election when the successes of the Union Armies are contributing to his popularity?

---

"PC: World Hockey Association Becomes the Dominant hockey league instead of the NHL."

How do you get the WHA to not only survive, but absorb the teams from the NHL, instead of the other way around?
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top