Rejectionist Alternate History Idea Novel

TheRejectionist

TheRejectionist
So at I am impasse because thanks my linguistic exam , it took me a year to pass it, four attempts to pass it before the fifth was the one I wrestled a 24/30* after I took 540,89 dollars tutoring (2 tutors actually) just to pass the barring process of this exam and having someone explain me many concepts in human, non-theoritical terms, I completely forgot to fill up the 1956-1960 timespan and went directly to 1960s period so far... I think I might have written it and just forgot where I saved it.

@Circle of Willis @raharris1973 @Tiamat @Sergeant Foley @49ersfootball @BlackDragon98 @Sārthākā @LordSunhawk
@Sailor.X

tagging seeing your threads on the subforum; any suggestions for what, where and so on I should look for points of divergence between1956-1960? This was my last update on Stassenite America and the Soviet Union.

@Circle of Willis @ATP

EISENHOWER-STASSEN PRESIDENCIES (1949 -1965)




If WWII was won with British intelligence, American steel and Russian blood, the empires of yore would be kept intact until the first biennium of the Eighties thanks to American intelligence and money and German blood and sweat.



Eisenhower and Stassen had inherited a delicate situation with the Truman administration. Helping Chiang Kai Shek had avoided a domino effect which could have spilled over into neighboring French Indochina, Thailand and Ba Maw’s State of Burma, but the British loss of India proved to be a difficult challenge, almost compromising London’s empire, but unlike his predecessor, Ike was less for self-determination, as demonstrated his acceptance of Ethiopia’s annexation of Italian Somalia and Eritrea; Americo-Indian relations were strained to say the least and while the United States had normalized relations with Bhose just as they had done with Sukarno, the membership of Portugal and France which guaranteed no further territorial concessions or modification, meaning their overseas exclaves were also guaranteed protection and soon Bhutan, Nepal and Afghanistan (which was enlisted by the British against Bhose and got compensated with Sind, Balochistan, Indian Pashtunistan, but failed to take Punjab) were safeguarded against Free India’s potential aggressions; following the resolution of the Chinese Civil War, the administration had another headache but more close to home : the Puerto Rican Revolt ; the unincorporated territory had exploded in anger after decades of occupation and the Puerto Rican Nationalist Party had taken advantage of the absence of the overwhelming majority of the National Guard that was yet to return from China and easily took over the island, demanding justice and freedom and Ike was undecided on how to properly react and before anyone could suggest a military intervention or a similar move Stassen argued to work out a deal with the PRNP , proposing to Puerto Rican inhabitants the choice of a referendum in which they could choose to be incorporated into the Union as a new state or indepedence but this last option would have also the obligation of Puerto Rico joining not only the Organization of American States but the PACCATO alliance as well.

Unsurprisingly with the PRNP control, most of their compatriots voted to be independent despite the catch of having to still be aligned with the United States even though de facto Puerto Rico wouldn’t even try to contribute anything significant during the Lukewarm War, but Eisenhower and Stassen had saved face for the time being. Their attention soon turned to the Philippines and British Malaya : both had to be dealt with quickly to show that Communism wouldn’t be tolerated ; so the United States Armed Forces in China were sent to those lands and brutally suppressed both rebellions with total media silence and by February 1951 both Communist Party of Malaya (CPM) and the Partido Komunista ng Pilipinas-1930 were nearly extinct and no longer a preoccupation for the Eisenhower administration, who by then had its attention returned its attention to Japan once more, Treaty of Peace with Japan in San Francisco being signed the 8th September 1951, with Eisenhower bitterly agreeing to it despite they had to recognize Soviet authority and claims over South Sakhalin and the Kuril Islands while at the same time renouncing any idea of military bases in Japan.

It wasn’t long before another foreign issue came to Washington's attention, this time in Africa with the Mau Mau Uprising of the next year, with the administration reacting the same way they had done in British Malaya and the Philippines : with efficient brutality while supported by the “Germans of the French Foreign Legions”, former Wehrmacht and Waffen-SS personnel that now were footsoldiers, drill sergeants and other jobs in the French Colonial Empire.

It wasn’t all of a success for Ike however : the Central Intelligence Agency attempted regime changes in Egypt, Iran, Costa Rica, Guatemala and Paraguay had failed and it was clear as day that Washington D.C. wouldn’t always get its way; if that wasn’t enough, in 1955 the Buraimi dispute turned into a war between the US-friendly Saudia Arabia and PACCATO member United Kingdom, with the peace treaty granting the Aden Protectorate the previously lost by Yemen regions of Asir, Qunfudah,Al Bahah, Jizan and Najran, meanwhile the Trucial states got a land connection with Kuwait who would also get its claims validated and recognized; recently available documents clearly show that the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia was the aggressor, but the threats made Saud bin Abdulaziz Al Saud regarding petrol had an effect of galvanizing the VP to promote energetic self sufficiency and started a program for using the power of the atom to achieve such goal.

In the last two months of the year it became evident of the instability of the French Republic, or so it seemed according to badly researched investigations and intelligence reports, probably exacerbated by the more often than not independent-minded French political class.

Stassen had to be convinced strongly it was utterly necessary to do something about the French Republic, especially because he had seen the miserable spectacles that were their past tries at interventions, rightfully pointing out their (reluctant) “allies” Spain and Portugal, who were also “recipients” of German veterans and American money, refused the help of their intelligence due to the pathetic failures that were the attempted topplings of King Farouk, Mossadegh and Arbenz which made the two Iberian autocracies realize that the Americans were incompetent in regard with espionage and counter-intelligence and had to be on their own.


Eisenhower was clear:


<< Unlike the Italians, where the far opposite sides of the political spectrum had found quid pro quos with the center, the French socio-political situation is volatile. >>


The Vice-President had unfortunately already used his political capital with Ike in persuading him to reply to Emmet Till’s mother's letter, a move that could have very well compromised his chance to become President.


<<I don’t want to put in charge people who shot our boys in France who sided with Hitler rather than their own countrymen >>


Eisenhower did agree with the sentiment and when Operation Gaul was enacted in the latter half of January 1956 the a rag-tag of military personnel of former Free French, whose first target after the government was none other than the man that had been their leader in wartime : De Gaulle. It is unclear how the Marshall of Free France met his untimely demise, but if reports from the Direction générale de la sécurité intérieure archives are not taken as pure speculation, he was tied, blindfolded and shot in the head, subsequently buried in the first pit found and many met an identical fate such as Minister of the Overseas François Mitterrand.

The Central Intelligence Agency and the “National Security Government” would give the same treatment to the opposite ends of the political spectrum : the Socialists lost Vincent Auriol, Daniel Mayer Guy Mollet and of the Communists only Waldeck Rochet didn’t meet the firing squad like Thorez, meanwhile former Axis collaborators like Jean-Louis Tixier-Vignancour either fled or got shot in the streets and the only surviving member of the French Action party was Georges-Paul Wagner unlike Pierre Boutang and others who would meet the guillotine in an almost tragi-comical repeat of history.

the “mois de silence” would be seen as a Robespierre-an and Stalin-esque show trials and purges but barely reported anywhere in the supposedly free world. Anyone who the government thought could potentially threaten the stability of the French Republic and her overseas territories was either on the government hit list or had been on the literal or metaphorical chopping block.

The new “French State” would serve the interests of PACCATO no matter who was in charge and effectively, with the exception of the nuclear program, the military governments of the “Période directoriale américaniste” were the Parisian puppet-like extensions of Washington D.C.


A first major (although diplomatic) victory against Moscow came with the 1956 Poznań protests, where a hundred thousands Polish protesters clashed against the Polish People's Army, Internal Security Corps and Służba Bezpieczeństwa, all commanded by none other than Anatol Fejgin on orders of Ministers of Internal Affairs of People's Republic of Poland Salomon Morel, former commander of the Zgoda labour camp and Jaworzno concentration camps, with him treating the protesters as “enemy insurgents and combatants” and the result was near chaos : over thirty-thousands protesters dead and nearly seven thousands wounded, but the government forces suffered eight-thousand dead and three hundred and half wounded, the consequences of this violent response was a full blown revolution due to word of mouth that grew so much that many Soviet and Polish military barracks got overpowered by massive waves of angry mobs, but the stroke that broke the camel's back was the execution of non-tenured professor of Catholic University of Lublin Karol Józef Wojtyła.


Soon, banners could be seen everywhere with written :


NIGDY WIĘCEJ! (NEVER AGAIN!)


PAMIĘTAJ WOJTYŁA! (REMEMBER WOJTYLA!)


Mikoyan was, understandably, livid. And panicking at the same time. Many wanted to invade to restore order, especially Molotov’s faction, but allegedly Zhukov had enough sway to convince Anastas that such action would compromise the public image of the Soviet Union.

Swallowing his pride, when Stassen proposed the USSR a neutral Poland, he accepted, but the Withdrawal Treaty that came with it had a couple of written clauses in which the Central European nation could not join any alliance and couldn’t ban the Polish United Workers' Party. The barely organized Polish revolutionary leadership, despite expressing enourmous outrage, accepted. As the last of Soviet soldiers and People’s Army withdrew, the Polish government-in-exile quickly flew and returned to Poland to organize the first (actually free) election of Poland in decades, with victory awarded to Tadeusz Bielecki with the promise of “NEVER AGAIN!”.


A transcript of a recording between an operative and Mikoyan reports the following :


From Nikolay [REDACTED]


“Chairman of the Council of Ministers of the Soviet Union Anastas Ivanovich Mikoyan, we lost Poland due to the brutal brainless machinations of Fejgin and Morel and I had told my superior that both were liabilities to the cause of the Communist International. Morel used methods which could only be described as butchery, I don’t think even the Fascists me and my comrades fought in the Great Patriotic War would go so low as them. It is no surprise that the Polish workers reacted as they did by defenestrating and impaling Fejgin and tearing apart Salomon.


I would advise a cautious approach from now on.”



As if a heart attack that hit Eisenhower in 1955 had not been enough, he and Stassen had to deal with the Civil Rights Movement, with the American Vice President strongly lobbying for much integration efforts, publicly declaring support for the U.S. Supreme Court decisions in Sweatt v. Painter (1950) McLaurin v. Oklahoma State Regents (1950) and Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka (1954), and pushed the general turned President to reply to Emmet Till’s mother’s letter, with Ike remarking later in life that Stassen was too much vocal and too partisan for being a second-in-command, expressing that he was surprised that they were both elected for two consecutive terms when “ everything Stassen did or said had the potential to compromise my presidency and his political future… I honestly don’t know what shocked me more, that he managed to win the primaries both times or that he won the elections in 1956 and 1960”.

They also had to constantly deal with the increasing Red Scare and McCarthyism, who “had the decency of dying of alcohol poisoning” shortly after the beginning of the Sputnik Crisis in December 1956.

When he was inaugurated, Stassen first priority was to understand why the Tech Gap was happening and set the Central Intelligence Agency to find out answers : with many operators of the bureau, it was discovered that the Soviets shortly before “liberating” Norway, the Low Countries and Germany had initiated Operation Osoaviakhim which wielded enormous results for the Soviet Union, not only as a bittersweet recompense but also to attempt to close the military gap Moscow had, with the hundreds of former Nazis experts helping Mikoyan’s Comintern to surpass the Americans in those fields in that period of time, later becoming the reason for legitimising and kickstarting the Comintern cybernetics camp.

Sergei Pavlovich Korolev couldn’t ask for better help in his projects than the Third Reich’s former employees, a sentiment shared by many of his colleagues and affiliates such as the mathematician Mstislav Keldysh and Igor Kurchatov, the latter bittersweetly remarking “We wouldn’t had the power of the atom so quickly if we hadn’t spilled so much blood to conquer Germany”.

The list the CIA recovered was enourmous :

Aeronautics and rocketry


Eugen Sänger

Hans Amtmann

Herbert Axster

Erich Ball

Oscar Bauschinger

Hermann Beduerftig

Rudi Beichel

Anton Beier

Herbert Bergeler

Magnus von Braun

Wernher von Braun

Ernst Czerlinsky

Theodor Buchhold

Walter Burose

Adolf Busemann

GN Constan

Werner Dahm

Konrad Dannenberg

Kurt H. Debus

Gerd De Beek

Walter Dornberger - head of rocket programme

Gerhard Drawe

Friedrich Duerr

Ernst R. G. Eckert

Rudolph Edse

Otto Eisenhardt

Krafft Arnold Ehricke

Alfred Finzel

Edward Fischel

Karl Fleischer

Anton Flettner

Anselm Franz

Herbert Fuhrmann

Ernst Geissler

Werner Gengelbach

Dieter Grau

Hans Gruene

Herbert Guendel

Fritz Haber

Heinz Haber

Karl Hager

Guenther Haukohl

Karl Heimburg

Emil Hellebrand

Gerhard B. Heller

Bruno Helm

Rudolf Hermann

Bruno Heusinger

Hans Heuter

Guenther Hintze

Sighard F. Hoerner

Kurt Hohenemser

Oscar Holderer

Helmut Horn

Hans Henning Hosenthien

Dieter Huzel

Walter Jacobi

Erich Kaschig

Ernst Klauss

Theodore Knacke

Siegfried Knemeyer

Heinz-Hermann Koelle

Gustav Kroll

Willi Kuberg

Werner Kuers

Hermann Kurzweg

Hermann Lange

Hans Lindenberg

Hans Lindenmayer

Alexander Martin Lippisch

Robert Lusser

Hans Maus

Helmut Merk

Joseph Michel

Hans Milde

Heinz Millinger

Rudolf Minning

William Mrazek

Hans Multhopp

Erich Neubert

Hans von Ohain

Robert Paetz

Hans Palaoro

Kurt Patt

Hans Paul

Fritz Pauli

Arnold Peter

Helmuth Pfaff

Theodor Poppel

Werner Rosinski

Heinrich Rothe

Ludwig Roth

Arthur Rudolph

Friedrich von Saurma

Edgar Schaeffer

Martin Schilling

Helmut Schlitt[

Albert Schuler

August Schulze

Walter Schwidetzky

Ernst Steinhoff

Wolfgang Steurer

Heinrich Struck

Ernst Stuhlinger

Bernhard Tessmann

Adolf Thiel

Georg von Tiesenhausen

Werner Tiller

JG Tschinkel

Arthur Urbanski

Fritz Vandersee

Richard Vogt

Werner Voss

Theodor Vowe

Herbert A. Wagner

Hermann Rudolf Wagner

Hermann Weidner

Georg Rickhey - director of the slave labour Mittelwerk factory

Walter Fritz Wiesemann

Philipp Wolfgang Zettler-Seidel



Architecture


Heinz Hilten and Hannes Luehrsen.


Electronics - including guidance systems, radar and satellites


Wilhelm Angele

Ernst Baars

Josef Boehm

Hans Fichtner

Hans Friedrich

Eduard Gerber

Georg Goubau

Walter Haeussermann

Otto Heinrich Hirschler

Otto Hoberg[

Rudolf Hoelker

Hans Hollmann

Helmut Hölzer

Horst Kedesdy

Kurt Lehovec

Kurt Lindner

JW Muehlner

Fritz Mueller

Johannes Plendl

Fritz Karl Preikschat

Eberhard Rees

Gerhard Reisig

Harry Ruppe

Heinz Schlicke

Werner Sieber[

Hans K. Ziegler

Material Science (high temperature)

Klaus Scheufelen


Medicine . biological weapons, chemical weapons, and space medicine


Theodor Benzinger, Rudolf Brill, Konrad Johannes Karl Büttner, Fritz Laves, Richard Lindenberg, Ulrich Cameron Luft, Walter Schreiber, Hubertus Strughold, Hans Georg Clamann, and Erich Traub.


Nuclear Program



Heinz Barwich

Ludwig Bewilogua

Erich Bagge

Carl Friedrich von Weizsäcker

Max von Laue

Karl Wirtz

Karl-Hermann Geib

Peter Adolf Thiessen

Justus Mühlenpfordt

Nikolaus Riehl


Physics


Gunter Guttein,

Manfred von Ardenne

Gustav Ludwig Hertz

Gerhard Schwesinger

Gottfried Wehner

Helmut Weickmann and Friedwardt Winterberg.

Chemistry and Chemical engineering

Helmut Pichler

Leonard Alberts

Ernst Donath

Josef Guymer

Hans Schappert

Max Josenhaus

Kurt Bretschneider

Erich Frese

@ATP @Batrix2070 if you have any suggestion on what Poland and the rest of Central Europe? I am not sure I am going to do it besides maybe said countries allowing Radio Free Europe to be established in their soil. Not because I don't want but besides Poland having nukes the rest of 34 years of history or more would be a pain to elaborate even with sources.

A much more less messy version of the timeline I am working is here secretprojects.co.uk/threads/roter-rhein-krasnyy-reyn-what-if-the-axis-members-called-it-quits-in-early-1943.39475/

*Exams' grades in the Italian university system go from 0 to 30, but you are not gonna pass if your professor think you achieved less than 18 and unlike the Portuguese university system you cannot integrate or upgrade your grade in any way (like additional work) but just straight up repeat it to the next exam date.
 

Tiamat

I've seen the future...
So at I am impasse because thanks my linguistic exam , it took me a year to pass it, four attempts to pass it before the fifth was the one I wrestled a 24/30* after I took 540,89 dollars tutoring (2 tutors actually) just to pass the barring process of this exam and having someone explain me many concepts in human, non-theoritical terms, I completely forgot to fill up the 1956-1960 timespan and went directly to 1960s period so far... I think I might have written it and just forgot where I saved it.

@Circle of Willis @raharris1973 @Tiamat @Sergeant Foley @49ersfootball @BlackDragon98 @Sārthākā @LordSunhawk
@Sailor.X

tagging seeing your threads on the subforum; any suggestions for what, where and so on I should look for points of divergence between1956-1960? This was my last update on Stassenite America and the Soviet Union.

Tough to say. I would ask, within that timeframe, what interests YOU?
 

ATP

Well-known member
So at I am impasse because thanks my linguistic exam , it took me a year to pass it, four attempts to pass it before the fifth was the one I wrestled a 24/30* after I took 540,89 dollars tutoring (2 tutors actually) just to pass the barring process of this exam and having someone explain me many concepts in human, non-theoritical terms, I completely forgot to fill up the 1956-1960 timespan and went directly to 1960s period so far... I think I might have written it and just forgot where I saved it.

@Circle of Willis @raharris1973 @Tiamat @Sergeant Foley @49ersfootball @BlackDragon98 @Sārthākā @LordSunhawk
@Sailor.X

tagging seeing your threads on the subforum; any suggestions for what, where and so on I should look for points of divergence between1956-1960? This was my last update on Stassenite America and the Soviet Union.



@ATP @Batrix2070 if you have any suggestion on what Poland and the rest of Central Europe? I am not sure I am going to do it besides maybe said countries allowing Radio Free Europe to be established in their soil. Not because I don't want but besides Poland having nukes the rest of 34 years of history or more would be a pain to elaborate even with sources.

A much more less messy version of the timeline I am working is here secretprojects.co.uk/threads/roter-rhein-krasnyy-reyn-what-if-the-axis-members-called-it-quits-in-early-1943.39475/

*Exams' grades in the Italian university system go from 0 to 30, but you are not gonna pass if your professor think you achieved less than 18 and unlike the Portuguese university system you cannot integrate or upgrade your grade in any way (like additional work) but just straight up repeat it to the next exam date.

Independent Poland who could not join NATO,but have free elections - they do not need to ban soviet party,in 1956 nobody except jews,progressive inteligencia and cryminals supported it.

They would probably show massgraves,and hang all cryminals - after that soviet party would have 1-2% support.

What they would do? free market,but with worker laws.And,computers.We had forst real microcomputer K202 in OTL after all.
Military - they would probably produce swedish fighters ,and swiss tanks.Or maybe swedish,too.

Only impossible thing - CIA making succesfull putch in France.Idiots in OTL could not remove Castro,and here they taken out De Gaulle? bullshit.
 

TheRejectionist

TheRejectionist
Tough to say. I would ask, within that timeframe, what interests YOU?

The following :

  1. The latest tech which the United States would sell to this Latin American partners (like jet planes, tanks and so on) both developed OTL and those who never saw the light of day
  2. Tech devolpment in the Soviet Union.

Independent Poland who could not join NATO,but have free elections - they do not need to ban soviet party,in 1956 nobody except jews,progressive inteligencia and cryminals supported it.

They would probably show massgraves,and hang all cryminals - after that soviet party would have 1-2% support.

What they would do? free market,but with worker laws.And,computers.We had forst real microcomputer K202 in OTL after all.
Military - they would probably produce swedish fighters ,and swiss tanks.Or maybe swedish,too.

Only impossible thing - CIA making succesfull putch in France.Idiots in OTL could not remove Castro,and here they taken out De Gaulle? bullshit.

@ATP De Gaulle had SEVERAL attempts against his life (granted, a few were by his own countryman and not as many as Castro) but the Americans probably had an intelligence presence as early as they landed in 1944...and they were in a continent. Castro on the other hand had the advantage of being in a island, so catching conspirators it was much more easier.
 

Batrix2070

RON/PLC was a wonderful country.
if you have any suggestion on what Poland and the rest of Central Europe? I am not sure I am going to do it besides maybe said countries allowing Radio Free Europe to be established in their soil. Not because I don't want but besides Poland having nukes the rest of 34 years of history or more would be a pain to elaborate even with sources.
Well, I can fill in something there myself, but I would have to get a more strictly defined framework so that I would know what I can and cannot do.

As for suggestions, mainly in Poland

1. militarization, total militarization. The army itself should be about 400k soldiers. A sizable air force, and a fleet sufficient to carve out a passage to the Danish Straits and close the USSR Baltic Fleet in the ports.

2 Reprivatization, any seized property whose owners are alive goes back to them. For example, the Polish candy company E.Wendel, the pre-war owner Jan Wendel is still alive, he died only in 1960 in Warsaw, he will surely strive to get his company back. BTW they make very good candy.
Reclaiming estates by the landed gentry (here you can do it with the help of Karol Stefan Hasburg, the last private owner of Zywiec Polish brewery as well as the Zywiec estates i.e. agricultural property), unless the owners were murdered then sell directly to peasants. Liquidation of PGRs (State Farms, the equivalent of Kolkhozes) and distribution of land to peasants or former owners (Though surely some of them are in fact peasants).

3. development based on the Polish middle class, promoting Polish culture and language. Creating historical propaganda films immortalizing Polish victories over both Germans (like OTL) and Russians. Attempting to assimilate Poland's remaining national minorities. Certainly, the nationalists will seek to destroy Pilsudski by making him as insignificant as possible, even if it means lying about him.

4 A state program of re-emigration, Free Poland will seek to bring back all the forced emigrants after World War II, including the generals of the Polish Armed Forces in the West, giving them due honor. BTW Bear Wojtek also counts as a Corporal in the Polish Army.

5. balanced and cold relations with former allies and occupiers. Nationalists are more politically realistic, or at least they consider themselves so. They will maintain relations with the West, but there will be no greater love in this. Certainly, the British and French will be treated firmly in the background. The Americans more positively but without much warmth, but certainly Polish intelligence will be strongly paranoid about any foreign influence including the US.

6. And the all-encompassing Polish intelligence and counterintelligence will be ready to do whatever is necessary to keep any superpower away from Poland as well as to influence it. The mysterious disappearances of students proposing more progressive ideas should be obvious.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ATP

TheRejectionist

TheRejectionist
Well, I can fill in something there myself, but I would have to get a more strictly defined framework so that I would know what I can and cannot do.

As for suggestions, mainly in Poland

1. militarization, total militarization. The army itself should be about 400k soldiers. A sizable air force, and a fleet sufficient to carve out a passage to the Danish Straits and close the USSR Baltic Fleet in the ports.

2 Reprivatization, any seized property whose owners are alive goes back to them. For example, the Polish candy company E.Wendel, the pre-war owner Jan Wendel is still alive, he died only in 1960 in Warsaw, he will surely strive to get his company back. BTW they make very good candy.
Reclaiming estates by the landed gentry (here you can do it with the help of Karol Stefan Hasburg, the last private owner of Zywiec Polish brewery as well as the Zywiec estates i.e. agricultural property), unless the owners were murdered then sell directly to peasants. Liquidation of PGRs (State Farms, the equivalent of Kolkhozes) and distribution of land to peasants or former owners (Though surely some of them are in fact peasants).

3. development based on the Polish middle class, promoting Polish culture and language. Creating historical propaganda films immortalizing Polish victories over both Germans (like OTL) and Russians. Attempting to assimilate Poland's remaining national minorities. Certainly, the nationalists will seek to destroy Pilsudski by making him as insignificant as possible, even if it means lying about him.

4 A state program of re-emigration, Free Poland will seek to bring back all the forced emigrants after World War II, including the generals of the Polish Armed Forces in the West, giving them due honor. BTW Bear Wojtek also counts as a Corporal in the Polish Army.

5. balanced and cold relations with former allies and occupiers. Nationalists are more politically realistic, or at least they consider themselves so. They will maintain relations with the West, but there will be no greater love in this. Certainly, the British and French will be treated firmly in the background. The Americans more positively but without much warmth, but certainly Polish intelligence will be strongly paranoid about any foreign influence including the US.

6. And the all-encompassing Polish intelligence and counterintelligence will be ready to do whatever is necessary to keep any superpower away from Poland as well as to influence it. The mysterious disappearances of students proposing more progressive ideas should be obvious.

  1. Why only 400k of the Army and not 1 million or more ? I see it as plausible for the army, also for the air-force BUT the Navy is still an issue. The Soviets have liberated everything up Norway and the Benelux (with the exclusion of OTL Denmark, Czechoslovakia, Hungary and Balkans) so except to the South, this new Poland is surrounded in the East and West, not to mention that it might not be of help a Navy since Norway IS a communist satellite of the Soviet Union. BUT... I could see a fortress Poland just like Switzerland WAS during WW2, just multiplied by 10.
  2. This would be interesting.
  3. Why any sane nationalist would DESTROY Pilsudksi? Far as I know he is like Dom Pedro II and Vargas are to Brazilians and Ataturk to Turks and Garibaldi to Italians? On moviemaking patriotic reels...against Germans I can see it is doable. But until Communism falls I don't see it politically doable for the Russians, although it could be circumvented with said movies being made outside of Poland, with non-Polish or Polish-Anglophone actors and distributed by other companies.
  4. Yeah that would make sense.
  5. As above.
  6. As above. I don't get this phrase though : The mysterious disappearances of students proposing more progressive ideas should be obvious.
 

TheRejectionist

TheRejectionist
On a sidenote to satisfy my curiosity @Batrix2070 and @ATP according to historically aware Poles and not, and the general population , what is/could be considered worst today : the puppetization of Poland by the USSR and Stalin or the WAllies abandoment of Poland to the USSR which then resulted in its puppetization ?
 

Batrix2070

RON/PLC was a wonderful country.
Why any sane nationalist would DESTROY Pilsudksi?
For the Nationalists and the Pilsudskis hate each other. These are two major political groups that have attacked each other since independence. A good example is the Battle of Warsaw in 1920, Pilsudski and his people believe that it was thanks to Pilsudski that the battle was won. (Which is true, although they focus exclusively on Pilsudski). Whereas the nationalists right after the battle immediately started saying that it was not him, but someone else.
And it was Maxime Weygand, a French general with a military mission in Poland, who immediately denied that he had any part in the victory. And it was the Mother of God, hence the name of the battle Miracle on the Vistula, and it was Rozwadowski (which is also true, but like the opposite side, they focus too much on him).

And now we have a free Poland ruled by nationalists who "liberated" the country after it was "lost" by the Sanacja (Pilsudski).

What is there to say, there is no shortage of nationalists to this day accusing the Marshal for principle.

Why only 400k of the Army
Because that's how much PRL(Communist Poland) OTL maintained and as it turned out it wasn't cheap at all. A million-strong army was formed from it after mobilization.
The mysterious disappearances of students proposing more progressive ideas should be obvious.
I refer to the fact that the Polish counterintelligence in such a situation, will bluntly, physically get rid of politically inconvenient people. Seeing in them agents of the enemy. Hardly moral, but in this situation that this Free Poland is, it is difficult to keep your hands clean. Given that for the past two decades Poland has been de facto raped, it is difficult to expect slackness or any forbearance with such ideas.

not to mention that it might not be of help a Navy
Maintaining communications with the world, this Poland is surrounded by enemies. Even despite being a fortress like Switzerland with a nuclear, it is not self-sufficient. In the event of war, it is better to have a navy to import the necessary resources, which will not be difficult because the Poles could see (during WWII) how pathetic the Red Fleet is in action. It does not mean that they will rest on their laurels.
The fleet does not have to be excessively large like the US Navy or Regia Marine, but sufficient to open a passage for themselves.
That is, a great many destroyers and frigates, supported by a few cruisers, and little submarines. All covered by the Marine Air Force from land.

Think of it as a healthy paranoia induced by the fall in 1939.

the puppetization of Poland by the USSR and Stalin or the WAllies abandoment of Poland to the USSR which then resulted in its puppetization ?
Both, for the Poles it makes little difference. Although with the second choice, we have a sense of betrayal. Because of which we are not only broken but feel potrayed like trash, cheated and then screwed over a couple of times. Hence I say cold approach to ex-allies.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: ATP

ATP

Well-known member
Well, I can fill in something there myself, but I would have to get a more strictly defined framework so that I would know what I can and cannot do.

As for suggestions, mainly in Poland

1. militarization, total militarization. The army itself should be about 400k soldiers. A sizable air force, and a fleet sufficient to carve out a passage to the Danish Straits and close the USSR Baltic Fleet in the ports.

2 Reprivatization, any seized property whose owners are alive goes back to them. For example, the Polish candy company E.Wendel, the pre-war owner Jan Wendel is still alive, he died only in 1960 in Warsaw, he will surely strive to get his company back. BTW they make very good candy.
Reclaiming estates by the landed gentry (here you can do it with the help of Karol Stefan Hasburg, the last private owner of Zywiec Polish brewery as well as the Zywiec estates i.e. agricultural property), unless the owners were murdered then sell directly to peasants. Liquidation of PGRs (State Farms, the equivalent of Kolkhozes) and distribution of land to peasants or former owners (Though surely some of them are in fact peasants).

3. development based on the Polish middle class, promoting Polish culture and language. Creating historical propaganda films immortalizing Polish victories over both Germans (like OTL) and Russians. Attempting to assimilate Poland's remaining national minorities. Certainly, the nationalists will seek to destroy Pilsudski by making him as insignificant as possible, even if it means lying about him.

4 A state program of re-emigration, Free Poland will seek to bring back all the forced emigrants after World War II, including the generals of the Polish Armed Forces in the West, giving them due honor. BTW Bear Wojtek also counts as a Corporal in the Polish Army.

5. balanced and cold relations with former allies and occupiers. Nationalists are more politically realistic, or at least they consider themselves so. They will maintain relations with the West, but there will be no greater love in this. Certainly, the British and French will be treated firmly in the background. The Americans more positively but without much warmth, but certainly Polish intelligence will be strongly paranoid about any foreign influence including the US.

6. And the all-encompassing Polish intelligence and counterintelligence will be ready to do whatever is necessary to keep any superpower away from Poland as well as to influence it. The mysterious disappearances of students proposing more progressive ideas should be obvious.

1.Indeed.Buy swedish J.35 Draken fighter,it could work from short airfields or even roads.And,except army,also 2-3M of local militias,which would have rifles with ammo in their houses.Finland during cold war had 0,5M.

2.Yes,Wedel should come back to owners.But,repriwatization for those who do not supported either german or soviets.
There were not many of such creatures,but they still existed.

3.Yes,middle class instead of corpo.And movies,too.In OTL we did very good "Pharaoh",here it could be 2-3 such movies per year.
Destroing Piłsudzki myth - easily done,just show how he resigned as commander 12.8.1920 and go to his lover.

4.That,and poles from soviet union.

5.Yes,do not taking sides.USA helped here - after giving us to soviets for nothing.So,no reason foe gratitude.

6.Yes,leaders of would-be-1968 would vanish.

But,more important,show all massgraves in Poland,filled by germans,soviets or ukrainians,so there would be no "polish death camp" shit there.
Germans here are soviet owned,so they do not start shit about "polish death camps"

P.S In OTL we build rocket,and stopped when soviets forbid us.Now,we could continue.
 
Last edited:

Batrix2070

RON/PLC was a wonderful country.
easily done,just show how he resigned as commander 12.8.1920 and go to his lover.
In fact, there was nothing of the sort, Pilsudski submitted his resignation to Prime Minister Witos to use this in the worst case of events for Poland to remove a commander disliked by the West and put all the blame on him. And this his "mistress" and future wife was he met for a short while. After which he was still on the same day to visit the troops that were to lead the strike from above the Wieprz River. This time when he was "not in command" is in fact a fiction. He was simply doing the work of the Commander-in-Chief, the plan was implemented and his job was only to raise morale and reduce disputes between commanders. Rozwadowski was simply carrying out his orders, according to the plan that the entire Staff had developed. This is the job of the Chief of Staff, to develop and implement the plan approved by the Commander-in-Chief.


The problem is that the nationalists could not and cannot understand this. For the simple reason that they consider Pilsudski to be the cause of disaster for Poland and the one who snatched control of Poland from them with his actions. Although in my opinion, they asked for it themselves. They allowed themselves to be defeated like children by one sly man from Sulejówka who, unlike them, was not afraid to act directly. This is the problem of the nationalists in my opinion, they can't sometimes play like Pilsudski va bank, because they can't think like a soldier thinks. And in war one takes risks, and only he who takes risks wins the war.

But as you say, they will use this very argument to sling mud at Pilsudski on principle. In a sense, this will be irotic, because surely after a few decades, in the 21st century, someone will write a book on why Poles were lied to about Pilsudski for decades. And that in fact Rozwadowski was not the most important person and without Pilsudski this war would not have been won.
 
Last edited:

ATP

Well-known member
In fact, there was nothing of the sort, Pilsudski submitted his resignation to Prime Minister Witos to use this in the worst case of events for Poland to remove a commander disliked by the West and put all the blame on him. And this his "mistress" and future wife was he met for a short while. After which he was still on the same day to visit the troops that were to lead the strike from above the Wieprz River. This time when he was "not in command" is in fact a fiction. He was simply doing the work of the Commander-in-Chief, the plan was implemented and his job was only to raise morale and reduce disputes between commanders. Rozwadowski was simply carrying out his orders, according to the plan that the entire Staff had developed. This is the job of the Chief of Staff, to develop and implement the plan approved by the Commander-in-Chief.


The problem is that the nationalists could not and cannot understand this. For the simple reason that they consider Pilsudski to be the cause of disaster for Poland and the one who snatched control of Poland from them with his actions. Although in my opinion, they asked for it themselves. They allowed themselves to be defeated like children by one sly man from Sulejówka who, unlike them, was not afraid to act directly. This is the problem of the nationalists in my opinion, they can't sometimes play like Pilsudski va bank, because they can't think like a soldier thinks. And in war one takes risks, and only he who takes risks wins the war.

But as you say, they will use this very argument to sling mud at Pilsudski on principle. In a sense, this will be irotic, because surely after a few decades, in the 21st century, someone will write a book on why Poles were lied to about Pilsudski for decades. And that in fact Rozwadowski was not the most important person and without Pilsudski this war would not have been won.

He go to his soldiers - 15 or 16.08.20.Nobody knew what he was doing before that,except meeting lover.
Rozwadowski was carring out plan made by himself.
And,15.08.20,it was him and Haller who ordered counter-attack.
So,Piłsudzki was not needed to win - they did it without him.
And they do not fear,that enemy could hurt them.

Which is half of problem.

Bigger Piłsudzki mistake was destroing polish air forces and armour.We have money for 12-year plan which would gave us 2300 planes ,5 mechanized dyvicions and 20 battalion of tanks.
Piłsudzki throw it out,spend money as he wished every year,and,as a result,in 1939 we had 392 planes,2 mechanized brigades,and equivalent of 4 tank battalions.

Moneys were the same - but spend in stupid way.

We really do not need to defend Piłsudzki now - becouse fake legends would not help us.
 

Batrix2070

RON/PLC was a wonderful country.
He go to his soldiers - 15 or 16.08.20.
Division reports and photos say otherwise.
Nobody knew what he was doing before that,except meeting lover.
and even if that were true, he didn't really have anything else to do anyway. He had already done his job.
Rozwadowski was carring out plan made by himself.
Because that's what the Chief of Staff's job is? Developing plans and implementing them was Rozwadowski's job. Pilsudski painfully learned in the Kiev operation that he was not suitable for this job, which is why he did not try to replace Rozwadowski then.
In fact, Pilsudski's only task was to toss around an idea, watching to see what Rozwadowski and others would make of it.

Listening to their arguments, moderating their disagreements and then choosing the plan they would carry out. This was Pilsudski's contribution to the Battle of Warsaw, and praise for it. He should do nothing more, because it is not the role of the Commander-in-Chief to develop plans and tease them into reality.

Ferdinad Foch or Dwight Eisenhower also did not become famous for being the ones who developed plans and put them into practice. Such Eisenhower during D-Day was reading a book to himself, because he had nothing to do anyway. He did his job. He might as well have been with his family as Pilsudski was.

And,15.08.20,it was him and Haller who ordered counter-attack.
Because they led the battle? The Commander-in-Chief gave the appropriate orders to the operational officers, that is, in this case Rozwadowski and Haller, and these officers, based on a general order of what to do, carried out the plan approved by Pilsudski. That is, they just gave the order to counterattack.
So,Piłsudzki was not needed to win
He was, without the one who knew how to reconcile, without the one on whose shoulders the responsibility for choosing the plan and its consequences rested. It was Rozwadowski who could only kiss own hand. Besides, if they had committed arbitrariness, they were the ones who would be punished.
they did it without him.
Here Pilsudski had and continues to have a significant advantage over Rydz. He realized that this is what the lower ranks of command existed for, to be relied upon in command. He did not try, as Rydz did, to decide on battalions, did not strive after the humiliating defeat at Kiev to take command from individual generals. Why the hell would he take away Rozwadowski's role? That they later tried to make either one or the other the sole authors of the victory at Warsaw is another matter.
We have money for 12-year plan
Well, yes, we had money. For purchases, but what about maintenance, and most importantly, what to maintain with? You can order yourself 1,000 tanks, but without logistics and plants that will supply it, it will be useless. Because the Second Republic could afford to constantly import the necessary components from abroad.
2300 planes
Looking at the time of the plan, which is 12 it means that the plan was to last from 1926 to 1938. Cool, the problem is that a good portion of these planes would have been obsolete by 1936 and it would have taken another Plan 12 to fix it!
ATP, those are the days when aircraft generation changed every 4 years. By the time this order would have been realized, these ordered aircraft would have been mostly obsolete. God forbid it would be like OLT, i.e. only a generation backwards and not two or more.
mechanized dyvicions
Yes, because Poland just happened to produce a sufficient number of mechanized vehicles and tanks. Or that we could afford to import most likely French, because it was only from Pilsudski that the planning of our own designs began in earnest and not purchases from abroad. I have read a number of studies on Polish attempts at mechanization between the wars, all of which were ambitious, but very quickly collided with the fact that more money was needed, and when the right equipment was bought, it turned out that it was not suitable for Polish conditions, so it was cheaper to design and build the right equipment in Poland.
20 battalion of tanks.
Mostly FT-17s, because tanks began to appear in earnest only in the second half of the 1930s. And as we know from experience, the larger the unit, the more difficult it is to modernize it
Piłsudzki throw it out
Just because he happened to be at the time. I guarantee you that if there had been no May coup, someone else would have dismissed this plan as just as viable as the Navy's. The one with two battleships, 18 cruisers and other toys we could afford.
spend money as he wished every year
Honestly, it gave better results than sticking to this "real" plan. A plan that would become obsolete as early as halfway through its duration.
,and,as a result,in 1939 we had 392 planes,2 mechanized brigades,and equivalent of 4 tank battalions.
This 12-year plan, de facto, would have achieved the same number, or perhaps even more although it would have very quickly become apparent that an immediate upgrade was needed. Although, as history proved, what we really needed we didn't have. And that something was decent communications, that is, enough telephone cable and radio stations. Ironically, that 1939 preparations were beginning for a proper factory, which was to go into production August 1940.
We really do not need to defend Piłsudzki now - becouse fake legends would not help us.
I agree that we don't have to defend Pilsudski, because no one has to defend him. He defends himself well enough, perhaps much less well than his fanatics would like, but enough to be another brick of the Polish Arms. Let's not make him a legend, because he was also a man who made mistakes. But let's not make a caricature of him because we just don't like him. Rozwadowski is not at all as good as many opponents of Pilsudski's legacy would like. (Mainly nationalists who dislike Pilsudski more than their leader. I know something about this from my own experience.)
 
Last edited:

TheRejectionist

TheRejectionist
@Batrix2070



Which of this two is supposedely the owner of the beer company ?

Because the guy you are talking me about was apparently dead already in 1933 ...



Well, I can fill in something there myself, but I would have to get a more strictly defined framework so that I would know what I can and cannot do.

As for suggestions, mainly in Poland

1. militarization, total militarization. The army itself should be about 400k soldiers. A sizable air force, and a fleet sufficient to carve out a passage to the Danish Straits and close the USSR Baltic Fleet in the ports.

2 Reprivatization, any seized property whose owners are alive goes back to them. For example, the Polish candy company E.Wendel, the pre-war owner Jan Wendel is still alive, he died only in 1960 in Warsaw, he will surely strive to get his company back. BTW they make very good candy.
Reclaiming estates by the landed gentry (here you can do it with the help of Karol Stefan Hasburg, the last private owner of Zywiec Polish brewery as well as the Zywiec estates i.e. agricultural property), unless the owners were murdered then sell directly to peasants. Liquidation of PGRs (State Farms, the equivalent of Kolkhozes) and distribution of land to peasants or former owners (Though surely some of them are in fact peasants).

3. development based on the Polish middle class, promoting Polish culture and language. Creating historical propaganda films immortalizing Polish victories over both Germans (like OTL) and Russians. Attempting to assimilate Poland's remaining national minorities. Certainly, the nationalists will seek to destroy Pilsudski by making him as insignificant as possible, even if it means lying about him.

4 A state program of re-emigration, Free Poland will seek to bring back all the forced emigrants after World War II, including the generals of the Polish Armed Forces in the West, giving them due honor. BTW Bear Wojtek also counts as a Corporal in the Polish Army.

5. balanced and cold relations with former allies and occupiers. Nationalists are more politically realistic, or at least they consider themselves so. They will maintain relations with the West, but there will be no greater love in this. Certainly, the British and French will be treated firmly in the background. The Americans more positively but without much warmth, but certainly Polish intelligence will be strongly paranoid about any foreign influence including the US.

6. And the all-encompassing Polish intelligence and counterintelligence will be ready to do whatever is necessary to keep any superpower away from Poland as well as to influence it. The mysterious disappearances of students proposing more progressive ideas should be obvious.
 

Batrix2070

RON/PLC was a wonderful country.
This one, I forgot his name is identical to his father's. It was Karol Hasburg Jr. who owned Żywiec. The worst thing is that his son is also named Karol, but his middle name is like his grandfather's, which is Stefan. Hardly original.

Charles Albert Brewery
Dying in 1933, Archduke. Karol Stefan bequeathed the brewery to his son Karol Olbracht. At that time, the brewery produced five basic types of beer:

After the outbreak of World War II in 1939. Germany occupied Zywiec, renaming it the German Saybusch. The archduke was saved from death by the intercession of the Swedish and Italian king with the highest Nazi authorities. Charles Olbracht was thrown into prison, and the brewery was taken over by the Third Reich. It was then given the official name Beskidenbrauerei Saybusch. Production at the brewery was maintained, however, the beer was mainly intended for the German military. The primary beer produced in Zywiec at the time was Saybuscher Quell, similar in composition to Zywiec Zdrój. Also brewed for the German army and police were Beskiden-Gold light beer and small quantities of Porter, Ale and Export Dunkel. Although the retreating Nazi army destroyed almost all major facilities in the city, the brewery survived. Although the Germans took away some machinery and equipment, partially burned the archives, blew up the railroad siding and planted explosive charges under the brewery buildings, however, thanks to the self-sacrificing attitude of the brewery workers, they did not manage to detonate them[3].

You have a quote from the Polish Żywiec Brewery website.

https://pl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Browar_w_Żywcu

And here's a link to this Brewery.
 
Last edited:

Batrix2070

RON/PLC was a wonderful country.
FOUND THIS !
Yes that's right, the last Polish Hasburg died without an heir 2018. It's a bit of a shame, especially since he no longer recovered his property. Anyway, this is what happened to many Polish noble families, they died childless in exile. You can prevent this by re-emigration. Hence the state re-emigration program.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: ATP

ATP

Well-known member
Division reports and photos say otherwise.

and even if that were true, he didn't really have anything else to do anyway. He had already done his job.

Because that's what the Chief of Staff's job is? Developing plans and implementing them was Rozwadowski's job. Pilsudski painfully learned in the Kiev operation that he was not suitable for this job, which is why he did not try to replace Rozwadowski then.
In fact, Pilsudski's only task was to toss around an idea, watching to see what Rozwadowski and others would make of it.

Listening to their arguments, moderating their disagreements and then choosing the plan they would carry out. This was Pilsudski's contribution to the Battle of Warsaw, and praise for it. He should do nothing more, because it is not the role of the Commander-in-Chief to develop plans and tease them into reality.

Ferdinad Foch or Dwight Eisenhower also did not become famous for being the ones who developed plans and put them into practice. Such Eisenhower during D-Day was reading a book to himself, because he had nothing to do anyway. He did his job. He might as well have been with his family as Pilsudski was.


Because they led the battle? The Commander-in-Chief gave the appropriate orders to the operational officers, that is, in this case Rozwadowski and Haller, and these officers, based on a general order of what to do, carried out the plan approved by Pilsudski. That is, they just gave the order to counterattack.

He was, without the one who knew how to reconcile, without the one on whose shoulders the responsibility for choosing the plan and its consequences rested. It was Rozwadowski who could only kiss own hand. Besides, if they had committed arbitrariness, they were the ones who would be punished.

Here Pilsudski had and continues to have a significant advantage over Rydz. He realized that this is what the lower ranks of command existed for, to be relied upon in command. He did not try, as Rydz did, to decide on battalions, did not strive after the humiliating defeat at Kiev to take command from individual generals. Why the hell would he take away Rozwadowski's role? That they later tried to make either one or the other the sole authors of the victory at Warsaw is another matter.

Well, yes, we had money. For purchases, but what about maintenance, and most importantly, what to maintain with? You can order yourself 1,000 tanks, but without logistics and plants that will supply it, it will be useless. Because the Second Republic could afford to constantly import the necessary components from abroad.

Looking at the time of the plan, which is 12 it means that the plan was to last from 1926 to 1938. Cool, the problem is that a good portion of these planes would have been obsolete by 1936 and it would have taken another Plan 12 to fix it!
ATP, those are the days when aircraft generation changed every 4 years. By the time this order would have been realized, these ordered aircraft would have been mostly obsolete. God forbid it would be like OLT, i.e. only a generation backwards and not two or more.

Yes, because Poland just happened to produce a sufficient number of mechanized vehicles and tanks. Or that we could afford to import most likely French, because it was only from Pilsudski that the planning of our own designs began in earnest and not purchases from abroad. I have read a number of studies on Polish attempts at mechanization between the wars, all of which were ambitious, but very quickly collided with the fact that more money was needed, and when the right equipment was bought, it turned out that it was not suitable for Polish conditions, so it was cheaper to design and build the right equipment in Poland.

Mostly FT-17s, because tanks began to appear in earnest only in the second half of the 1930s. And as we know from experience, the larger the unit, the more difficult it is to modernize it

Just because he happened to be at the time. I guarantee you that if there had been no May coup, someone else would have dismissed this plan as just as viable as the Navy's. The one with two battleships, 18 cruisers and other toys we could afford.

Honestly, it gave better results than sticking to this "real" plan. A plan that would become obsolete as early as halfway through its duration.

This 12-year plan, de facto, would have achieved the same number, or perhaps even more although it would have very quickly become apparent that an immediate upgrade was needed. Although, as history proved, what we really needed we didn't have. And that something was decent communications, that is, enough telephone cable and radio stations. Ironically, that 1939 preparations were beginning for a proper factory, which was to go into production August 1940.

I agree that we don't have to defend Pilsudski, because no one has to defend him. He defends himself well enough, perhaps much less well than his fanatics would like, but enough to be another brick of the Polish Arms. Let's not make him a legend, because he was also a man who made mistakes. But let's not make a caricature of him because we just don't like him. Rozwadowski is not at all as good as many opponents of Pilsudski's legacy would like. (Mainly nationalists who dislike Pilsudski more than their leader. I know something about this from my own experience.)

1.Piłsudzki memories say,that till 16.08.20 he did notching.
2.It was true,and he resigned from his job.Taking it again 17.8.20 from Witos.Poor idiot go to Bereza for that later.
3.Rozwadowski still have his job,and did it.Piłsudzki resigned,so could not be either blamed or praised for plan implemented when he resigned.
4.Problem is,Piłsudzki was no more Commander.
5.Piłsudzki know how to reconcile? say to general Zagórski.
6.Problem is - since he resigned,there was not his role at all.
7.Valid questions.Still,it should be much more then we had in 1939
8.They would not buy new 2300 planes each 5 years,only form new dyvisions every year.2300 would be in 1938,before it would be less.They would replace 400-500 planes per year.
Which mean,that older planes in 1939 would be from 1934.
Still better then OTL.
And,we would have 800-900 planes from 1938-39,compared to 36 in 1939.
9.They could then just buy american trucks.When Piłsudzki buyed italian shit,not better or worst then french.And,it was Piłsudzki who killed polish private bus industry.

10.Or R.35.Even Fiat 3000 would be still good enough in 1939.
11.Navy plan was fake.Real now had 2 light cruisers and 6 destroyers.And,in that case,Piłsudzki partially made it/4 destroyers/
12.When spending according to Piłsudzki whims mean,that in 1935 we had no modern planes,tanks,or AT and AA guns.
13.Yes,we do not have radios.Why? becouse Sanacja wanted it made in state manufacturies,like trucks.In state ruled by people who at least partially supported free market it would not happen
14.He made his myth and get his place in Wawel,but for what exactly? in 1914 he tried to made uprising to help germans conqer France.
Later he do not agree with them,so was keep in good house with german servant when german children was dying from hunger.
In 1920 he did nothing,in 1926 made putch and fucked both economy and military.

Well,in 1919 he saved Poland - when thanks to him german soldiers who do not heed their officers anymore agreed to go through Poland in peace ,and even leaved guns for us.

For that he should be praised.
 
Question Would the Karabinek-granatnik wz.1960 still exist in this Poland EVEN IF it got rid of Soviet presence and influence in 1956 ?

TheRejectionist

TheRejectionist
@Batrix2070 @ATP

@Buba why don't you chime in as well?

Karabinek-granatnik_wz.1960.jpg


If you guys know of any Polish variant or other military stuff before 1956 or slightly after please let me know!
 

Buba

A total creep
I confess to knowing next to nothing on the subject, but I'd expect the Karabinek-granatnik wz.1960 (which needed special blank ammo to work properly, and was capable of breaking foldable stocks) to fade away regardless of Soviet influence.
The grandchild of the Tromboncino:
the M79:
and all its underslung derivates/clones showed the way to go, i.e. a dedicated launcher for c.40mm shells.

As to other Polish weapons in that time frame, there is the dog called the RAK or PM wz.63. Ten times more complicated than the Czech weapons doing the same thing.
versus
 
Last edited:
Another series of drafts for the next update/chapters

TheRejectionist

TheRejectionist
FEARFUL FIFTIES


Newly sworn in President Stassen's reaction to the list was nothing short of surprising shock.


<< What is more miraculous ? That we have a list of who our now enemy has or the fact they managed to get so many ? >>


The Director of Central Intelligence who had substituted Dulles after the fiascos in Guatemala and Iran, Charles Pearre Cabell, was cautiously proud of the list. Twenty agents died for this little information.


<< The information however >> noted Stassen << is of little use to us, except give us motivation to make Congress see we need a proper budget to bridge the gap ! >>


Everybody agreed on it and a draft was made to ask Congress for a billion dollars or slightly less to be given to the newborn American space program, as well as the Central Intelligence Agency, with Cabell being encouraged to draw plans for infiltration into the Soviet Union. He probably knew what those plans would be. “Hiring as contractors former Wehrmact and Schutzstaffel. As well as their Eastern European Quislings!” and he would be proven right later on.


Someone knocked on the door :


<< President Stassen ? >>

His secretary.

<< Yes ? >>

It was his secretary.

<< Attorney General Thomas Dewey is here to see you >>

<< Let him in >>

Dewey was visibly stressed and it looked he was containing an outburst as furious as righteous :

<< Mister President, remember when you and Eisenhower asked me, before the election, to look into Fidel Castro’s opponents here and there in Cuba ? >>

<< I do. What can you tell me ? >>

<< Simply put…it is an excrement show ! >>

Stassen remained silently puzzled :

<< President Stassen, many of them in question are connected with big corporations, organized crimes or even worse, both ! >>

<< Any examples ? >>

<< Meyer Lansky of the National Crime Syndicate; he is “upset” because the Cuban government coalition of Fidel Castro's 26th of July Movement has nationalized not only his hotel-casinos but and can be operated only by Cuban with gambling’s going to the general and with the proof the Cuban president has given Eisenhower during his visit here a couple of months ago, I have enough evidence to jail him. It …infuriates me…that lobbyists, criminals and congressmen ask us to… “do something” to protect alleged American interests!>>


<< You may proceed as you wish with no strings attached Dewey. Many call to suspend them from Inter-American Treaty of Reciprocal Assistance but I rather not, they are in our garden and neighbors and certainly do not wish to scare them into going into the Soviet’s arms because some gangster or crooked company lost their treasures. >>


<< Thanks Har…mister President >>


Asking him to become Attorney General was perhaps the best choice. He will clean up the streets, thought the now president.

But now he had more pressing matters : meeting with the new Italian and Polish ambassadors.


Soon as the Tadeusz Bielecki’s government had begun reprivatization, with all seized property whose owners did not collaborate with either Nazi Germany or the USSR and were alive going back to them such as candy company E.Wendel, who was returned to its pre-war owner Jan Wendel, followed by a program of reclamation of estates by the landed gentry, one of the first of this operation was the last private owner of Zywiec Polish brewery as well as his Zywiec estates , former archduke Karol Albert Habsbursko-Lotaryński , reclaimed by his son Karol Stefan Maksymilian Ferdynand Narcyz Maria Habsbursko – Lotaryński due to his father psycho-physical condition being abysmal since he had taken refuge in Sweden due to the torture by Nazi occupiers.

a program of total militarization which projected an estimate of 400 thousand active soldiers and it was speculated they wanted to achieve one million or more in a decade while at the same time they were planning for having a sizeable air force and a fleet (hopefully for them) to be able to carve out a seapath in case of war with the Comintern, because it bordered only two friendly neighbors : the restored Czechoslovak Republic and the Kingdom of Hungary, the latter who still had disputes over Őrvidék ( Burgenland ) with the Germans and Kárpátalja (Zakarpatska) with the Soviet Union and would be of little help if push come to shove; they were also in the talks to acquire Ambrosini Sagittario and the

Captain Stefan Kenneth Janson (born Kazimierz Stefan Januszewski) was a Polish-born British firearms designer who worked for RSAF Enfield. One of a number of Polish immigrants who worked for RSAF Enfiel



Kryptę


@USSEssex @RazNaRok @kekw3 @Matej I am writing an alternate history, part of this story is most of central Europe never being liberated by the Soviets and Poland freeing itself after a brutal repression. I tagged you guys because I have no insight or personal acquaintance that can help with speculating military projects of Central Europe. What do you guys so far ?

I haven’t written anything on Czechoslovakia because the point of divergence is in 1948 and imagining the story of a country when it’s that soon the “change” is rather difficult since I lack the context



THE SCORNFUL SIXTIES


In the aftermath of the Second World War, the Anglo-French Empires had fallen into severe debt and supposedly weren’t able to manage to keep it. However, they were kept on life support thanks to the Eisenhower-Stassen administrations since both presidents were vehemently opposed to upset (yet)the balance of power and buffer the European hegemonies offered, but there were some issues which were delicate.

The first the two nations of the Low Countries , the Netherlands and Belgium, the first had seen its jewel of the empire, the Dutch East Indies, going independent and it sat in exile in the newborn “Kingdom of Suriname, Antilles and New Guinea” , basically a Dutch speaking Anglo-Franco-American co-dominium of sorts in all but name meanwhile the second was in a more precarious position with its “only” “territory” being the Belgian Congo, with discussions of an “union” with the BGIE (Belgian Government In Exile), which come into fruition after many concessions were made to minor independence leaders, the European settlers and exiles and the various Belgian companies, with the compromise of an United Nations supervision, with Baudoin as Sovereign King-Regent of Congo and Ruanda-Urundi, gaining the utter resentment of the Congolese population, who were dealt as swiftly as possible by Belgium's prime collaborateur, newly appointed Defence Minister Joseph-Désiré Mobutu, personally seeking to it and crushing with the help of foreign mercenaries and the Force Publique swelling with former German veterans, raising many concerns with neighboring Portugal and the United Kingdom for that. Stassen, again, wanted to keep the equilibrium but did so with grinned teeth and clenched fists as he would become more worried with the homefront due to the simple fact that the Lukewarm War had essentially become a sitting “tech” war where he and Mikoyan would menacingly stare at each other but except the Soviet First Secretary announcing support for Indonesia and supplying Jakarta with large amounts of modern and Great Patriotic War leftover weaponry, nothing was done , unless someone counts Rome’s 1960 Summer Olympics (Italian: Giochi Olimpici estivi del 1960) and the following Winter Olympics of the same year as geopolitical clashes between the two blocs, with the Soviet Union coming ahead of the United States, as it wasn’t enough boxer and gold medal winner Cassius Clay (later to be known as Muhammah Ali) used the occasion to spoke against the racial injustices occurring in his country, because there were still tensions arising between Black and White Americans, who were left head scratching with the Republican president due to his support for Civil Rights but at the same time supporting the (mainly) Anglo-French colonial territories around the world, just as when it backed British support for a secessionist movement in Natal after the former Union of South Africa had turned into a republic through referendum ; it didn’t make it easier Stassen had a serious problems when first the United States was technologically humiliated the next year with the first human orbital spaceflight in history of the Vostok 1 by Soviet cosmonaut Yuri Alekseyevich Gagarin on 12 April 1961 and then on May 14th 1961 Freedom Riders were burned alive at the outskirts of Anniston, Alabama and race riots broke out around the nation and the National Guard had to be deployed in several states but especially the Deep South as the widespread violence engulfed those areas, with massive retaliations on both sides and pushing “Stassenite'' Republicans further into the Civil Rights camp and making the Democrats furtherly reactionary for the time being, albeit with few notable exceptions such as John Fitzgerald Kennedy and (privately) George Armistead Smathers; it wouldn't be until November, just after the Ole Miss riots, that the situation would calm down, however another problem arose : the attempted invasion of Goa by Boseist India. Subhas Chandra Bose had made it clear since he had “liberated” most of India from the British but was still as zealous for a total ouster of European forces from the subcontinent and that included the Portuguese, who had stood idle in their neutrality in World War II; the Netaji thought the United States and the PACCATO alliance would dare intervene for the small Lusitanian enclaves, but when the Lisbon government invoked Article 5 it was a very short (mostly aero-naval) war where the USSR brokered a ceasefire by sheer nuclear menace, with the United States and Portugal meeting in Rome, Italy with Indian representatives, where a “peace” was strong armed to Bose in December 1962 who had to accept in perpetuity the Portuguese presence, in turn bringing India closer to the USSR, which was having problem of its own, because approximately twenty percent of the German population had fled (and similar figures were being reported in the Beneluxian puppet state) so the COMINTERN solution consisted in the building a 1143 kilometer series of border walls, officially with the justification of “defensive structuralization and construction against potential capitalist oppressive aggression”.

Stassen watched in shock together with his PACCATO partner-collegue when it was being noticed when they were building walls in the Italian-German border and the Danish-German border as well and rapidly so. The Iron Curtain was going up and had enclosed the Low Countries and Germany into total isolation safe from COMINTERN allies.

Many newspapers both domestic and foreign domestic, safe for France, criticized the U.S. president for its inaction but as his supporters and public relations department pointed out to his critics : “do you rather be comfortable, fed and healthy or you do want to be the exact contrary in order to stop the construction of a Communist wall?” implying the theory of mutually assured destruction if they challenged Premier Mikoyan over the construction of the wall.


I will probably had bigger fish to fry.


He did in fact.


In March 1963, retired US Marine Lee Harvey Oswald used the alias "A. Hidell" to make a mail-order purchase of a secondhand 6.5 mm caliber Carcano rifle for $29.9 and had purchased a .38 Smith & Wesson Model 10 revolver with the same method, both of which were used to kill retired U.S. Major General Edwin Walker, on April 10, 1963 as Walker sat at a desk in his Dallas home.

The case felt like a tinderbox, because the John Birch Society immediately accused the US government of allowing the murder of a patriot to happen on American sovereign soil while on the other hand many organization Civil Rights activists tried to appease public opinion by divulging Walker’s reputation as an outspoken segregationist, who had been relieved of his command of the 24th Division of the U.S. Army in the Saar Protectorate for distributing right-wing literature to his troops and who was arrested on insurrection, seditious conspiracy, and other charges and temporarily held in a mental institution on orders of Attorney General Dewey.

Demonstrations and riots started almost immediately and Lee Harvey Oswald was postponed multiple times due to continuously growing tensions and if having internal instability wasn’t enough, the Lukewarm War was about to witness its first tumultuous period, with the homefront being rocked on September 15, 1963 when white supremacist terrorists bombed the 16th Street Baptist Church of Birmingham, Alabama, killing dozens and injuring hundreds


Sukarno’s Indonesia had started a campaign of infiltration against Malaysia, Singapore,Brunei and the Dutch exiles’ Territory of New Guinea with support from the People’s Republic of (North West) China, the Soviet Union and other COMINTERN countries in logistics, supplies and “volunteers”, with many Indonesian “battalions” were entirely made up of Norwegians, Baltics, Beneluxians, Germans, Soviets and Chinese. Stassen, despite his own and his government reservations, drafted many young boys into the Army and unfortunately, as he had predicted, did not ease tensions, but at least he showed he wasn’t “a pinko or a softie on Communism”

The Soviet Union, to support Sukarno and his Communist proxies and him initiated the month 1963 with the Moskalyov DSB-LK long-range supersonic strategic bomber over the Strait of Malacca just as they were sending tonnes both leftover and new weapons from the Democratic Republic of Germany and the People’s Republic of Benelux, consecutively Stassen followed this move

by authorizing the usage of

with more investment on research, defense and education to “one up” Moscow, unfortunately this included, due to the influence of both Republican and Democrat McCarthyites to send military advisors to Malaysia, Singapore, Brunei,Australia, New Zealand and Canada which in turn turned into also to send economic financial investment to those countries, as the drafted military “advisors” continued to exponentially increase as the months went by the liberal Republican president did not wish for an actual escalated intervention but at some point

While the liberal faction of the Republican faction was firmly cemented, the conservative side of Stassen’s party wasn’t totally satisfied and issued a veiled threat of siding with the Democrats in the last year if he wouldn’t concede on a Conservative Republican ticket in the upcoming 1964 election. While initially opposed to this threatening proposal, Harold Stassen the soon to be ex President agreed on supporting Goldwater with the compromise they would accept Rockfeller as VP.







NOTE : This a very SPECULATIVE part of mine due to time constraints, university schedules and lack of monetary resources as well as access to sources that are either in the four languages I know.


1968 :



Many people asked how the Soviet Union had managed to reach the moon before the United States, the allegedly greatest country of the world ; many would point out of the almost complete success of Operation Osoaviakhim over two decades which resulted in the USSR acquiring many German experts that did marginally accelerate the progress in many fields of science

Aleksandr Ignatyevich Shargey (1) was a Soviet Ukranian engineer,theoretician, mathematician, Great Patrioc War veteran and visionary pioneer of astronautics and spaceflight in the early 20th century, who developed the first known lunar orbit rendezvous (LOR).

Initially he was just an advisor on the Sputnik 1 program but several sources credit his wise insight to having contributed to making the satellite a reality much earlier than it was predicted initially. It is speculated he would have been involved in the VOSTOK 1 program as well but it is unclear why he wasn’t ; however a year later he was called for a secret meeting between him and Mikoyan who wanted him to report on the space programs of the USSR and when informed of them, Shargey replied :


<< Comrade Premier Mikoyan, why do we have space programs and not a space program ? >>


<< What do you mean, comrade Shargey? >>


<< It seems at first glance from you are referring to me of a situation where’s the lack of coordination and waste of resources, but I should verify in person before making any definitive conclusion >>


In his personal diaries Shargey reported he expected a Stalinist response from Mikoyan and that he would end up in a gulag (again) at best or shot in the head for pointing out an obvious flaw in the Soviet system, but “luckily for me, Mikoyan wasn’t as intransigent as his predecessor and wanted results, as long as said result didn’t compromised him publicly, in front of the Party or both.”


<< I want you to make a report on our space programs… if your conclusion does coincide with what you just said, we might have more to discuss >>


Aleksandr Ignatyevich Shargey was put to work immediately the next day and secretly “toured” the various programs with Artyom Ivanovich Mikoyan, the brother of the premier, who believed the space programs could also give contributions to his “sector” as well.


When he returned to the Premier’s office, not only he had proof of what he had said previously but also that uselessly competing and bickering against one another and that “no amount of help, money or German experts would get us further… the capitalist United States will humiliate us in less than a decade unless something is done”. Mikoyan had Valentin Glushko, Mikhail Yangel, Vladimir Chelomei and Sergei Korolev convened in his office and they were submissively scolded into collaborating rather “wrecking” each other and they would be under Shargey’s supervision. The Osvobozhdeniye program, the unified space program, would be started immediately.

Aleksandr Ignatyevich Shargey correctly predicted they could tail the United States’ program and successfully precede them in the “liberation of space” if the program was well funded and the resources located where they needed to be; Shargey, despite being Jewish, was also more of a pragmatist and realist compared to the colleagues who were subordinated to him and noticed there were some gaps in the Soviet research and with “heavy heart” recruited a former member of the Nazi Party and Allgemeine SS aerospace engineer and space architect Wernher Magnus Maximilian Freiherr von Braun as an “assistant collaborator on the Osvobozhdeniye program”; later, when the moon landing successfully went through and the cosmonaut team safely re-entered Earth, the German ex-Nazi was awarded both in the Soviet Union and his home country and used as a propaganda tool for the COMINTERN to prove that Communism could redeem the humanity of a former despicable individual.


The display of scientific advancement shocked and demoralized the United States and its allies, dooming Goldwater’s chances of re-election who would resign a week after the launch, leaving his office to Rockefeller.


  1. OTL Yuri Vasilyevich Kondratyuk https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yuri_Kondratyuk in our world he died/disappeared in 1942 during WW2
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top